Weak Dominant Balance for Robust Identification of Dynamically Consistent Fluid Flow Structure
Authors: Samuel Ahnert, Esther Lagemann, H. Jane Bae, Kunihiko Taira, Ricardo Vinuesa, Christian Lagemann, Steven L. Brunton
Organizations: Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA · AI Institute in Dynamic Systems, University of Washington, Seattle, WA, USA · Lynn Booth and Kent Kresa Department of Aerospace, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, CA, USA · Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, CA, USA · Department of Aerospace Engineering, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA
Abstract
Extracting interpretable, localized physical mechanisms from complex spatiotemporal data is a foundational challenge across physics, biology, and engineering, but has remained out of reach on real measurements. The central obstacle is obtaining high-quality gradients of data via numerical differentiation, which amplifies noise, diverges for high-order equations, and falters on irregular geometries, limiting the scope of existing approaches to clean simulations of low-order systems. Here, we present weak dominant balance, a derivative-free framework that projects governing equations into a weak (integral) formulation, offloading differentiation onto smooth analytical test functions and leaving the data untouched. The method sustains accurate regime identification under severe noise where existing approaches categorically fail, delivers the first data-driven decomposition of a third-order partial differential equation applied to turbulent duct flow, and produces matching decompositions across direct numerical simulation and particle-image velocimetry measurements of a wavy channel flow, uncovering a previously uncharacterized dynamical regime. Weak dominant balance brings mechanism-level analysis out of simulation and onto measured data, and opens complex physical systems to direct, equation-grounded interpretation.
Data-driven discovery of governing equations has advanced significantly in recent years; however, existing methods often struggle in multiscale systems where dynamically significant terms may have small coefficients. Therefore, we propose Balance-Guided SINDy (BG-SINDy) inspired by the principle of dominant balance, which reformulates ℓ0-constrained sparse regression as a term-level ℓ2,0-regularized problem and solves it using a progressive pruning strategy. Terms are ranked according to their relative contributions to the governing equation balance rather than their absolute coefficient magnitudes. Based on this criterion, BG-SINDy alternates between least-squares regression and elimination of negligible terms, thereby preserving dynamically significant terms even when their coefficients are small. Numerical experiments on the Korteweg--de Vries equation with a small dispersion coefficient, a modified Burgers equation with vanishing hyperviscosity, a modified Kuramoto--Sivashinsky equation with multiple small-coefficient terms, and a two-dimensional reaction--diffusion system demonstrate the validity of BG-SINDy in discovering small-coefficient terms. The proposed method thus provides an efficient approach for discovering governing equations that contain small-coefficient terms.
Characterizing the complete wall-pressure spectrum in turbulent wall-bounded flows requires simultaneous access to the viscous-scale high-wavenumber content and the outer-layer low-wavenumber content -- a requirement that neither short-domain direct numerical simulation (DNS) nor sparse experimental measurements alone can satisfy. We propose Patched Flow Matching (Patched FM), a generative framework that fuses these two complementary sources by learning a patch-local prior over inner-scaled wall-pressure statistics from short-domain DNS and assimilating sparse sensor measurements at inference time through training-free posterior sampling. The patch-additive decomposition of the flow matching vector field decouples the generative prior from the global domain size, enabling reconstruction on domains arbitrarily larger than the training configuration. By expressing the patch prior in inner-scaled coordinates, where high-wavenumber wall-pressure statistics are approximately Reynolds-number invariant, the framework extends to higher Reynolds numbers through hierarchical transfer learning with as few as 500 short-domain snapshots (2.5% of the base training data) at a fraction of the scratch-training cost. Applied to compressible channel-flow DNS at Reτ=180, 500, and 1000, Patched FM reconstructs full-resolution wall-pressure fields on a domain four times larger than the training configuration (LxL=16πδ versus LxS=4πδ) from sensor coverage as low as 0.25%, recovering the low-wavenumber spectral content inaccessible to short-domain DNS with high fidelity in both streamwise and spanwise directions. Zero-shot generalization to unseen Reynolds numbers and ablation studies further confirm the role of inner scaling as a physical prerequisite for data-efficient Reynolds-number transfer.
Fractional partial differential equations describe nonlocal dynamics, but discovering them from noisy data is difficult because fractional differentiation amplifies high-frequency measurement noise and the derivative orders are unknown. We propose Weak-Pareto, which combines an adjoint-consistent weak formulation of fractional terms with Pareto-based subset selection over discrete term types and continuous fractional orders. For linear right-hand-side terms, the adjoint transfers fractional operators from measured fields to smooth test functions, replacing noise-sensitive pointwise differentiation with smoothing integration; for nonlinear terms, the noise-suppression effect is partial yet useful. Coefficients are fitted by ridge regression within a branch-aware differential-evolution search over the orders. The support size is then selected at the validation-error-complexity elbow. We show that the variance of fixed linear right-hand-side weak features vanishes under grid refinement, whereas noise amplification in pointwise fractional features increases with derivative order. Across fractional advection-diffusion, reaction-diffusion, and Burgers benchmarks, Weak-Pareto recovers parsimonious structures from clean and noisy measurements. In controlled advection-diffusion and Burgers comparisons, it retains the correct support at every tested multiplicative-noise level, whereas the unregularised strong-form counterpart largely fails once noise is introduced; this advantage persists under additive Gaussian noise. Ablations show that the weak library drives noise robustness and that continuous-order Pareto search avoids the support-selection failure of a dense fixed dictionary. On the advection-diffusion benchmark, Weak-Pareto yields more consistent operator recovery and substantially lower measured runtime than a contemporary neural baseline.