Beyond Teacher Assignment: Domain-Normalized Multi-Teacher On-Policy Distillation

Multi-teacher on-policy distillation (MOPD) aims to combine the strengths of RL-trained teachers in a single student, but how teacher signals affect parameter changes remains underexplored. We study Qwen3-1.7B with four domain teachers trained with RL from the same initialization as the student, comparing gradients, optimizer updates, and task learning curves, with additional SmolLM3-3B diagnostics. We find that several factors influence teacher signals. First, loss averaging implicitly weights responses: token averaging favors longer responses, and equalizing domain contributions retains this weighting within domains. Second, Adam's first moment reduces differences in parameter updates: the cosine similarity is 0.83 between teachers and 0.96 between averaging rules, despite differences in raw gradients. Third, BF16 rounding hides small changes: about 97% of FP32 master weights differ from initialization, but only 7--11% of BF16 weights do. Finally, the top-64 intersection KL gradient closely matches Qwen's full-vocabulary gradient, but the effect on task performance depends on averaging: mathematics accuracy is 2.6 points higher than with sampled-token policy-gradient (PG) under response averaging and 2.1 points lower under global token averaging.

Specializing large language models to vertical domains improves domain-specific behavior but often degrades general capabilities. We study this trade-off in Multi-Teacher On-Policy Distillation (MOPD), where a specialized model learns from domain and general teachers on its own sampled trajectories. Standard MOPD faces two limitations: ordinary on-policy sampling rarely exposes tokens with large positive teacher--student advantages, and advantage sign alone does not establish whether the proposed update direction is reliable. We propose Uncertainty-Calibrated MOPD (UCMOPD), which addresses these limitations through two complementary mechanisms. Golden-Gain Enhancement combines higher-temperature exploration with a standard-temperature anchor and retains trajectories whose positive learning signal matches or exceeds the prompt-specific anchor. Teacher-Endorsement Filtering then uses centered log-likelihood (CLL) to estimate each retained token's plausibility relative to the teacher's uncertainty and probabilistically preserves updates whose directions are supported by that endorsement. Across role-playing and medical-domain specialization, UCMOPD improves the general-capability average over standard MOPD by $4.48\%$ and $7.86\%$, respectively, while maintaining vertical-domain performance. Component ablations and diagnostic analyses support the intended roles of the two mechanisms: exposing and selecting stronger positive signals at the trajectory level and validating update directions through teacher endorsement at the token level.

Multi-teacher on-policy distillation (MOPD) distills several domain-expert teachers into a single student by minimizing per-domain reverse-KL divergence on the student's own rollouts. Existing approaches typically fix the per-domain data mixture before training, overlooking the fact that different domains converge at substantially different rates: some plateau early while others continue to improve throughout the training budget. A fixed mixture therefore wastes compute on fast-converging domains and undertrains slower-converging ones. To address this, we propose D$^3$-MOPD (Dynamic Domain ScheDuling for MOPD), a zero-overhead scheduler that repurposes the per-domain reverse-KL signal already produced during training to adapt the domain mixture online. Running asynchronously outside the training process, an off-process watcher periodically tracks each domain's KL trajectory, estimates remaining headroom and current improvement rate, and accordingly adjusts the domain sampling ratios without altering the core training loop. Our D$^3$-MOPD scales naturally to arbitrary numbers of domains, and the expected benefit grows as more domains introduce more diverse convergence patterns for the scheduler to exploit. On a Qwen3.6-35B-A3B student distilled from four domain-expert teachers, D$^3$-MOPD closes 97% of the average student-to-teacher performance gap, compared with 63% for vanilla MOPD, reaches the same peak performance with an approximately 3$\times$ reduction in rollout steps, and surpasses the specialist teachers on three of seven benchmarks.