Probing Low-Level Acoustic Attribute Encoding in CLAP Audio Embeddings
Authors: Héctor Martel, Joe Hennessy-Priest, Taemin Cho
Organizations: BandLab Technologies, Singapore
Abstract
Audio foundation models are widely adopted as general-purpose feature extractors, yet the internal structure of their learned representations remains insufficiently understood. In this work, we analyze CLAP audio embeddings through a probing framework, studying the encoding of three fundamental perceptual dimensions: reverberation (RT60), loudness (LUFS), and spectral content, measured via spectral centroid (SC) and relative pitch (RP). Probes of increasing complexity are trained to predict each attribute from frozen embeddings across five datasets spanning noise, speech, monophonic musical notes, and music mixtures. Our primary finding is that all of these attributes are reliably recoverable from the CLAP embedding space across the examined datasets. Within this global picture, two encoding regimes emerge: RT60, LUFS, and RP are approximately linearly encoded, while SC requires non-linear probes. Both regimes generalize across eight additional audio foundation models, with the notable exception that amplitude-invariant architectures discard loudness entirely by construction. The identified linear feature directions are geometrically consistent across datasets for RT60 and LUFS, while highly domain-specific for RP. Finally, we provide a qualitative demonstration of cross-modal consistency, showing that text embeddings of acoustic descriptors align geometrically with the identified RT60 feature direction.
Contrastive Language-Audio Pretraining (CLAP) models are widely used for audio understanding and support modality-agnostic condition swapping in many zero-shot applications. However, their performance is heavily affected by the modality gap between audio and text embeddings. Existing explanations mainly attribute this gap to the cone effect, treating it as a shift between mean embeddings, yet correcting the mean alone yields only limited improvements. Alternative hypotheses, such as information imbalance and dimensionality collapse, have also been proposed, but they remain insufficiently verified and have not been thoroughly studied in the audio domain. Meanwhile, several works attempt to decompose multimodal contrastive embeddings into interpretable concepts, but none explicitly analyze the modality gap from the perspective of concept decomposition. In this work, we introduce COMET (Concept space Organization and Modality gap Explanation with PLS-SVD Transformation), a novel partial least squares singular value decomposition (PLS-SVD) framework for CLAP that unveils a broader perspective of the modality gap. Our framework reveals that only a small, interpretable subset of axes, which captures shared concepts, contributes substantially to similarity computation, and that the mean component represents only partially the modality gap. Building on this insight, we propose a simple spectral truncation method that mitigates the modality gap in a training-free manner. The method enables zero-shot audio captioning with condition swapping to approach fully supervised performance, without requiring large auxiliary memory banks or expensive computation. At the same time, it achieves substantial embedding dimensionality reduction while preserving strong performance on retrieval and audio captioning tasks.
Pretrained audio embeddings are standard in bioacoustics, yet little is known about which acoustic features these models encode, nor which are useful for a given task. This hinders transparency and limits extension to rare species or data-scarce domains. Here we reveal which speech-like features are encoded in bioacoustic representations. Using the 88~eGeMAPS features across six taxonomic groups, we apply linear and nonlinear regression probes to quantify which acoustic properties each model captures. Results confirm a ``no free lunch'' pattern: no single model captures the full feature space. A concatenated embedding achieves the highest performance, suggesting complementary acoustic space coverage across models. Loudness features are best encoded (R2=0.76) while F0 is hardest to recover (R2=0.33). By cross-referencing recoverability with per-species feature salience (NMI), we derive data-driven model selection guidance for bioacoustics.
Pretrained spatial audio encoders are increasingly used as general-purpose representations for perceptual tasks, yet their spatial encoding capabilities remain poorly understood. We introduce the Spatial Audio Representation Learning (SARL) benchmark, a controlled framework for evaluating spatial information in pretrained audio models. SARL probes source-level factors (azimuth, elevation, distance, class) and room-level factors (RT60, volume, shape). Experiments across diverse encoders reveal three patterns: input configuration and training paradigm shape spatial encoding; source factors are consistently easier to decode than room factors; and sensitivity analysis under controlled perturbations shows heterogeneous responses to source and room variation. These results reveal systematic biases in current pretrained audio representations. SARL is released as an open-source benchmark for reproducible evaluation of spatial audio representations.