Remembering Solomon Marcus

We audit the multimodal-physics evaluation pipeline end-to-end and document three undetected construction practices that distort how the field measures vision-language reasoning: train-eval contamination, translation drift, and MCQ saturation. (1) Public training pools (UGPhysics-Train, SciInstruct, MMK12) pass single-stage 5-gram-Jaccard audits with zero hits across all six public physics evals; a three-stage audit (Jaccard -> mxbai-embed-large cosine -> Haiku-4.5 LLM-judge) surfaces 134 near-duplicates and 4,846 paraphrase candidates in SciInstruct alone. (2) A 17-pp Sonnet 4.5 delta on 59 paired Estonian-English olympiad problems (30.5% vs. 13.6%; sign test p=0.011, McNemar p=0.021, paired bootstrap 95% CI [+5.1, +28.9] pp). (3) A 46-pp format-and-novelty gradient on identical Sonnet weights between MCQ (79.7% on PhyX) and open-ended olympiad evaluation (33.4% on PhysOlym-A). We release four artifacts addressing these gaps: PhysCorp-A (6,432-record three-stage-audited multimodal corpus), PhysR1Corp (2,268-record closed-form RL pool), PhysOlym-A (500-problem, 99.8% novel-source held-out olympiad eval with native difficulty labels and an EN/ET bilingual subset), and Physics-R1, a reference GSPO+DAPO recipe cold-started from Qwen3-VL-8B-Thinking. Across 3 seeds, Physics-R1 lifts the audited corpus over the 8B base by +18.3 pp on PhysOlym-A liberal (8.0 -> 26.3 +/- 1.7; 7.1 pp behind Sonnet 4.5), +15.7 pp on PhysReason (23.9 -> 39.6 +/- 6.4; ahead of Qwen3-VL-32B and Gemini 2.5 Pro), +6.9 pp on OlympiadBench-Physics (46.2 +/- 1.5), and +4.1 pp on PhyX MCQ (77.8 +/- 0.3).

Context. Metamorphic Testing addresses the test-oracle problem in scientific computing, but classical Mutation Score operates on syntactic AST mutations and misses domain semantics. Objective. We propose the Semantic Mutation Score (SMS), built on five domain-semantic operators (Conservation Erosion, Operator Substitution, Hyperparameter, Trajectory Flip, Structural Injection). SMS degenerates almost everywhere to MS in a characterised limit, so any SMS-based conclusion remains consistent with prior mutation-testing literature in the classical regime. Method. A 12-PUT x 5-MP design over four single-output float-to-float classes (numeric, probabilistic, surrogate, machine-learning) is paired with a three-layer attribution classifier separating true semantic faults from tolerance, OOD, statistical, and artefact categories. A same-source / cross-source ablation under an identical prompt isolates the LLM-source-diversity contribution. LLM-generated mutants are compared against a default-configuration cosmic-ray syntactic pool at the AST-normalised level. Results. The pre-registered large-effect threshold for Cliff's delta is not met under the point-estimate criterion; the observed effect lies in the medium-effect range. Cross-source pooling under an identical prompt does not appreciably shift delta, indicating that LLM identity is not the lever within this design. AST-level overlap between LLM-generated and default cosmic-ray syntactic mutants is small; the Hyperparameter, Structural Injection, and Trajectory Flip classes are unreachable under default first-order syntactic configurations. Conclusion. SMS is a backward-compatible adequacy metric for domain-semantic metamorphic-relation sets in scientific computing. The first-order unreachability evidence is independent of the effect-size question.

In 2016, Viazovska famously solved the sphere packing problem in dimension $8$, using modular forms to construct a 'magic' function satisfying optimality conditions determined by Cohn and Elkies in 2003. In March 2024, Hariharan and Viazovska launched a project to formalize this solution and related mathematical facts in the Lean Theorem Prover. A significant milestone was achieved in February 2026: the result was formally verified, with the final stages of the verification done by Math, Inc.'s autoformalization model 'Gauss'. We discuss the techniques used to achieve this milestone, reflect on the unique collaboration between humans and Gauss, and discuss project objectives that remain.