Bumblebee: Interleaved Mixed-Layer Building Blocks for Large-Scale Recommendation Systems
Authors: David Bauer, Cancan Zhang, Wenshun Liu, Xiaoyi Zhang, Weijia Liu, Wanli Ma, Yue Weng, Wei Li, +8 more
Abstract
Recommendation systems have undergone significant transformations in the past years. The transition from traditional feature interaction modules to generative next-action prediction has pushed the boundaries of personalized content. Developments have largely evolved along two separate tracks. Sequence modeling approaches on the one hand and feature interaction methods on the other. In this paper, we introduce Bumblebee, a recommendation architecture that addresses the lack of interaction between the two directions through an interleaved, stackable block design. Each block implements a micro-pipeline of layers combining sequence personalization, attention-based encoding, and feature crossing into a self-contained unit. Every block produces a joint representation of both feature modalities which is consumed by the next block in the sequence. This mechanism encourages early and repeated mixture of modalities and enriches downstream features with additional contextual information. Residual connections between blocks create cross-modal information pathways and yield additional predictive performance without adding additional parameters. Blocks can be specialized by selectively dropping components, enabling flexible trade-offs between quality and throughput. We evaluate our approach on large-scale industrial data and show consistent improvements over comparable baseline models across several classification and regression tasks. Furthermore, we conduct ablation studies to confirm that the interleaved composition itself is the primary driver of these improvements. Our results suggest that interleaving heterogeneous functional units, rather than composing deep stacks, is a promising paradigm for future-generation recommendation architectures.
As scalability becomes increasingly important in recommendation modeling, recent architectures have advanced the modeling of two broad sources of ranking signals along separate paths: non-sequence features, including user, item, context, and cross features; and sequence features from user behavior histories. Wukong and HSTU have emerged as representative scalable backbones for these paths: Wukong scales high-order non-sequence feature-interaction modeling, while HSTU scales long user-behavior sequence modeling. Despite their complementary strengths, practical architectures that combine these two types of feature modeling remain underexplored. We present WHALE, a scalable unified recommendation architecture that jointly models non-sequence and sequence features on top of Wukong and HSTU. Each WHALE layer contains a Wukong module, an HSTU module, and an attention-based fusion module in which Wukong-derived interaction representations query HSTU-derived behavior representations. This design keeps both backbones active throughout the network and enables progressive Wukong-HSTU exchange, allowing high-order feature crosses to repeatedly retrieve fine-grained evidence from long user histories. To make WHALE practical for industrial deployment, we introduce customized Triton kernels and other model-systems co-design techniques to improve training and inference efficiency. On large-scale industrial recommendation data, WHALE achieves consistent gains in offline experiments. Additionally, it delivers positive online gains with a modest serving-throughput trade-off. The method has been deployed in production systems. Overall, WHALE provides a practical example of how these two sources of information can be scalably unified in an industrial recommendation model.
Sequence learning has emerged as the promising paradigm in recommendation systems, surpassing traditional Deep Learning Recommendation Models (DLRM) by capturing the temporal nuances of user behavior. However, current state-of-the-art architectures operate under a limiting analogy: they treat user history as a monolithic chronological sequence like a sentence in a Large Language Model (LLM). We observe a fundamental divergence between natural language and recommendation data: unlike the linear, logical flow of text, user history is inherently multi-faceted. A user's journey is a fragmented reflection of diverse interests, resulting in much weaker coherence between items than is found in LLM training data. This lack of structural unity leads to context pollution. In single-sequence modeling, unrelated behaviors compete for the same attention budget. This "noisy" signal dilutes the model's focus, effectively capping its ability to discern high-intent patterns from background activity. To address this, we propose Constructive Multi-Sequence Learning (CMSL), a paradigm shift from passive sequence ingestion to active "context engineering" that constructs multiple coherent sequences in latent space. CMSL leverages a learnable Sequence Construction Module to disentangle user history into "pure" thematic strands, followed by a linear attention mechanism to efficiently model these strands at scale. CMSL has been deployed across ranking and retrieval tasks and across four major surfaces at Meta.
Transformer-style architectures are increasingly adopted for industrial recommendation systems, yet they inherit a design premise misaligned with the task: generative models rely on per-token autoregressive prediction, which justifies maintaining large intermediate tensors that scale with sequence length. In contrast, recommendation systems produce a single set of relevance scores for each <user, item> pair without token-level supervision. Leveraging this observation, we propose SlimPer, which reformulates personalized ranking as iterative refinement of a compact, unified <user, item> knowledge base. At each layer, the model selectively queries raw multi-modal user-side tokens, computes explicit relevance matching scores, and refines the knowledge base, all in O(N) per-layer cost with a fixed-size intermediate representation. As a result, model depth is decoupled from user history length, enabling deeper relevance understanding without proportional growth in compute or memory; request-only optimization further trims memory by sharing a single copy of user-side tokens across all candidate items. SlimPer unifies sparse, dense, and sequence features within a single backbone and provides inherent interpretability through its attention mechanism. Deployed on Instagram Reels and Feed, SlimPer yields measurable improvements in user engagement while streamlining the overall system and enabling effective modeling of 10k+ fine-grained user history events.