Performance Evaluation of GraphCast for Medium-Range Weather Forecasting over Brazil
Authors: Wolfgang R. Rowell, Lucas S. Kupssinskü
Organizations: MALTA, Machine Learning Theory and Applications Lab, PUCRS, Porto Alegre, Brazil
Abstract
The paradigm of global weather forecasting is rapidly shifting with the emergence of Machine Learning Weather Prediction models (MLWP). While these data-driven architectures demonstrate remarkable global skill, regional benchmarks in the Global South remain scarce, leaving their efficacy in complex, highly convective environments largely unverified. This study evaluates the performance of GraphCast operational against the deterministic ECMWF IFS HRES as baseline across four distinct Brazilian climatic sub-regions. Utilizing a scalable, cloud-native pipeline and the WeatherBench-X framework for benchmarking weather models, we assess selected tropospheric variables (T850, Q850, Z500) over four selected seasonal windows, employing the operational IFS analysis as the ground truth to calculate the statistical metrics for both models. Results reveal a regime-dependent skill profile. During the austral winter, GraphCast underperforms in the medium range (lead days 2-7) for Z500 when resolving fast-propagating baroclinic systems over southern Brazil, but regains an advantage in the extended range, where its inherent smoothing of chaotic small-scale variability becomes beneficial under deterministic skill metrics. Conversely, during the austral summer wet season, GraphCast accurately captures large-scale moisture transport while intrinsically dampening the high-frequency convective variability that degrades deterministic NWP temperature forecasts. These findings establish a baseline for Brazil and define the specific physical boundaries that will guide future ``tropicalization'' efforts, aiming to optimize these foundational AI models for regional resilience.
Accurate and timely weather forecasts are critical for high-impact decisions in modern society. Machine-learning-based weather prediction is emerging as an alternative for producing initial conditions, forecasts, and even both in end-to-end systems. These methods deliver predictions faster and often with higher skill than traditional numerical weather prediction (NWP). However, even end-to-end models typically rely on NWP-generated reanalyses for supervision, thereby inheriting the biases and resolution limitations of those NWPs, and limiting adaptation to settings where suitable reanalysis products are unavailable, infrequently updated, or expensive to produce. Here we introduce ObsCast, a regional system that generates both analysis and predictions, without using any NWP-derived data in either training or inference, while still achieving state-of-the-art performance in short-term high-resolution regional modeling. Over the contiguous United States and Europe, ObsCast outperforms operational NWP for near-surface variables through 18 h and produces skillful precipitation forecasts. It provides a simpler and more adaptable route to build and refine regional forecasting services directly from local observations, without the need to develop complex and costly traditional forecasting pipelines.
State-of-the-art AI weather models have shown impressive medium-range forecast skill and computational efficiency, but suffer two key shortcomings: their forecasts have lower spatial and temporal resolution than the best physics-based models and they are exclusively initialized with and trained on analysis data. As a result, they cannot directly make use of observations, and any biases in the analysis are inherited by the forecast. WeatherNext 3 addresses these shortcomings and establishes a new state-of-the-art for probabilistic medium-range forecasting skill. First, WeatherNext 3 generates new forecasts every hour (rather than every 6 hours like traditional global models) by ingesting low-latency geostationary satellite data. Second, WeatherNext 3's temporal and spatial resolution are on par with physics-based global models, with hourly time steps and 0.1 degree resolution for single-level variables, including solar radiation and cloud cover. Third, WeatherNext 3 moves beyond traditional analysis variables by learning to predict satellite-derived precipitation estimates, as well as tropical cyclone and station observations. Modelling sparse station data allows WeatherNext 3 to make 2m temperature and dewpoint predictions at any location and time, conditioned on local geographical features, with substantially lower error than competing global models, even when evaluated against unseen stations. Together, WeatherNext 3's capabilities move operational AI-based weather forecasting beyond emulating the traditionally distinct stages of data assimilation, forecasting and post-processing, which helps to further push the frontier of performance and granularity for global weather prediction.
Artificial intelligence weather prediction systems now surpass state-of-the-art physical models for medium-range forecasting. However, because these models are trained almost exclusively on historical climate reanalyses, they inherit pervasive structural biases, particularly for precipitation. Here we fine-tune a global graph-transformer architecture directly on high-resolution, satellite-derived precipitation observations. The resulting model reduces global medium-range probabilistic forecasting errors by up to 19% and improves extreme rainfall prediction accuracy by 57% over current operational models. It additionally demonstrates superior skill for tropical storms and drizzle events, though a physics-based operational model remains more reliable for the heaviest precipitation events. Our results demonstrate that incorporating observation-based data directly into training can substantially improve precipitation forecasts.
Julian F. Schmitt, Bertrand Delorme, Robert C. King +4