What's in a Smoothness Constant? Tighter Rates for Local SGD with Bounded Second-order Heterogeneity

Local SGD is a popular optimization method in distributed learning, often outperforming other algorithms in practice, including mini-batch SGD. Despite this success, theoretically proving the dominance of local SGD in settings with reasonable data heterogeneity has been difficult, creating a significant gap between theory and practice. In this paper, we provide new lower bounds for local SGD under existing first-order data heterogeneity assumptions, showing that these assumptions are insufficient to prove the effectiveness of local update steps. Furthermore, under these same assumptions, we demonstrate the min-max optimality of accelerated mini-batch SGD, which fully resolves our understanding of distributed optimization for several problem classes. Our results emphasize the need for better models of data heterogeneity to understand the effectiveness of local SGD in practice. Towards this end, we consider higher-order smoothness and heterogeneity assumptions, providing new upper bounds that imply the dominance of local SGD over mini-batch SGD when data heterogeneity is low.

Decentralized stochastic gradient descent (D-SGD) is an efficient method for large-scale distributed learning. Existing generalization studies mainly address expected results, achieving rates limited to $\mathcal{O}\left(\frac{1}{δ\sqrt{mn}}\right)$, where $δ$ is the confidence parameter, $m$ the number of workers, and $n$ the sample size. When $m=1$, D-SGD reduces to traditional SGD, whose optimal high-probability generalization bound is $\mathcal{O}\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{n}}\log (1/δ)\right)$. This discrepancy reveals a gap between high-probability guarantees for SGD and those for D-SGD. To close this, we develop a high-probability learning theory for D-SGD, aiming for the optimal $\mathcal{O}\left(\frac{1}{\sqrt{mn}}\log (1/δ)\right)$ rate. We refine bounds for D-SGD using pointwise uniform stability in distributed learning-a weaker notion than uniform stability-and analyze them across convex, strongly convex, and non-convex settings. We also provide high-probability results for gradient-based measures in non-convex cases where only local minima exist, and derive optimization error and excess risk bounds. Finally, accounting for communication overhead, we analyze generalization bounds for local models within time-varying frameworks.

Stochastic gradient descent (SGD) is the primary workhorse for large-scale optimization. While the average behavior of its iterates, typically characterized by mean-squared error bounds, is well-understood, obtaining high-probability guarantees for the last iterate remains challenging. Prior approaches to this problem have either imposed restrictive assumptions (such as bounded domains or gradients) or relied on complex proofs involving auxiliary sequences. In this work, we propose Batched SGD, a simple variant that partitions online samples into epochs and performs a single update per epoch using a refined, low-variance gradient estimate. Our main contribution demonstrates that this batching mechanism enables a surprisingly simple high-probability analysis that avoids both restrictive assumptions and auxiliary sequences. Under standard smoothness and norm-sub-Gaussian noise assumptions, we establish near-optimal rates for both strongly convex and non-convex objectives. Furthermore, we show that our batching idea extends naturally to federated learning (FL). We provide the first high-probability guarantees for FL, achieving logarithmic communication complexity, linear speedup in the number of agents, and resilience to data heterogeneity.