eess.ASSep 24, 2026

Oracle Complementarity Is Not Realizable Complementarity in Frozen-Encoder Audio-Visual Emotion Recognition

Authors: Benjamin Hurt

Organizations: University of California, Santa Barbara

Abstract

Complementarity analyses of multimodal systems commonly report an oracle ceiling (the fraction of examples on which at least one unimodal branch is correct) and interpret the gap between it and realized fusion accuracy as recoverable headroom. We show that this ceiling is not a fusion target. Using frozen self-supervised audio and visual encoders with a trained head, we measure the ceiling and realized gain on CREMA-D under two audio encoders (one whose fine-tuning lineage includes CREMA-D, one clean) and on EAV under the contaminated encoder. Replacing the fine-tuned encoder with a self-supervised one triples the headroom, from +0.055to +0.186. A second clean encoder and a controlled degradation of the contaminated one fall on the same curve, so provenance moves the headroom by changing audio-branch accuracy. Concatenation realizes at most about half of the headroom (converted fraction 0.55), and on EAV the converted fraction is indistinguishable from zero despite larger headroom. A learned router is beaten by plain concatenation everywhere. Oracle headroom measures branch disagreement, not a fusion budget.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Sep 25, 2026

Differential Attention Unlocks Complementary EEG and Speech Fusion for Emotion Recognition

Multimodal emotion recognition (MER) increasingly pairs EEG with speech, treating internal neural signals and external vocal expression as informative views of affect. In practice, naive fusion underperforms the stronger single modality, because EEG artifacts inject noise that corrupts the shared representation. We introduce EmoSpeechBrain, a multimodal framework built on the insight that noise suppression is a precondition for effective fusion. Its EEG encoder uses differential attention, taking the difference between two attention maps to cancel shared noise and isolate discriminative neural activity. An attention-based gating adapter aligns both modalities in a shared space and weights each one's contribution to the prediction. On two datasets - PME4 and EAV, EmoSpeechBrain improves MER accuracy by up to 12.9% over other state-of-the-art (SOTA) EEG encoders, and surpasses unimodal speech and EEG baselines by up to 13.1% and 23.1%. These results show that once EEG noise is suppressed, fusion delivers gains that naive combination cannot.
May 3, 2026

Delayed Commitment for Representation Readiness in Stage-wise Audio-Visual Learning

Stage-wise audio-visual encoders propagate fused intermediate states across layers, making the formation of later representations depend on the readiness of earlier fusion states. Strong local audio-visual agreement provides useful correspondence evidence, yet a fused state also needs sufficient cross-layer and cross-modal support before it can reliably guide later fusion. This paper studies this issue through propagation-aware representation readiness and formulates premature perceptual commitment as a readiness-deficiency problem, where local plausibility, propagation influence, and support insufficiency jointly appear at an intermediate stage. We propose the Delayed Perceptual Commitment Network (DPC-Net), an encoder-level framework that estimates an observable readiness-deficiency surrogate, localizes the intervention-sensitive bottleneck, and applies support-aware correction with cross-layer and cross-modal evidence. DPC-Net preserves task-specific heads, losses, decoding modules, and evaluation protocols, making it applicable to different audio-visual tasks through encoder-side intervention. Experiments on audio-visual speech separation, audio-visual event localization, and audio-visual speech recognition show consistent improvements across reconstruction, localization, and recognition regimes. Further analyses on component contribution, selection criteria, counterfactual intervention, and readiness trajectories support the effectiveness of readiness-guided bottleneck correction.
Mar 11, 2026

Multimodal Self-Attention Network with Temporal Alignment for Audio-Visual Emotion Recognition

Audio-visual emotion recognition (AVER) methods typically fuse utterance-level features, and even frame-level attention models seldom address the frame-rate mismatch across modalities. In this paper, we propose a Transformer-based framework focusing on the temporal alignment of multimodal features. Our design employs a multimodal self-attention encoder that simultaneously captures intra- and inter-modal dependencies within a shared feature space. To address heterogeneous sampling rates, we incorporate Temporally-aligned Rotary Position Embeddings (TaRoPE), which implicitly synchronize audio and video tokens. Furthermore, we introduce a Cross-Temporal Matching (CTM) loss that enforces consistency among temporally proximate pairs, guiding the encoder toward better alignment. Experiments on CREMA-D and RAVDESS datasets demonstrate consistent improvements over recent baselines, suggesting that explicitly addressing frame-rate mismatch helps preserve temporal cues and enhances cross-modal fusion.