Wiktionary as a Crowdsourced Lexicon for English Dialects
Authors: Sidney Wong
Organizations: Centre for Sustainability Research, University of Otago Te P¯unaha Matatini Centre of Research Excellence for Complex Systems, New Zealand
This paper evaluates Wiktionary as an ethically crowdsourced lexicon for English dialects. We took a two-phase approach, providing an in-depth descriptive analysis of the crowdsourced lexicon for 12 national varieties of English before applying the lexicon to geo-referenced, country-level social media language data to examine the real-world performance of this crowdsourced dialect lexicon. We demonstrate that Wiktionary matches or exceeds the coverage of traditional dictionaries, such as the Oxford English Dictionary (OED), for regional and Outer-Circle varieties. Our dialect-specific case study on New Zealand English found high alignment between Wiktionary and the OED based on word-formation patterns (R = 0.883). Similarly, we observed high alignment between the dialect lexicon and geo-referenced social media language. While this paper found that Wiktionary has broad coverage of lexical properties, it also highlighted some of the macro-challenges involved in evaluating dialect-responsive language resources and tools, such as the role of language contact in dialects and register effects in web-based corpora.
Figures & tables
Category
n
Example
African
13
Botswanan, Cameroonian
Antarctic
-
-
Asian
3
East Asian, South Asian
Caribbean
8
Bahaman, Barbadian
Commonwealth
16
Australian, Bangaldeshi
European
6
British, Channel Islands
Table 1: Summary table of the Wiktionary categories of regional varieties including the number of subcategories ( n ) and examples.
Grouping
Country
Subreddit
Members
Submissions
Comments
n
xˉ
n
xˉ
Outer-Circle
India
r/india
3.2M
481K
64.5
12.5M
202.8
Outer-Circle
Pakistan
r/pakistan
575K
87K
56.9
2.4M
212.0
Outer-Circle
Malaysia
r/malaysia
1.3M
73K
55.3
3.5M
179.0
Outer-Circle
Philippines
r/Philippines
3.3M
331K
52.0
13.6M
138.7
Outer-Circle
Kenya
r/Kenya
219K
24K
42.3
475K
150.6
Table 2: Summary table of Reddit communities including the associated national variety of English (Country), the name of the community (Community), the number of subscribers as of June 2025 (Members), and the total number of words ( n ) and mean word length ( xˉ ) for Submission Posts and Comments.
Dialect
OED
Wiki
%Δ
Malaysian
19
450
2,268.4
Filipino
93
1,493
1,505.4
Canadian
550
2,834
415.3
Indian
721
1,816
151.9
Irish
1,145
2,105
83.8
Australian
2,435
3,381
38.9
Table 3: Summary table comparing the total number of entries from the OED and Wiktionary (Wiki) by national variety (Dialect).
Figure 1: Euler diagram illustrating the degree of overlap in Wiktionary entries for the six Inner-Circle varieties of English. Similar to Venn diagrams, a Euler diagram visualises sets and their relationships particularly those with complex hierarchies.
Figure 2: Euler diagram illustrating the degree of overlap in Wiktionary entries filtered by NZE and the six Inner-Circle varieties of English.
Word Formation Process
OED
Wiki
%Δ
Initialism
3
14
366.7
Blend
3
9
200.0
Backformation
3
6
100.0
Unknown
21
38
81.0
Proper name
37
66
78.4
Borrowing
287
399
39.0
Table 4: Summary table comparing the number of entries classified by word formation processes between the OED and Wiktionary (Wiki). The categories are ordered by percentage difference ( %Δ ) between OED and Wiktionary.
Dialect
Submission Posts
Comments
Community
μi
Alignment
Community
μi
Alignment
British
r/unitedkingdom
5,475.2
Yes
r/malaysia
3,973.3
No
Irish
r/ireland
889.1
Yes
r/ireland
771.1
Yes
Australian
r/australia
743.4
Yes
r/australia
333.4
Yes
New Zealand
r/newzealand
829.5
Yes
r/Philippines
498.8
No
American
r/usa
5,538.7
Yes
r/canada
3,582.3
No
Table 5: Summary table presenting the Subreddit communities (Community) with the greatest mean relative frequency ( μi ) and alignment by Inner-Circle variety of English (Dialect) grouped by text-type: Submission Posts or Comments.
Entry
Submissions
Comments
box of birds
-
11
box of fluffies
-
14
in the dogbox
-
7
jack a dandy
-
-
pack a sad
-
39
suck the kumara
1
5
Table 6: Table listing the total number of multi-word expressions (excluding borrowings from te reo Māori) in r/newzealand from Submission Posts and Comments.
Entry
r/newzealand
r/Philippines
n
μi
n
μi
mo
1,902
0.6
1,319,868
403.9
pa
3,338
1.1
1,174,769
359.5
para
372
0.1
499,040
152.7
eh
17,914
5.9
435,229
133.2
po
857
0.3
309,069
94.6
Table 7: Summary table including the token frequency ( n ) and mean relative frequency ( μi ) for the top five NZE Wiktionary entries grouped by Subreddit communities.
Entry
Submissions
Comments
biddi biddi
-
-
hei tiki
-
42
ka pai
2
619
kapa haka
8
415
kia ora
121
2,645
kohanga reo
-
90
Table 8: Total number of multi-word expressions (borrowings from te reo Māori) in r/newzealand from Submission Posts and Comments.
Figure 3: Relative frequencies of lexical dialect features associated with the six Inner-Circle varieties of English across twelve Reddit communities in Submission Posts.
Figure 4: Relative frequencies of lexical dialect features associated with the six Inner-Circle varieties of English across twelve Reddit communities in Comments.
This thesis investigates geographic dialect alignment in place-informed social media communities, focussing on New Zealand-related Reddit communities. By integrating qualitative analyses of user perceptions with computational methods, the study examines how language use reflects place identity and patterns of language variation and change based on user-informed lexical, morphosyntactic, and semantic variables. The findings show that users generally associate language with place, and place-related communities form a contiguous speech community, though alignment between geographic dialect communities and place-related communities remains complex. Advanced language modelling, including static and diachronic Word2Vec language embeddings, revealed semantic variation across place-based communities and meaningful semantic shifts within New Zealand English. The research involved the creation of a corpus containing 4.26 billion unprocessed words, which offers a valuable resource for future study. Overall, the results highlight the potential of social media as a natural laboratory for sociolinguistic inquiry.
Recent research on dialectal NLP has identified data scarcity as a primary limitation. To address this limitation, this paper presents a catalog of contemporary Basque dialectal data and resources, offering a systematic and comprehensive compilation of the dialectal data currently available in Basque. Two types of data sources have been distinguished: online data originally written in some dialect, and standard-to-dialect adapted data. The former includes all dialectal data that can be found online, such as news and radio sites, informal tweets, as well as online resources such as dictionaries, atlases, grammar rules, or videos. The latter consists of data that has been adapted from the standard variety to dialectal varieties, either manually or automatically. Regarding the manual adaptation, the test split of the XNLI Natural Language Inference dataset was manually adapted into three Basque dialects: Western, Central, and Navarrese-Lapurdian, yielding a high-quality parallel gold standard evaluation dataset. With respect to the automatic dialectal adaptation, the automatically adapted physical commonsense dataset (BasPhyCowest) underwent additional manual evaluation by native speakers to assess its quality and determine whether it could serve as a viable substitute for full manual adaptation (i.e., silver data creation).
Automatic induction of high-quality dictionaries is essential for building lexical resources, yet low-resource languages and dialects pose several challenges: limited access to annotators, high degree of spelling variations, and poor performance of large language models (LLMs). We empirically show that statistical models (random forests) trained on string similarity features are surprisingly effective for inducing German dialect lexicons. They outperform LLMs, enable cross-dialect transfer, and offer a lightweight data-driven alternative. We evaluate our models intrinsically on bilingual lexicon induction (BLI) and extrinsically on dialect information retrieval (IR). On BLI, random forests outperform Mistral-123b while being more resource-lean. On dialect IR with BM25, using our dialect dictionaries for query expansion yields relative improvements of up to 28.9% in nDCG@10 and 50.7% in Recall@100. Motivated by the resource scarcity in dialects, we further investigate the extent to which models transfer across different German dialects, and their performance under varying amounts of training data.
Robert Litschko, Barbara Plank, Diego Frassinelli
MaiNLP, Center for Information and Language Processing, LMU Munich, Germany · Munich Center for Machine Learning (MCML), Munich, Germany