Benchmarking transferability of SSL pretraining to same and different modality segmentation tasks

Self-supervised learning (SSL) is increasingly used in medical image analysis to reduce dependence on costly expert annotations by learning transferable representations from unlabeled data. However, SSL performance depends not only on model architecture, but also on whether the pretext task preserves information required by the downstream clinical objective. This review presents a task-oriented synthesis of SSL methods for medical imaging, focusing on how pretext-task design interacts with imaging modality, label availability, and downstream performance. We analyze 75 studies published from 2017 to 2025 and organize them into four paradigms: contrastive learning, non-contrastive and predictive learning, generative and reconstruction-based learning, and hybrid learning. Rather than cataloging methods chronologically, we examine how these paradigms support classification, segmentation, detection, reconstruction, and regression. The evidence suggests that no SSL strategy is universally optimal. Contrastive objectives generally encourage global discriminative representations and are well aligned with classification, but may underrepresent subtle or localized pathology. Spatial prediction, masked modeling, and reconstruction-based objectives better preserve anatomical structure and are often more suitable for segmentation and dense prediction. Hybrid methods can provide balanced representations, although they increase training complexity. Across modalities, SSL is most beneficial in low-label and few-shot regimes, but its effectiveness depends on modality-aware augmentation, pathology-preserving corruption, and clinically meaningful evaluation. We conclude with practical design guidelines and identify open challenges, including pathology-aware pretext tasks, resource-efficient training for high-dimensional data, and standardized evaluation protocols.

Although self-supervised pretraining is expected to learn broadly transferable representations, its effectiveness across imaging modalities substantially different from the pretraining domain, and on complex tumor-segmentation tasks, remains understudied. Evaluating CT-pretrained transformers on MRI rectal cancer segmentation, we identified two interacting failure modes in CT-to-MRI transfer: (a) inefficient token usage caused by zero-padding to match pretrained input dimensions, and (b) ineffective feature adaptation. We investigated these vulnerabilities using two primary CT-pretrained hierarchical shifted-window transformer backbones, SMIT and Swin UNETR, together with VoCo as a large-scale-pretrained supporting benchmark; these models differ in pretraining objectives and datasets. Mechanistic analysis leveraged an attention dilution index (ADI), an entropy-based metric quantifying attention diverted toward uninformative padding tokens, and centered kernel alignment (CKA) to measure feature reuse during MRI adaptation. ADI increased with zero-padding, while high feature reuse did not necessarily translate to improved downstream accuracy. To mitigate these issues, we introduced two interventions: a tumor-aware augmentation strategy to expand tumor appearance heterogeneity coverage, and an anisotropic cropping strategy to restore token efficiency. Fine-tuning with these strategies on identical rectal MRI datasets yielded detection rates of 91.1% (225/247) and 88.7% (219/247) for the primary SMIT and Swin UNETR backbones, with the supporting VoCo benchmark reaching 90.3% (223/247), demonstrating significantly improved robustness under CT-to-MRI transfer. This study is among the first to examine when pretrained transformers fail to transfer across imaging modalities and demonstrates how targeted mitigation strategies can systematically overcome cross-modality transfer limitations.

Masked image modeling (MIM) is a highly effective self-supervised learning (SSL) approach to extract useful feature representations from unannotated data. Predominantly used random masking methods make SSL less effective for medical images due to the contextual similarity of neighboring patches, leading to information leakage and SSL simplification. Hierarchical shifted window (Swin) transformer, a highly effective approach for medical images cannot use advanced masking methods as it lacks a global [CLS] token. Hence, we introduced an attention guided masking mechanism for Swin within a co-distillation learning framework to selectively mask semantically co-occurring and discriminative patches, to reduce information leakage and increase the difficulty of SSL pretraining. However, attention guided masking inevitably reduces the diversity of attention heads, which negatively impacts downstream task performance. To address this, we for the first time, integrate a noisy teacher into the co-distillation framework (termed DAGMaN) that performs attentive masking while preserving high attention head diversity. We demonstrate the capability of DAGMaN on multiple tasks including full- and few-shot lung nodule classification, immunotherapy outcome prediction, tumor segmentation, and unsupervised organs clustering.