Debiased Negative Mining Improves Out-of-distribution Detection with Pre-trained Vision-Language Models
Authors: Bo Peng, Jie Lu, Guangquan Zhang, Zhen Fang
Organizations: University of Technology Sydney
Abstract
Aiming at identifying unexpected inputs from unknown classes, out-of-distribution (OOD) detection has emerged as a pivotal approach to enhancing the reliability of machine learning models. This paper focuses on the burgeoning paradigm of post-hoc OOD detection with pre-trained vision-language models (VLMs), where a popular pipeline is to detect OOD inputs by examining their affinities between ID labels and negative labels, i.e., those semantically different from ID labels. Due to the unavailability of target OOD labels, existing works predominantly rely on heuristic rules to mine negative labels from unlabeled wild corpus data. Despite the empirical success, we argue that the power of VLM-based OOD detection has yet to be fully unleashed since the notorious false negative problem is far from addressed in the literature. With this motivation, we are interested in addressing the challenge of mining true negative labels for OOD scoring. To this end, we develop a theoretical framework for correcting the sampling bias of negatives labels by indirectly approximating the distribution of negative labels. Perhaps surprisingly, we show that the debiased negative mining can be naturally converted into Monte-Carlo sampling based on ID labels and the unlabeled wild corpus data. Extensive experiments empirically manifest that our method establishes a new state-of-the-art in a variety of OOD detection setups. Code is publicly available at \href{https://github.com/60pen9/Debiased-Negative-Mining-Improves-OOD-Detection-with-Pre-trained-VLMs}{\textcolor{red}{here}}.
Out-of-Distribution (OOD) detection is essential for ensuring the robustness and reliability of object detection systems deployed in safety-critical applications. While prior research has mainly focused on uni-modal detectors or vision-language model (VLM) based classifiers, the potential of VLM-based object detectors in OOD scenarios remains underexplored. In this work, we take the first step toward building OOD object detection methods upon VLMs. We identify two challenges specific to VLM detectors: (i) their text-guided attention enhances foreground with ID labels but treats background uniformly, leaving potential OOD regions unexploited for separating in-distribution (ID) from OOD instances; and (ii) their sigmoid-based multi-label outputs are incompatible with softmax-based OOD scores, calling for scoring functions consistent with VLM probabilistic outputs. Hence, we introduce Negative Label Guided Attention and Scoring (NegAS). To address (i), we propose a negative label guided attention module (NegA), where LLM-generated, visually-similar but semantically-different negative labels are used to guide attention toward potential OOD background regions. To address (ii), we introduce a novel sigmoid-based OOD scoring function (NegS) that leverages both ID and negative labels, producing strong responses for ID instances and suppressed responses for OOD ones. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our approach improves OOD detection performance by a large margin while maintaining ID accuracy, e.g., reducing the FPR95 by 11.4% on the COCO dataset and 25.5% on the OpenImages dataset compared to the baseline model. While initially designed for dense VLM detectors like YOLO-World, we successfully adapt NegAS to Grounding DINO, a query-based VLM transformer and achieve significant improvements, demonstrating the generalizability of our framework.
Out-of-distribution (OOD) detection has emerged as a popular technique to enhance the reliability of machine learning models by identifying unexpected inputs from unknown classes. Recent progress in pre-trained vision-language models (VLMs) has enabled zero-shot OOD detection without access to in-distribution (ID) training data; in this setting, existing methods commonly treat text embeddings of class names as class prototypes. In this paper, we challenge the widely adopted text-as-prototype paradigm by theoretically showing that off-the-shelf textual prototypes are generally misaligned with the optimal visual prototypes, yielding an intrinsic modality gap that cannot be eliminated by prompt engineering alone. To mitigate this gap under the post-hoc constraint, this paper presents an online pseudo-supervised framework that directly learns class prototypes in the visual feature space using unlabeled test-time data streams and soft predictions from the pre-trained VLMs. We provide theoretical guarantees for the convergence of the online optimization procedure. Extensive experiments empirically demonstrate that our method achieves a new state of the art across a variety of OOD detection setups.
Recent studies show that using potential out-of-distribution (OOD) labels from large corpora as auxiliary information can improve OOD detection in vision-language models (VLMs). However, these methods often fail when real-world OOD samples fall outside the predefined OOD label set. To address this limitation, we propose DynProto, a novel approach that learns OOD prototypes dynamically during testing using only in-distribution (ID) information. DynProto is inspired by a key observation: OOD samples predicted as the same ID class tend to cluster in the feature space. With this insight, we leverage easy-to-detect OOD samples as ``anchors'' to find their harder-to-detect, similar counterparts. To this end, DynProto introduces two modules: \textbf{Coarse OOD Pattern Capturing Module} caches OOD patterns that are easily confused with each ID class during testing, and \textbf{Fine-grained OOD Pattern Refinement Module} subsequently clusters these patterns within each cache and aggregates them into representative OOD prototypes. By measuring similarity to ID and dynamic OOD prototypes, DynProto enables accurate OOD detection. DynProto significantly outperforms prior methods across multiple benchmarks. On ImageNet OOD benchmark, DynProto reduces FPR95 by 11.60% and improves AUROC by 4.70%. Moreover, the framework is architecture-agnostic and can be integrated into various backbones.