Mapping the Concept Landscape: Structural Perception of Global Distributions for Transparent Data Pruning
Authors: Dongyue Wu, Tao Ma
Organizations: State Key Laboratory of Multispectral Information Intelligent Processing Technology, School of Artificial Intelligence and Automation, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China · Ant Group · Institute of Computing Technology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China
Existing data pruning methods predominantly rely on high-dimensional feature embeddings to measure sample importance. However, these compressed vectors often obscure fine-grained semantic interactions, leading to suboptimal coverage of rare semantic concepts in the pruned subsets. In this paper, we propose Mapping the Concept Landscape (MCL), a novel structural perception framework for transparent data pruning. Instead of abstract embeddings, we represent each image-caption pair as an explicit sample-level graph comprising entities, events, and attributes. By integrating these individual graphs into a comprehensive dataset-level graph, we characterize the global distribution of semantic concepts and quantify their rarity across the entire corpus. Based on this structured perception, we develop a greedy concept-coverage maximization algorithm that iteratively selects samples to maximize the marginal gain of high-value, under-represented concepts. Experimental results on various benchmarks demonstrate that our method not only achieves superior pruning efficiency compared to state-of-the-art methods but also provides a transparent and interpretable audit trail for the selection process.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Illustration of the challenge of data pruning methods and the overview of our proposed Mapping the Concept Landscape (MCL) framework for transparent data pruning. MCL aims to maximize semantic coverage based on concept graphs. The node size is positively related to the number of samples a concept appears in the dataset.
Figure 2: Wall-clock time comparison with recent data pruning methods [ 29 , 58 ] . Results are collected on a device with four NVIDIA RTX 3090 GPUs.
Benchmarks
Valid Data
MME-P
MME-C
SEED-I
POPE
MMMU
SQA
GQA
TextQA
Rel.
Baseline
665k
1476.9
267.9
67.4
86.4
32.8
70.0
63.0
58.2
100.0%
Random
50k
1387.5
287.5
59.7
85.7
32.2
68.4
55.0
53.1
95.7%
Length
50k
1357.0
265.7
47.0
82.6
33.9
60.9
55.5
45.2
89.1%
EL2N [ 35 ]
50k
1077.3
252.5
59.3
80.8
33.6
71.0
61.0
41.7
90.1%
GradN [ 35 ]
50k
1275.4
303.6
58.3
75.7
32.4
70.9
44.9
46.0
90.5%
IFD [ 24 ]
50k
1113.4
301.8
55.1
76.7
33.0
48.2
41.9
43.6
83.6%
Table 1: Comparison to state-of-the-art methods on LLaVA-v1.5-mix-665k dataset with 50k (7.5%) and 133k (20%) selected data. Our results are shown in the gray block. The best and the second best results are in bold and underlined , respectively. We all use the LoRA model due to limited resources. † denotes our implementation.
Method
AP50:95
AP50
AP75
APsmall
APmid
APlarge
Baseline
40.06
61.12
42.03
19.27
43.39
59.24
Random
38.26 ↓ 1.80
58.91
39.77
17.83
41.19
56.69
EL2N
34.35 ↓ 5.71
53.29
36.14
16.58
37.64
48.54
InfoBatch
34.95 ↓ 5.11
53.86
36.55
17.00
38.74
49.05
DivBS
39.74 ↓ 0.32
60.84
41.98
18.07
43.14
58.78
PFB
39.69 ↓ 0.37
60.85
41.74
18.45
43.25
59.07
Table 2: Comparison to state-of-the-art data pruning methods on COCO 2017 object detection dataset with 70% selected training data.
Figure 5Figure 6
Figure 7: Visualization of the dataset graph (a) before and (b) after pruning. The size of each node is proportional to the fraction of samples containing the concept. Concept distribution becomes more balanced after pruning.
The rapid growth of modern training datasets has significantly increased computational cost, motivating dataset pruning~(DP) methods which retain only a subset of informative samples to reduce training cost. Existing pruning criteria typically rely on either intrinsic signals that assess samples independently or extrinsic signals that promote diversity via pairwise relations. While effective in their own specific regimes, each captures only one aspect of sample utility and lacks robustness across different pruning ratios or data distribution. In this work, we present a unified graph-based DP framework. By modeling the dataset as a weighted graph, where node weights encode intrinsic value and edge weights encode extrinsic value, DP can be cast as a Maximum Weight Clique Problem (MWCP). Although MWCP is NP-hard, its structure admits a principled greedy solution based on sample-wise marginal gains. Under a few mild conditions, we further prove that this unified objective enjoys a formal approximation guarantee, which applies to a broad family of importance metrics and provides practical design guidelines. Extensive experiments show that our method outperforms existing DP methods while substantially reducing training cost, reducing training time by over 40% without sacrificing accuracy on ImageNet-1k with ResNet-50.
Dongyue Wu, Zilin Guo, Xiaoyu Li +4
State Key Laboratory of Multispectral Information Intelligent Processing Technology, School of Artificial Intelligence and Automation, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China · Ant Group, Hangzhou, China
Dataset pruning reduces a large training set to a representative subset while preserving model performance. Existing geometry-based methods typically assume that nearby points in embedding space share similar properties. Rather than imposing this assumption, we derive geometric selection criteria by reformulating unbiased subset selection as a variance minimization problem. Unbiasedness ensures that unweighted subset averages recover full-dataset averages in expectation, including losses and gradients at fixed model parameters. Specifically, we characterize a family of unbiased subset selection algorithms as a high-dimensional polytope. In this context, minimizing the expected sampling variance is a linear objective. Differences in sampling variance, averaged over rigid motions, admit closed-form pairwise expressions. Because the polytope has high dimension, directly applying standard linear programming is impractical. We instead use these expressions to construct an efficient vertex walk that optimizes an approximation of the variance objective while preserving unbiasedness, yielding a method that requires neither labels nor model training during selection. Across CIFAR-10, MNIST, and CelebA benchmarks, our method matches or exceeds uniform sampling in mean test accuracy at every evaluated budget and outperforms competing geometric methods in several settings, particularly at small selection budgets. Beyond dataset pruning, the same framework reduces stochastic-gradient variance by increasing diversity within mini-batches while keeping the batch size unchanged.
Rodrigo Schuller, Francisco Ganacim
Instituto de Matem´atica Pura e Aplicada (IMPA) Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Data selection reallocates training support across visual concepts, including objects, attributes, color, texture, and backgrounds. Different allocation strategies may produce varied downstream model behavior, especially for tail concepts supported by only a few samples. Discarding them can hurt test-time robustness, while overemphasizing samples lying on category boundaries may introduce unstable training signals. This work explicitly investigates this relationship across fine-grained, spurious-correlation, and general image classification, as well as multimodal pretraining. Specifically, we use sparse autoencoders (SAEs) to extract concept activations from individual images. During selection, we accumulate the dataset-level concept support for each added sample. Applying diminishing returns to this distribution down-weights well-represented concepts and shifts the focus to the distribution tail. We then incorporate local support to find samples that reliably strengthen under-supported concepts. Empirical results show consistent improvements over strong data selection baselines across all benchmarks. We also reveal the connection between concepts our method enhances and the induced behavioral changes, including improved robustness against out-of-distribution and spurious contexts. This work establishes concept support, beyond individual sample importance, as a useful principle for data-efficient and robust learning.
Ziheng Zhang, Neha Hulkund, Colin Lee +7
University of Texas at Austin · The Ohio State University · Massachusetts Institute of Technology +2