A Van Trees Lower Bound for Fully Interactive Differentially Private Federated Learning
Authors: T. Tony Cai, Yicheng Li
Organizations: Department of Statistics and Data Science, The Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA. · KLATASDS-MOE, School of Statistics, East China Normal University, Shanghai, China.
Federated differentially private protocols can communicate over many adaptive rounds and reuse each client's local samples. Existing lower bound arguments for federated DP are often restricted to noninteractive protocols or fresh batch decompositions, so the fundamental information-theoretic limit of estimation under fully interactive protocols remains unknown. We establish a federated van Trees inequality for parameter estimation under squared \ell_2 loss from any complete public transcript satisfying a clientwise zCDP constraint at the sample level. A scalar trace form covers homogeneous experiments, while a matrix form preserves directional Fisher geometry in heterogeneous experiments where different clients are informative in different subspaces. Together with existing upper bounds for the corresponding problems, these results identify the minimax rates for various statistical problems including mean estimation, linear regression, nonparametric regression, and functional mean estimation over the full class of interactive public-transcript protocols. For these problems, arbitrary public interaction and repeated sample reuse do not improve the rate over simpler restricted protocols. The key technical ingredient in our paper is a contraction inequality for the Fisher information in the transcript: each client's contribution is bounded both by the Fisher information in its local experiment and by its total privacy budget.
Federated Learning is a leading framework for training ML and AI models collaboratively across numerous user devices or databases. We study the trade-offs among estimation accuracy, privacy constraints, and communication cost for differentially private (DP) federated M estimation. The two standard methods in the literature are FedAvg, which may suffer from high federation bias, and FedSGD, which can incur high communication cost. Aimed at improving accuracy at a reduced communication cost, we propose FedHybrid, which uses FedSGD starting with an improved initialization by the FedAvg estimator. We propose FedNewton, which averages local Newton iterations to reduce bias in FedAvg, achieving an estimation accuracy comparable to FedSGD with much fewer communication rounds when the number of clients grows sufficiently slowly. We establish finite sample upper bounds on the mean-squared error rates of the DP versions of these estimators as functions of the number of clients, local sample sizes, privacy budget, and number of iterations. We further derive a minimax lower bound on the MSE of any iterative private federated procedure that provides a benchmark to assess the optimality gap of these methods. We numerically evaluate our methods for training a logistic regression and a neural network on the computer vision datasets MNIST and CIFAR-10.
Record-level differential privacy exposes a structural misalignment in personalized federated learning when client-specific variation is low-dimensional while training repeatedly releases high-dimensional updates. In this paper, we address this misalignment by releasing a private client context once and confining repeated adaptation to a fixed coefficient space. Beyond dimensionality reduction, the factorized generator induces an adaptive optimization geometry that reshapes noisy updates, and controlled ablations show that most of its private-training gain is retained by radial evolution. To further reduce the communication cost, we realize the Gaussian mechanism for coefficient updates directly through variable-length quantization with finite expected code length, so that the quantization error itself serves as the required privacy perturbation rather than extra distortion. Across MNIST and CIFAR-10, our design matches or outperforms full-model private adaptation across privacy budgets and client heterogeneity, while reducing protected uplink by a factor of 2.67 at ε=16 on CIFAR-10 with comparable future-client accuracy.
Federated learning enables collaborative model training across distributed clients without centralising their data, yet privacy remains a persistent concern because the shared model updates can leak information about local datasets. Existing privacy-preserving methods either inject calibrated noise into client updates, limiting their composition guarantees, or formulate client privacy choices as a multi-agent game whose Nash equilibrium becomes intractable as the number of clients grows. We bridge these two lines of work by formulating privacy-preserving federated learning as a mean-field privacy game: each client strategically chooses its own privacy budget while interacting with the population only through a single mean-field statistic. The mean-field limit yields a tractable equilibrium for arbitrarily many clients, accommodates heterogeneous client preferences, and inherits an exponentially decaying privacy guarantee through a log-Sobolev contraction. The framework recovers the entropic privacy baseline as the homogeneous special case and the multi-agent privacy game as the finite-population case. Experiments on quadratic regression, logistic regression, and MNIST demonstrate that the proposed framework attains the privacy-utility trade-off of the entropic baseline while delivering a personalized privacy guarantee that the homogeneous baseline cannot express.