From Convolution to Transformer: A Comparative Study of U-Net Variants for Brain Tumor and Retinal Vessel Segmentation

Medical image segmentation is dominated by U-Net-style encoder-decoder architectures. Vision Transformers (ViTs) overcome the limited receptive field of convolutional networks through self-attention, enabling modeling of long-range dependencies. Early ViT-based segmentation methods typically retained U-Net-style decoders because pretrained ViT representations were insufficient to support accurate dense prediction. Recent advances in large-scale pretraining have redefined the representation capability of ViTs, reducing the reliance on U-Net-style decoder architectures in modern vision models. This prompts two questions: Is the U-Net paradigm still necessary for medical image segmentation? If not, how should an encoder-only segmentation framework be designed? Motivated by these questions, we explore key architectural choices for encoder-only medical image segmentation based on modern ViT backbones and establish a query-based encoder-only design with multi-level query modeling and learnable block fusion, realized in Encoder-only Segmentation (EoSeg). Extensive experiments across seven benchmark datasets spanning CT, MRI, histopathology, endoscopy, and dermoscopy validate the effectiveness of the proposed design across diverse medical imaging modalities, including mDice scores of 85.50% on Synapse, 91.73% on ACDC, and 93.27% on GlaS. The results demonstrate that a U-Net-style decoder is no longer necessary for medical image segmentation with modern ViT backbones and further show that EoSeg provides an effective encoder-only design. Code is available at: https://github.com/Retinal-Research/EoSeg

Accurate segmentation of thin, tortuous anatomical structures, such as retinal vessels, cerebral vasculature, and facial wrinkles, remains challenging due to low contrast, frequent discontinuities, and severe class imbalance. Although recent convolutional and Transformer-based models have improved performance, they often yield fragmented predictions and fail to recover fine branches. We propose CSWinUNETR, a general-purpose backbone for 2D and 3D thin-structure segmentation. It employs cross-shaped stripe self-attention to model long-range principal-axis context and incorporates cyclic shifts to enhance information exchange across stripes. To better preserve fine-grained details, we further introduce a detail-enhanced multi-scale self-attention module that aggregates contextual features from multi-resolution representations. In addition, we propose sparse-control dynamic snake convolution, which reconstructs reliable dense curvilinear kernels from sparsely predicted control points to better follow tortuous geometry. Extensive experiments on four benchmarks across ophthalmology, neurovascular imaging, and dermatology demonstrate that CSWinUNETR consistently outperforms state-of-the-art methods without task-specific post-processing or topology-aware losses. The code is available at https://github.com/labhai/CSWinUNETR.

Early detection of vision-threatening conditions such as diabetic retinopathy, glaucoma, and age-related macular degeneration depends on retinal fundus image analysis, but manual assessment is slow and expert-dependent. Automated convolutional neural networks classify fundus images accurately yet act as black boxes, and existing retinal vessel segmentation methods lose discriminative power under pathology and seldom exploit attention or transformer backbones. Using the FIVES and DRIVE fundus datasets, we develop a two-pipeline framework that pairs four-class disease classification with attention- and transformer-based vessel segmentation, organised in three stages: (1) FIVES images are augmented by rotation and horizontal and vertical flips and used to fine-tune eight ImageNet-pretrained CNNs: ResNet101, DenseNet169, Xception, InceptionV3, DenseNet121, InceptionResNetV2, ResNet50, and EfficientNetB0. (2) Five gradient-based explanation methods, Grad-CAM, Grad-CAM++, Score-CAM, Faster Score-CAM, and Layer-CAM, are computed on the final convolutional block of each classifier and compared qualitatively across architectures. (3) Ten U-Net variants are benchmarked for vessel segmentation: TransUNet (hybrid CNN--Transformer encoder) and Attention U-Net (gated skip connections), evaluated with ResNet50V2, ResNet101V2, and ResNet152V2 backbones, along with additional Attention U-Net configurations using DenseNet backbones, and the fully transformer-based Swin-UNet. ResNet101 gives the highest classification accuracy: 94.17% (F1 0.942) $>$ 88.33% for EfficientNetB0. For segmentation, the architecture ranking is consistent on both datasets: Attention U-Net $>$ TransUNet $>$ Swin-UNet. The strongest configuration is Attention U-Net with a ResNet101V2 backbone: FIVES IoU 0.722, Dice 0.838; DRIVE IoU 0.648, Dice 0.787, lifting DRIVE IoU 60.80 $\rightarrow$ 64.83 over a prior custom U-Net.