BAT-CLIP: Trimodal Alignment of Brain, Audio and Text
Authors: Suhyun Kim, Jinmo Han, Danny Dongyeop Han, Ahhyun Lucy Lee, Jewoon Lee, Yonghyeon Gwon, Zach Paris, Chun Kee Chung, Saewoong Bahk, Nam Soo Kim, Seong Jae Hwang, Jiook Cha
Organizations: Yonsei University, Seoul, Republic of Korea · Seoul National University, Seoul, Republic of Korea · Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH, USA
Decoding and interpreting naturalistic speech from the brain increasingly relies on alignment to pretrained speech and language representation spaces. However, current CLIP-style brain-speech alignment ground neural activity to a single anchor modality-audio or text-despite the brain's inherently multimodal speech processing. This induces a trade-off: audio anchoring preserves temporal structure but weakens linguistic separability, while text anchoring captures semantics yet discards acoustic detail. We propose BAT-CLIP, the first CLIP-style trimodal alignment framework for iEEG that jointly aligns neural embeddings to both pretrained audio and text anchors in a shared, frozen audio-text manifold. On the naturalistic Podcast benchmark, BAT-CLIP yields more robust representations than bimodal CLIP baselines. We also highlight the importance of using self-supervised foundation models for CLIP training.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1 : Overview of BAT-CLIP . A trainable brain encoder fθ , initialized from brain foundation model DIVER-1, maps neural windows to brain embeddings zB . Frozen AudioCLIP encoders provide audio anchors zA and text anchors zT . BAT-CLIP optimizes a trimodal contrastive objective LTotal to align neural embeddings with the joint audio–text representation space.
Method
Type
Content
Onset
POS
GPT Surprisal
Word Emb
Whisper
AUC
Δ
AUC
Δ
AUC
Δ
AUC
Δ
AvgAUC
Δ
Acc
Δ
CNN(Baseline) †
Sup
0.5498
–
0.7519
–
0.5653
–
0.5019
–
0.6260
–
0.6634
–
BrainBERT
SSL
0.5505
+0.13%
0.6341
-15.67%
0.5325
-5.80%
0.5157
+2.75%
0.5533
-11.61%
0.5805
-12.49%
PopT
SSL
0.4950
-9.97%
0.4654
-38.10%
0.5031
-11.00%
0.5022
+0.06%
0.5002
-20.10%
0.5014
-24.42%
DIVER-1
SSL
0.5645
+2.67%
0.7729
+2.79%
0.5656
+0.05%
0.5155
+2.71%
0.6450
+3.04%
0.7022
+5.85%
BA-CLIP
Align
0.5840
+6.31%
0.6560
-12.61%
0.5673
+0.32%
0.5169
+3.02%
0.6468
+4.26%
0.7141
+7.75%
Table 1: Overall decoding performance (averaged over 9 subjects). We report AUC for Content , Onset , POS , GPT surprisal , and Word Emb decoding, and accuracy for Whisper . Δ denotes relative gain over the supervised CNN baseline (baseline Δ : “–”). † indicates full fine-tuning (CNN); all other methods are evaluated via linear probing. BA-CLIP , BT-CLIP , and BAT-CLIP apply CLIP-style contrastive alignment on top of the pretrained DIVER-1 brain encoder, using brain–audio, brain–text, and trimodal brain–audio–text alignment, respectively. Overall, DIVER-1 is the strongest foundation-model baseline, CLIP alignment generally improves over DIVER-1, and BAT-CLIP achieves the best result among the aligned variants on five of six probe tasks. Bold and underline denote the best and second-best results within each column.
Method
Init.
Content
Onset
POS
GPT Surprisal
Word Emb
Whisper
AUC
Δ
AUC
Δ
AUC
Δ
AUC
Δ
AvgAUC
Δ
Acc
Δ
BA-CLIP
Scratch
0.5671
+3.14%
0.7792
+3.75%
0.5624
-0.35%
0.5143
+2.55%
0.6059
-2.33%
0.6609
+0.05%
DIVER-1
0.5840
+6.31%
0.6560
-12.61%
0.5673
+0.32%
0.5169
+3.02%
0.6468
+4.26%
0.7141
+7.75%
BT-CLIP
Scratch
0.5650
+2.85%
0.7822
+4.19%
0.5635
-0.18%
0.5120
+2.10%
0.6296
+1.52%
0.6607
-0.02%
DIVER-1
0.5813
+5.82%
0.6562
-12.56%
0.5709
+0.97%
0.5203
+3.69%
0.6510
+4.94%
0.7157
+7.98%
BAT-CLIP
Scratch
0.5586
+1.70%
0.7600
+0.94%
0.5480
-2.94%
0.5119
+2.09%
0.6123
-1.32%
0.6463
-2.36%
Table 2: Effect of pretraining across methods. We compare CLIP-aligned models trained from scratch (Scratch) versus the same models initialized with pretrained DIVER-1 weights, across unimodal alignments ( BA-CLIP : brain–audio; BT-CLIP : brain–text) and trimodal alignment ( BAT-CLIP : brain–audio–text). As in Table 1 , Δ denotes relative gain over the supervised CNN baseline (baseline Δ : “–”). Pretrained DIVER-1 initialization is key to realizing the gains from trimodal CLIP alignment; training from scratch largely fails to capitalize on brain–audio–text supervision.
Fig. 2 : Visualization of learned word-level representations. 2D t-SNE projection of brain embeddings extracted by various models for Sub03. Each point represents a single word-level embedding. The color of the point denotes the sentence to which the word belongs, and the shape indicates the speaker. Compared to the baselines, the proposed trimodal alignment model, BAT-CLIP , exhibits tighter clustering of words from the same sentence (shared colors), consistent with the sentence-level clustering results in Table 3 .
Method
Cosine Coherence ( ↑ )
Separation Ratio ( ↑ )
DIVER-1 (SSL)
0.0004
0.95
BA-CLIP
0.0789
1.09
BT-CLIP
0.0954
1.04
BAT-CLIP (Ours)
0.1572
1.23
Table 3: Quantitative clustering evaluation of word-level embeddings. We evaluate the structure of the learned embedding space for a representative subject (Sub03; Fig. 2 ) using sentence-level clustering metrics, where higher values indicate tighter grouping of word embeddings within the same sentence. The proposed trimodal alignment ( BAT-CLIP ) yields the strongest clustering compared to the unaligned foundation model (DIVER-1) and unimodal alternatives.
Electroencephalography (EEG) foundation models have shown promise for learning generalizable representations, yet they remain sensitive to channel heterogeneity, such as changes in channel composition or ordering. We propose channel-aware multimodal EEG-text alignment contrastive language-image pretraining (CAMEL-CLIP), a contrastive EEG-text multimodal foundation model designed to be robust to heterogeneous channel configurations and widely applicable to diverse downstream tasks. CAMEL-CLIP introduces three key components: (1) channel attribute-based positional encoding, which identifies channels through semantic information; (2) dynamic channel projection, which generates variable-length embeddings by independently projecting each channel without feature compression; and (3) dual-level contrastive learning, which jointly performs channel-level and sample-level contrastive learning to capture both channel-specific and global signal characteristics. Experimental results demonstrate that CAMEL-CLIP achieves state-of-the-art performance under linear-probing and outperforms existing foundation models that rely on full-finetuning.
Hanseul Choi, Jinyeong Park, Seongwon Jin +2
Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Incheon National University, Yeonsu-gu, 22012, Incheon, Republic of Korea · Department of Artificial Intelligence, Inha University, Michuhol-gu, 22212, Incheon, Republic of Korea · Center for Brain-Machine Interface, Incheon National University, Yeonsu-gu, 22012, Incheon, Republic of Korea
Reconstructing what a person perceives from their brain activity is a stringent test of whether neural recordings carry meaningful information. Naturalistic speech offers a rich testbed for this challenge: it unfolds over multiple timescales, but fMRI's noisy, temporally smeared measurements make this structure hard to recover. We introduce NOEMA, a temporal convolutional decoder that aligns windows of consecutive fMRI measurements with multimodal stimulus embeddings. These embeddings combine complementary text, audio, and speech representations of the same stimulus segment, enabling its retrieval directly from brain activity. On two naturalistic speech datasets, Cephalonauts One and LeBel, NOEMA retrieves the correct segment among 2,000 candidates within the top 10 for more than 42% of held-out queries. This substantially outperforms baseline decoders, an advantage that persists when the candidate pool is extended with thousands of distractors absent from training. Controlled ablations establish the contributions of temporal modeling and complementary stimulus representations.
Corentin Caris, Louis Jalouzot, Nona Rajabi +9
Karavela · UNICOG, CNRS, INSERM, CEA, Paris-Saclay University · LSCP, EHESS, ENS, CNRS, PSL University +1
Imagined speech decoding from EEG offers a promising route toward naturalistic brain-computer interfaces. Traditional closed-set classifiers treat semantic categories as independent labels and do not explicitly exploit relationships among linguistic intents, limiting output flexibility. We adapt a multimodal contrastive learning framework to imagined speech, aligning EEG trials with language representations in the embedding space of a frozen pretrained text encoder. An EEG encoder is trained with a composite objective combining semantically reweighted EEG-sentence alignment and text-prototype-based class discrimination, encouraging semantic structure while preserving separability among 39 intent categories. We evaluate the approach on the Chisco imagined speech dataset across five subjects, reporting Top-k accuracy, macro-F1, and balanced pairwise matching accuracy (2v2). We also investigate maximum EEG-text cosine similarity (MaxCosine) as an intrinsic indicator of decoding reliability and probe semantic structure beyond category labels using five evaluation-time semantic axes and a qualitative Semantic Gallery Probe (SGP) with previously unseen candidate sentences. The contrastive framework achieved decoding performance comparable to a task-optimized closed-set classifier while mapping EEG into a frozen language embedding space. MaxCosine identified subsets of held-out trials with higher Top-1 and Top-5 accuracy across subjects. Evaluation-time semantic axes showed mean agreement above the 50% chance reference across all five dimensions, and the SGP qualitatively illustrated direct comparison with unseen candidate sentences. Together, these findings suggest that EEG-language alignment can retain comparable fixed-intent decoding while supporting similarity-based retrieval, intrinsic reliability ranking, and evaluation of broader semantic structure.
Shahryar G. Namdari, Francesco Iacomi, Riccardo Barbieri +1
Department of Electronics, Information and Bioengineering, Politecnico di Milano, Milano, 20133, Italy