cs.IROct 13, 2026

Revisiting Generative vs. Dense Retrieval: A Static Value Prior Reverses the Gap

Authors: Renbo Tu, Yang Liu, Shuying Sun

Organizations: Shopify · University of Toronto

Abstract

Generative retrieval (GR) has emerged as a strong candidate generator for sequential recommendation as language models and semantic-item identifiers have improved. However, GR is not a uniformly stronger replacement of dense retrieval (DR) in online retail candidate generation. We examine their differences on two Amazon Toys datasets under different metrics. GR leads on best relevant item value among users both methods cover, while DR leads on exact-target recall and relevant value across the ranked list. With deep analysis, we find that popularity contributes the most to GR's measured value lead. Adding the same static item value to DR in one reranking step reverses this lead and keeps recall above GR. Finally, on an industrial-scale internal e-commerce dataset with LLM-judged relevance, we show that a 14B SID-LLM still underperforms a 47×47\times smaller dense encoder.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. GR2: Generative Reasoning Re-ranker

    Feb 8, 2026Mingfu Liang, Yufei Li, Jay Xu +20RL for Language ModelsRL for Recommendation

  2. GenRec: A Preference-Oriented Generative Framework for Large-Scale Recommendation

    Apr 16, 2026Yanyan Zou, Junbo Qi, Lunsong Huang +7RL for RecommendationGenerative Retrieval