Faithful Federated Tabular Data Synthesis
Organizations: School of Mathematics, Northwest University · Carlson School of Management, University of Minnesota
Abstract
Synthetic data is an important data source in the AI era. This paper studies the generation of mixed-type tabular synthetic data in federated settings, where two key challenges arise: ensuring distributional fidelity and effectively handling mixed-type data. We propose Federated Integrative Two-Step Synthesis (FITS), a framework for mixed-type tabular data synthesis. At its core is a two-step federated algorithm for estimating conditional cumulative distribution functions (CDFs) using local linear regression. Building on this algorithm, we develop a federated synthesis procedure based on the probability chain rule to ensure distributional fidelity. To handle mixed-type data, FITS introduces a continualization method that lifts discrete variables into a continuous space and recovers their discrete distributions without loss at both the density-function and CDF levels. This transformation provides a unified continuous representation of mixed-type variables, facilitating the application of local linear regression and synthetic data generation. Our theoretical analysis characterizes the conditional density and cumulative distribution functions of the continualized mixed-type variables and establishes the uniform convergence of the resulting federated conditional CDF estimators. Experiments demonstrate that FITS-generated synthetic data improves downstream task performance for all clients, with the benefits depending on how the synthetic data is used.
Figures & tables
| \begin{cases}\widehat{\bm{F}}(\bm{g}_{1})\text{ by Eq.~\eqref{eq:first_dim_kde}},&j=1,\\[2.84526pt] \widehat{\bm{F}}(\bm{g}_{j}\mid\hat{{\bm{x}}}_{b,:j-1}=(\hat{x}_{b,1},...,\hat{x}_{b,j-1}))\text{ by Algorithm~\ref{alg:two_step_fllr}},&j>1.\end{cases} |
| Simulation | Bike Sharing | Adult Income | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Task | Regression and classification | Regression | Classification |
| Data source | Synthetic DGP | UCI Bike Sharing | UCI Adult Income |
| Full sample size | |||
| Training sample size | |||
| Test sample size | |||
| Generated sample size |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | 4.6669 (0.3037) | |
| FedTabDiff | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | 1.3846 (0.5311) | |
| M2 | None | 0.0751 (0.0329) | 0.0930 (0.0385) | 0.1302 (0.0568) | 0.1446 (0.0698) | 0.1310 (0.0616) | 0.1541 (0.0704) | 0.1751 (0.0725) | 0.2063 (0.0856) | 0.2198 (0.1036) | 0.4730 (0.1856) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.1060 (0.0435) | 0.1225 (0.0549) | 0.1350 (0.0622) | 0.1406 (0.0620) | 0.1405 (0.0638) | 0.1413 (0.0629) | 0.1438 (0.0654) | 0.1467 (0.0663) | 0.1501 (0.0669) | 0.1545 (0.0682) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | 3.7460 (0.5029) | |
| FedTabDiff | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | 2.1627 (0.7893) | |
| M2 | None | 0.3923 (0.1852) | 0.5028 (0.2397) | 0.6821 (0.3112) | 0.8635 (0.3364) | 0.7619 (0.3377) | 0.8787 (0.4005) | 0.8757 (0.4659) | 1.0606 (0.5028) | 1.1961 (0.6224) | 10.6726 (16.6535) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.5117 (0.1249) | 0.5694 (0.1246) | 0.6281 (0.1209) | 0.6370 (0.1343) | 0.6446 (0.1351) | 0.6602 (0.1370) | 0.6615 (0.1381) | 0.6714 (0.1420) | 0.6681 (0.1364) | 0.6983 (0.1363) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | 0.7650 (0.0221) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | 0.8582 (0.0075) | |
| M2 | None | 0.8547 (0.0101) | 0.8406 (0.0093) | 0.8280 (0.0105) | 0.8278 (0.0115) | 0.8237 (0.0127) | 0.8242 (0.0123) | 0.8259 (0.0122) | 0.8246 (0.0135) | 0.8234 (0.0134) | 0.8193 (0.0235) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.8692 (0.0080) | 0.8672 (0.0070) | 0.8644 (0.0074) | 0.8645 (0.0075) | 0.8629 (0.0082) | 0.8638 (0.0072) | 0.8635 (0.0084) | 0.8634 (0.0081) | 0.8617 (0.0079) | 0.8603 (0.0081) |
| Variables | HeteroFedSyn | FedTabDiff | FITS-G |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.0702 (0.0084) | 0.1215 (0.0493) | 0.0392 (0.0079) | |
| 0.1074 (0.0073) | 0.1260 (0.0492) | 0.0429 (0.0076) | |
| 0.0752 (0.0074) | 0.1231 (0.0490) | 0.0409 (0.0079) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | 0.3068 (0.0503) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | 0.3077 (0.0708) | |
| M2 | None | 0.1059 (0.0711) | 0.1397 (0.0924) | 0.2044 (0.1343) | 0.2043 (0.1359) | 0.2331 (0.1749) | 0.2088 (0.1111) | 0.2900 (0.1840) | 0.3137 (0.1962) | 0.3291 (0.2270) | 0.6422 (0.4136) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.0933 (0.0370) | 0.0976 (0.0402) | 0.1138 (0.0442) | 0.1117 (0.0460) | 0.1126 (0.0413) | 0.1114 (0.0425) | 0.1186 (0.0406) | 0.1169 (0.0424) | 0.1173 (0.0399) | 0.1224 (0.0445) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | 0.7025 (0.0331) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | 0.6709 (0.0267) | |
| M2 | None | 0.6099 (0.0189) | 0.6106 (0.0189) | 0.6135 (0.0193) | 0.6140 (0.0190) | 0.6157 (0.0189) | 0.6152 (0.0196) | 0.6172 (0.0198) | 0.6192 (0.0200) | 0.6216 (0.0209) | 0.6582 (0.0274) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.6098 (0.0192) | 0.6101 (0.0192) | 0.6109 (0.0194) | 0.6107 (0.0195) | 0.6110 (0.0194) | 0.6110 (0.0194) | 0.6111 (0.0194) | 0.6111 (0.0195) | 0.6113 (0.0194) | 0.6116 (0.0194) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | 0.8725 (0.0907) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | 0.6221 (0.0552) | |
| M2 | None | 0.0687 (0.0060) | 0.0727 (0.0041) | 0.0896 (0.0065) | 0.0944 (0.0056) | 0.0990 (0.0070) | 0.1079 (0.0079) | 0.1154 (0.0107) | 0.1262 (0.0142) | 0.1522 (0.0192) | 0.4313 (0.0741) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.1150 (0.0122) | 0.1324 (0.0143) | 0.1636 (0.0177) | 0.1697 (0.0191) | 0.1732 (0.0152) | 0.1790 (0.0210) | 0.1840 (0.0212) | 0.1908 (0.0158) | 0.1984 (0.0210) | 0.2213 (0.0199) |
| Variables | HeteroFedSyn | FedTabDiff | FITS-G |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.0903 (0.0093) | 0.1247 (0.0260) | 0.0595 (0.0042) | |
| 0.1008 (0.0072) | 0.1244 (0.0253) | 0.0599 (0.0044) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | 0.7452 (0.2609) | |
| FedTabDiff | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | 2.3245 (0.1224) | |
| M2 | None | 0.2712 (0.1082) | 0.2810 (0.1239) | 0.4893 (0.2531) | 0.5538 (0.2660) | 0.5820 (0.2656) | 0.5930 (0.2823) | 0.6766 (0.2996) | 0.7805 (0.3195) | 0.7778 (0.4350) | 1.6560 (0.8013) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.7996 (0.1013) | 0.8844 (0.1078) | 0.9800 (0.1166) | 0.9865 (0.1158) | 0.9973 (0.1187) | 1.0069 (0.1231) | 1.0121 (0.1186) | 1.0249 (0.1155) | 1.0422 (0.1198) | 1.0822 (0.1207) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | 0.8179 (0.0036) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | 0.7821 (0.0083) | |
| M2 | None | 0.8204 (0.0031) | 0.8207 (0.0032) | 0.8204 (0.0036) | 0.8199 (0.0034) | 0.8202 (0.0028) | 0.8194 (0.0038) | 0.8196 (0.0034) | 0.8195 (0.0033) | 0.8189 (0.0038) | 0.8131 (0.0054) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.8201 (0.0029) | 0.8198 (0.0029) | 0.8195 (0.0032) | 0.8193 (0.0030) | 0.8193 (0.0030) | 0.8192 (0.0029) | 0.8192 (0.0029) | 0.8190 (0.0030) | 0.8190 (0.0030) | 0.8188 (0.0030) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | 0.8291 (0.0079) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | 0.8333 (0.0065) | |
| M2 | None | 0.8513 (0.0045) | 0.8506 (0.0040) | 0.8394 (0.0076) | 0.8353 (0.0086) | 0.8304 (0.0081) | 0.8290 (0.0079) | 0.8231 (0.0091) | 0.8176 (0.0068) | 0.8098 (0.0075) | 0.8015 (0.0102) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.8513 (0.0042) | 0.8513 (0.0039) | 0.8498 (0.0043) | 0.8498 (0.0044) | 0.8496 (0.0039) | 0.8493 (0.0045) | 0.8496 (0.0044) | 0.8491 (0.0045) | 0.8474 (0.0053) | 0.8485 (0.0048) |
| Variables | HeteroFedSyn | FedTabDiff | FITS-G |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.0551 (0.0017) | 0.2021 (0.0605) | 0.0543 (0.0023) | |
| 0.0552 (0.0017) | 0.2020 (0.0594) | 0.0539 (0.0023) |
Appendix figures & tables29 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
| Component | Specification | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Covariates | Chain order used to generate the synthetic covariate table. | |
| Linear task | The response is generated after the covariates. | |
| Logistic task | The response is generated after the same covariates. | |
| Parameter order | Coefficients are aligned with this ordering. | |
| True linear-model parameter | Ground-truth coefficient vector for the linear response model. | |
| True logistic-model parameter | Ground-truth coefficient vector for the logistic response model. |
| Bike Sharing | Adult Income | |
| Response | cnt , standardized | |
| Full sample size | ||
| Train/test split | ||
| Variable mapping | : temp : atemp : hum : windspeed : season : yr : mnth : hr : holiday : weekday : workingday : weathersit | : age : fnlwgt : capital-gain : capital-loss : hours-per-week : education-num : workclass : education : marital-status : occupation : relationship : race : sex : native-country |
| Continuous predictors | ||
| Discrete predictors |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) |
| FITS-K | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | 0.1721 (0.0580) | |
| M2 | None | 0.0751 (0.0329) | 0.0930 (0.0385) | 0.1302 (0.0568) | 0.1446 (0.0698) | 0.1310 (0.0616) | 0.1541 (0.0704) | 0.1751 (0.0725) | 0.2063 (0.0856) | 0.2198 (0.1036) | 0.4730 (0.1856) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.1060 (0.0435) | 0.1225 (0.0549) | 0.1350 (0.0622) | 0.1406 (0.0620) | 0.1405 (0.0638) | 0.1413 (0.0629) | 0.1438 (0.0654) | 0.1467 (0.0663) | 0.1501 (0.0669) | 0.1545 (0.0682) |
| FITS-K | 0.1140 (0.0398) | 0.1315 (0.0493) | 0.1462 (0.0526) | 0.1500 (0.0538) | 0.1511 (0.0542) | 0.1522 (0.0547) | 0.1565 (0.0560) | 0.1584 (0.0554) | 0.1635 (0.0550) | 0.1680 (0.0554) | |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) |
| FITS-K | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | 0.7289 (0.1278) | |
| M2 | None | 0.3923 (0.1852) | 0.5028 (0.2397) | 0.6821 (0.3112) | 0.8635 (0.3364) | 0.7619 (0.3377) | 0.8787 (0.4005) | 0.8757 (0.4659) | 1.0606 (0.5028) | 1.1961 (0.6224) | 10.6726 (16.6535) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.5117 (0.1249) | 0.5694 (0.1246) | 0.6281 (0.1209) | 0.6370 (0.1343) | 0.6446 (0.1351) | 0.6602 (0.1370) | 0.6615 (0.1381) | 0.6714 (0.1420) | 0.6681 (0.1364) | 0.6983 (0.1363) |
| FITS-K | 0.5252 (0.1168) | 0.5823 (0.1136) | 0.6448 (0.1178) | 0.6529 (0.1194) | 0.6603 (0.1237) | 0.6752 (0.1200) | 0.6779 (0.1286) | 0.6896 (0.1315) | 0.6856 (0.1328) | 0.7172 (0.1244) | |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) |
| FITS-K | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | 0.8603 (0.0082) | |
| M2 | None | 0.8547 (0.0101) | 0.8406 (0.0093) | 0.8280 (0.0105) | 0.8278 (0.0115) | 0.8237 (0.0127) | 0.8242 (0.0123) | 0.8259 (0.0122) | 0.8246 (0.0135) | 0.8234 (0.0134) | 0.8193 (0.0235) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.8692 (0.0080) | 0.8672 (0.0070) | 0.8644 (0.0074) | 0.8645 (0.0075) | 0.8629 (0.0082) | 0.8638 (0.0072) | 0.8635 (0.0084) | 0.8634 (0.0081) | 0.8617 (0.0079) | 0.8603 (0.0081) |
| FITS-K | 0.8695 (0.0084) | 0.8671 (0.0076) | 0.8638 (0.0080) | 0.8656 (0.0078) | 0.8637 (0.0076) | 0.8627 (0.0085) | 0.8640 (0.0077) | 0.8633 (0.0078) | 0.8608 (0.0083) | 0.8615 (0.0080) | |
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) | 0.1584 (0.0698) |
| M2 | – | 0.0751 (0.0329) | 0.0930 (0.0385) | 0.1302 (0.0568) | 0.1446 (0.0698) | 0.1310 (0.0616) | 0.1541 (0.0704) | 0.1751 (0.0725) | 0.2063 (0.0856) | 0.2198 (0.1036) | 0.4730 (0.1856) |
| M3 | 0.0751 (0.0329) | 0.0930 (0.0385) | 0.1302 (0.0568) | 0.1446 (0.0698) | 0.1310 (0.0616) | 0.1541 (0.0704) | 0.1751 (0.0725) | 0.2063 (0.0856) | 0.2198 (0.1036) | 0.4730 (0.1856) | |
| 0.0938 (0.0376) | 0.1082 (0.0464) | 0.1364 (0.0651) | 0.1582 (0.0761) | 0.1490 (0.0804) | 0.1616 (0.0748) | 0.1836 (0.0678) | 0.2218 (0.1041) | 0.2308 (0.0934) | 0.4392 (0.2013) | ||
| 0.0999 (0.0401) | 0.1184 (0.0481) | 0.1491 (0.0679) | 0.1544 (0.0687) | 0.1642 (0.0853) | 0.1580 (0.0759) | 0.1823 (0.0736) | 0.2009 (0.1022) | 0.2129 (0.0876) | 0.3802 (0.1548) | ||
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) | 0.7111 (0.1401) |
| M2 | – | 0.3923 (0.1852) | 0.5028 (0.2397) | 0.6821 (0.3112) | 0.8635 (0.3364) | 0.7619 (0.3377) | 0.8787 (0.4005) | 0.8757 (0.4659) | 1.0606 (0.5028) | 1.1961 (0.6224) | 10.6726 (16.6535) |
| M3 | 0.3923 (0.1852) | 0.5028 (0.2397) | 0.6821 (0.3112) | 0.8635 (0.3364) | 0.7619 (0.3377) | 0.8787 (0.4005) | 0.8757 (0.4659) | 1.0606 (0.5028) | 1.1961 (0.6224) | 10.6726 (16.6535) | |
| 0.4041 (0.1665) | 0.4679 (0.1653) | 0.5697 (0.2247) | 0.6907 (0.2742) | 0.6489 (0.2302) | 0.6532 (0.2362) | 0.7458 (0.3929) | 0.8008 (0.3280) | 0.8787 (0.3414) | 3.0192 (3.4075) | ||
| 0.4546 (0.1308) | 0.4850 (0.1498) | 0.5876 (0.2121) | 0.6201 (0.2102) | 0.6232 (0.2326) | 0.6382 (0.2552) | 0.6440 (0.3432) | 0.7573 (0.2600) | 0.7669 (0.2690) | 1.7311 (0.8331) | ||
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) | 0.8608 (0.0079) |
| M2 | – | 0.8547 (0.0101) | 0.8406 (0.0093) | 0.8280 (0.0105) | 0.8278 (0.0115) | 0.8237 (0.0127) | 0.8242 (0.0123) | 0.8259 (0.0122) | 0.8246 (0.0135) | 0.8234 (0.0134) | 0.8193 (0.0235) |
| M3 | 0.8547 (0.0101) | 0.8406 (0.0093) | 0.8280 (0.0105) | 0.8278 (0.0115) | 0.8237 (0.0127) | 0.8242 (0.0123) | 0.8259 (0.0122) | 0.8246 (0.0135) | 0.8234 (0.0134) | 0.8193 (0.0235) | |
| 0.8639 (0.0067) | 0.8486 (0.0097) | 0.8306 (0.0111) | 0.8251 (0.0121) | 0.8214 (0.0137) | 0.8187 (0.0139) | 0.8210 (0.0114) | 0.8208 (0.0128) | 0.8179 (0.0137) | 0.8115 (0.0229) | ||
| 0.8661 (0.0070) | 0.8566 (0.0088) | 0.8323 (0.0111) | 0.8295 (0.0097) | 0.8232 (0.0111) | 0.8191 (0.0111) | 0.8206 (0.0116) | 0.8167 (0.0138) | 0.8120 (0.0160) | 0.8078 (0.0217) | ||
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) |
| FITS-K | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | 0.1577 (0.0603) | |
| M2 | None | 0.1059 (0.0711) | 0.1397 (0.0924) | 0.2044 (0.1343) | 0.2043 (0.1359) | 0.2331 (0.1749) | 0.2088 (0.1111) | 0.2900 (0.1840) | 0.3137 (0.1962) | 0.3291 (0.2270) | 0.6422 (0.4136) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.0933 (0.0370) | 0.0976 (0.0402) | 0.1138 (0.0442) | 0.1117 (0.0460) | 0.1126 (0.0413) | 0.1114 (0.0425) | 0.1186 (0.0406) | 0.1169 (0.0424) | 0.1173 (0.0399) | 0.1224 (0.0445) |
| FITS-K | 0.1095 (0.0516) | 0.1169 (0.0508) | 0.1347 (0.0557) | 0.1350 (0.0556) | 0.1377 (0.0552) | 0.1373 (0.0568) | 0.1428 (0.0572) | 0.1440 (0.0595) | 0.1460 (0.0563) | 0.1551 (0.0602) | |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) |
| FITS-K | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | 0.6187 (0.0184) | |
| M2 | None | 0.6099 (0.0189) | 0.6106 (0.0189) | 0.6135 (0.0193) | 0.6140 (0.0190) | 0.6157 (0.0189) | 0.6152 (0.0196) | 0.6172 (0.0198) | 0.6192 (0.0200) | 0.6216 (0.0209) | 0.6582 (0.0274) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.6098 (0.0192) | 0.6101 (0.0192) | 0.6109 (0.0194) | 0.6107 (0.0195) | 0.6110 (0.0194) | 0.6110 (0.0194) | 0.6111 (0.0194) | 0.6111 (0.0195) | 0.6113 (0.0194) | 0.6116 (0.0194) |
| FITS-K | 0.6119 (0.0185) | 0.6130 (0.0186) | 0.6151 (0.0184) | 0.6153 (0.0186) | 0.6158 (0.0184) | 0.6158 (0.0185) | 0.6162 (0.0185) | 0.6166 (0.0185) | 0.6169 (0.0184) | 0.6182 (0.0185) | |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) |
| FITS-K | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | 0.2826 (0.0270) | |
| M2 | None | 0.0687 (0.0060) | 0.0727 (0.0041) | 0.0896 (0.0065) | 0.0944 (0.0056) | 0.0990 (0.0070) | 0.1079 (0.0079) | 0.1154 (0.0107) | 0.1262 (0.0142) | 0.1522 (0.0192) | 0.4313 (0.0741) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.1150 (0.0122) | 0.1324 (0.0143) | 0.1636 (0.0177) | 0.1697 (0.0191) | 0.1732 (0.0152) | 0.1790 (0.0210) | 0.1840 (0.0212) | 0.1908 (0.0158) | 0.1984 (0.0210) | 0.2213 (0.0199) |
| FITS-K | 0.1253 (0.0128) | 0.1524 (0.0140) | 0.1911 (0.0196) | 0.1988 (0.0215) | 0.2061 (0.0163) | 0.2148 (0.0225) | 0.2220 (0.0261) | 0.2336 (0.0237) | 0.2414 (0.0241) | 0.2753 (0.0256) | |
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) | 0.1240 (0.0443) |
| M2 | – | 0.1059 (0.0711) | 0.1397 (0.0924) | 0.2044 (0.1343) | 0.2043 (0.1359) | 0.2331 (0.1749) | 0.2088 (0.1111) | 0.2900 (0.1840) | 0.3137 (0.1962) | 0.3291 (0.2270) | 0.6422 (0.4136) |
| M3 | 0.1059 (0.0711) | 0.1397 (0.0924) | 0.2044 (0.1343) | 0.2043 (0.1359) | 0.2331 (0.1749) | 0.2088 (0.1111) | 0.2900 (0.1840) | 0.3137 (0.1962) | 0.3291 (0.2270) | 0.6422 (0.4136) | |
| 0.0872 (0.0571) | 0.1019 (0.0543) | 0.1626 (0.0885) | 0.1498 (0.0676) | 0.1713 (0.1141) | 0.1391 (0.0711) | 0.1881 (0.1157) | 0.2089 (0.1124) | 0.2287 (0.1309) | 0.4503 (0.2013) | ||
| 0.0871 (0.0389) | 0.0983 (0.0587) | 0.1493 (0.0802) | 0.1302 (0.0707) | 0.1179 (0.0663) | 0.1328 (0.0521) | 0.1719 (0.0813) | 0.1727 (0.0921) | 0.1821 (0.0818) | 0.3670 (0.1706) | ||
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) | 0.6117 (0.0195) |
| M2 | – | 0.6099 (0.0189) | 0.6106 (0.0189) | 0.6135 (0.0193) | 0.6140 (0.0190) | 0.6157 (0.0189) | 0.6152 (0.0196) | 0.6172 (0.0198) | 0.6192 (0.0200) | 0.6216 (0.0209) | 0.6582 (0.0274) |
| M3 | 0.6099 (0.0189) | 0.6106 (0.0189) | 0.6135 (0.0193) | 0.6140 (0.0190) | 0.6157 (0.0189) | 0.6152 (0.0196) | 0.6172 (0.0198) | 0.6192 (0.0200) | 0.6216 (0.0209) | 0.6582 (0.0274) | |
| 0.6095 (0.0191) | 0.6102 (0.0193) | 0.6125 (0.0195) | 0.6123 (0.0196) | 0.6133 (0.0190) | 0.6134 (0.0192) | 0.6144 (0.0196) | 0.6156 (0.0191) | 0.6176 (0.0194) | 0.6388 (0.0234) | ||
| 0.6097 (0.0192) | 0.6102 (0.0189) | 0.6116 (0.0195) | 0.6113 (0.0196) | 0.6123 (0.0193) | 0.6127 (0.0197) | 0.6130 (0.0188) | 0.6135 (0.0194) | 0.6154 (0.0201) | 0.6299 (0.0203) | ||
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) | 0.2348 (0.0209) |
| M2 | – | 0.0687 (0.0060) | 0.0727 (0.0041) | 0.0896 (0.0065) | 0.0944 (0.0056) | 0.0990 (0.0070) | 0.1079 (0.0079) | 0.1154 (0.0107) | 0.1262 (0.0142) | 0.1522 (0.0192) | 0.4313 (0.0741) |
| M3 | 0.0687 (0.0060) | 0.0727 (0.0041) | 0.0896 (0.0065) | 0.0944 (0.0056) | 0.0990 (0.0070) | 0.1079 (0.0079) | 0.1154 (0.0107) | 0.1262 (0.0142) | 0.1522 (0.0192) | 0.4313 (0.0741) | |
| 0.0935 (0.0091) | 0.1047 (0.0092) | 0.1467 (0.0123) | 0.1597 (0.0171) | 0.1661 (0.0204) | 0.1760 (0.0186) | 0.1970 (0.0202) | 0.2112 (0.0231) | 0.2334 (0.0240) | 0.4408 (0.0804) | ||
| 0.1077 (0.0108) | 0.1215 (0.0133) | 0.1578 (0.0167) | 0.1751 (0.0173) | 0.1848 (0.0244) | 0.1994 (0.0196) | 0.2175 (0.0233) | 0.2352 (0.0261) | 0.2596 (0.0254) | 0.4393 (0.0654) | ||
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) |
| FITS-K | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | 1.2821 (0.0896) | |
| M2 | None | 0.2712 (0.1082) | 0.2810 (0.1239) | 0.4893 (0.2531) | 0.5538 (0.2660) | 0.5820 (0.2656) | 0.5930 (0.2823) | 0.6766 (0.2996) | 0.7805 (0.3195) | 0.7778 (0.4350) | 1.6560 (0.8013) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.7996 (0.1013) | 0.8844 (0.1078) | 0.9800 (0.1166) | 0.9865 (0.1158) | 0.9973 (0.1187) | 1.0069 (0.1231) | 1.0121 (0.1186) | 1.0249 (0.1155) | 1.0422 (0.1198) | 1.0822 (0.1207) |
| FITS-K | 0.9506 (0.0771) | 1.0472 (0.0796) | 1.1552 (0.0915) | 1.1634 (0.0879) | 1.1752 (0.0891) | 1.1857 (0.0927) | 1.1962 (0.0903) | 1.2082 (0.0856) | 1.2248 (0.0852) | 1.2697 (0.0898) | |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) |
| FITS-K | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | 0.8174 (0.0030) | |
| M2 | None | 0.8204 (0.0031) | 0.8207 (0.0032) | 0.8204 (0.0036) | 0.8199 (0.0034) | 0.8202 (0.0028) | 0.8194 (0.0038) | 0.8196 (0.0034) | 0.8195 (0.0033) | 0.8189 (0.0038) | 0.8131 (0.0054) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.8201 (0.0029) | 0.8198 (0.0029) | 0.8195 (0.0032) | 0.8193 (0.0030) | 0.8193 (0.0030) | 0.8192 (0.0029) | 0.8192 (0.0029) | 0.8190 (0.0030) | 0.8190 (0.0030) | 0.8188 (0.0030) |
| FITS-K | 0.8195 (0.0031) | 0.8191 (0.0032) | 0.8184 (0.0032) | 0.8185 (0.0032) | 0.8181 (0.0030) | 0.8182 (0.0030) | 0.8182 (0.0030) | 0.8180 (0.0030) | 0.8178 (0.0030) | 0.8176 (0.0030) | |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) |
| FITS-K | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | 0.8465 (0.0038) | |
| M2 | None | 0.8513 (0.0045) | 0.8506 (0.0040) | 0.8394 (0.0076) | 0.8353 (0.0086) | 0.8304 (0.0081) | 0.8290 (0.0079) | 0.8231 (0.0091) | 0.8176 (0.0068) | 0.8098 (0.0075) | 0.8015 (0.0102) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.8513 (0.0042) | 0.8513 (0.0039) | 0.8498 (0.0043) | 0.8498 (0.0044) | 0.8496 (0.0039) | 0.8493 (0.0045) | 0.8496 (0.0044) | 0.8491 (0.0045) | 0.8474 (0.0053) | 0.8485 (0.0048) |
| FITS-K | 0.8507 (0.0038) | 0.8499 (0.0048) | 0.8487 (0.0039) | 0.8484 (0.0043) | 0.8475 (0.0044) | 0.8477 (0.0049) | 0.8482 (0.0040) | 0.8476 (0.0052) | 0.8461 (0.0042) | 0.8467 (0.0042) | |
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) | 1.0930 (0.1225) |
| M2 | – | 0.2712 (0.1082) | 0.2810 (0.1239) | 0.4893 (0.2531) | 0.5538 (0.2660) | 0.5820 (0.2656) | 0.5930 (0.2823) | 0.6766 (0.2996) | 0.7805 (0.3195) | 0.7778 (0.4350) | 1.6560 (0.8013) |
| M3 | 0.2712 (0.1082) | 0.2810 (0.1239) | 0.4893 (0.2531) | 0.5538 (0.2660) | 0.5820 (0.2656) | 0.5930 (0.2823) | 0.6766 (0.2996) | 0.7805 (0.3195) | 0.7778 (0.4350) | 1.6560 (0.8013) | |
| 0.4937 (0.1383) | 0.5016 (0.1498) | 0.6129 (0.2177) | 0.5926 (0.2377) | 0.6516 (0.2328) | 0.6575 (0.2170) | 0.6018 (0.2645) | 0.6413 (0.2764) | 0.7271 (0.3544) | 1.3037 (0.5863) | ||
| 0.6709 (0.1233) | 0.6605 (0.1319) | 0.7212 (0.2112) | 0.7154 (0.2037) | 0.7412 (0.2095) | 0.7044 (0.2303) | 0.6906 (0.2636) | 0.7160 (0.3141) | 0.8068 (0.2605) | 1.2527 (0.6042) | ||
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) | 0.8187 (0.0030) |
| M2 | – | 0.8204 (0.0031) | 0.8207 (0.0032) | 0.8204 (0.0036) | 0.8199 (0.0034) | 0.8202 (0.0028) | 0.8194 (0.0038) | 0.8196 (0.0034) | 0.8195 (0.0033) | 0.8189 (0.0038) | 0.8131 (0.0054) |
| M3 | 0.8204 (0.0031) | 0.8207 (0.0032) | 0.8204 (0.0036) | 0.8199 (0.0034) | 0.8202 (0.0028) | 0.8194 (0.0038) | 0.8196 (0.0034) | 0.8195 (0.0033) | 0.8189 (0.0038) | 0.8131 (0.0054) | |
| 0.8204 (0.0032) | 0.8205 (0.0031) | 0.8204 (0.0034) | 0.8202 (0.0033) | 0.8201 (0.0028) | 0.8199 (0.0036) | 0.8196 (0.0033) | 0.8196 (0.0033) | 0.8191 (0.0039) | 0.8152 (0.0046) | ||
| 0.8202 (0.0030) | 0.8204 (0.0031) | 0.8202 (0.0034) | 0.8199 (0.0033) | 0.8199 (0.0030) | 0.8195 (0.0035) | 0.8198 (0.0032) | 0.8193 (0.0036) | 0.8188 (0.0039) | 0.8163 (0.0047) | ||
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) | 0.8478 (0.0039) |
| M2 | – | 0.8513 (0.0045) | 0.8506 (0.0040) | 0.8394 (0.0076) | 0.8353 (0.0086) | 0.8304 (0.0081) | 0.8290 (0.0079) | 0.8231 (0.0091) | 0.8176 (0.0068) | 0.8098 (0.0075) | 0.8015 (0.0102) |
| M3 | 0.8513 (0.0045) | 0.8506 (0.0040) | 0.8394 (0.0076) | 0.8353 (0.0086) | 0.8304 (0.0081) | 0.8290 (0.0079) | 0.8231 (0.0091) | 0.8176 (0.0068) | 0.8098 (0.0075) | 0.8015 (0.0102) | |
| 0.8526 (0.0040) | 0.8498 (0.0050) | 0.8444 (0.0062) | 0.8445 (0.0054) | 0.8397 (0.0065) | 0.8369 (0.0074) | 0.8318 (0.0068) | 0.8268 (0.0076) | 0.8181 (0.0076) | 0.7954 (0.0112) | ||
| 0.8514 (0.0049) | 0.8501 (0.0044) | 0.8475 (0.0041) | 0.8451 (0.0047) | 0.8438 (0.0051) | 0.8425 (0.0051) | 0.8382 (0.0056) | 0.8329 (0.0083) | 0.8242 (0.0087) | 0.7942 (0.0106) | ||
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | 3.5888 (0.3499) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | 0.7209 (0.1486) | |
| M2 | None | 0.4926 (0.0113) | 0.4942 (0.0111) | 0.4968 (0.0115) | 0.4970 (0.0120) | 0.4975 (0.0116) | 0.4997 (0.0123) | 0.5015 (0.0135) | 0.5032 (0.0133) | 0.5057 (0.0126) | 0.5602 (0.0375) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.4938 (0.0120) | 0.4947 (0.0120) | 0.4956 (0.0123) | 0.4958 (0.0123) | 0.4960 (0.0125) | 0.4960 (0.0124) | 0.4962 (0.0125) | 0.4963 (0.0124) | 0.4966 (0.0126) | 0.4969 (0.0127) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | 0.8147 (0.0184) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | 0.8687 (0.0058) | |
| M2 | None | 0.8763 (0.0054) | 0.8760 (0.0055) | 0.8748 (0.0055) | 0.8736 (0.0058) | 0.8745 (0.0058) | 0.8738 (0.0059) | 0.8727 (0.0058) | 0.8722 (0.0065) | 0.8705 (0.0077) | 0.8488 (0.0177) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.8763 (0.0056) | 0.8761 (0.0056) | 0.8762 (0.0058) | 0.8758 (0.0059) | 0.8760 (0.0059) | 0.8760 (0.0057) | 0.8762 (0.0058) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8760 (0.0060) | 0.8760 (0.0059) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) |
| HeteroFedSyn | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | 5.5571 (0.9458) | |
| FedTabDiff | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | 0.7994 (0.1271) | |
| M2 | None | 0.5567 (0.0273) | 0.5889 (0.0319) | 0.7232 (0.0644) | 0.7731 (0.0580) | 0.8112 (0.0694) | 0.8747 (0.0853) | 0.9386 (0.1001) | 1.0237 (0.0881) | 1.1248 (0.1095) | 1.4740 (0.2824) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.5625 (0.0341) | 0.5688 (0.0345) | 0.5777 (0.0468) | 0.5756 (0.0371) | 0.5806 (0.0384) | 0.5763 (0.0269) | 0.5970 (0.0547) | 0.5820 (0.0376) | 0.5748 (0.0277) | 0.5910 (0.0437) |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) |
| FITS-K | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | 0.4986 (0.0124) | |
| M2 | None | 0.4926 (0.0113) | 0.4942 (0.0111) | 0.4968 (0.0115) | 0.4970 (0.0120) | 0.4975 (0.0116) | 0.4997 (0.0123) | 0.5015 (0.0135) | 0.5032 (0.0133) | 0.5057 (0.0126) | 0.5602 (0.0375) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.4938 (0.0120) | 0.4947 (0.0120) | 0.4956 (0.0123) | 0.4958 (0.0123) | 0.4960 (0.0125) | 0.4960 (0.0124) | 0.4962 (0.0125) | 0.4963 (0.0124) | 0.4966 (0.0126) | 0.4969 (0.0127) |
| FITS-K | 0.4944 (0.0118) | 0.4955 (0.0118) | 0.4966 (0.0120) | 0.4967 (0.0120) | 0.4969 (0.0122) | 0.4971 (0.0121) | 0.4974 (0.0121) | 0.4975 (0.0121) | 0.4978 (0.0123) | 0.4982 (0.0124) | |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) |
| FITS-K | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0055) | |
| M2 | None | 0.8763 (0.0054) | 0.8760 (0.0055) | 0.8748 (0.0055) | 0.8736 (0.0058) | 0.8745 (0.0058) | 0.8738 (0.0059) | 0.8727 (0.0058) | 0.8722 (0.0065) | 0.8705 (0.0077) | 0.8488 (0.0177) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.8763 (0.0056) | 0.8761 (0.0056) | 0.8762 (0.0058) | 0.8758 (0.0059) | 0.8760 (0.0059) | 0.8760 (0.0057) | 0.8762 (0.0058) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8760 (0.0060) | 0.8760 (0.0059) |
| FITS-K | 0.8765 (0.0054) | 0.8763 (0.0053) | 0.8763 (0.0054) | 0.8761 (0.0057) | 0.8762 (0.0053) | 0.8761 (0.0054) | 0.8761 (0.0052) | 0.8761 (0.0056) | 0.8761 (0.0055) | 0.8759 (0.0054) | |
| Mode | Baselines | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | FITS-G | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) |
| FITS-K | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | 0.6358 (0.0519) | |
| M2 | None | 0.5567 (0.0273) | 0.5889 (0.0319) | 0.7232 (0.0644) | 0.7731 (0.0580) | 0.8112 (0.0694) | 0.8747 (0.0853) | 0.9386 (0.1001) | 1.0237 (0.0881) | 1.1248 (0.1095) | 1.4740 (0.2824) |
| M3 | FITS-G | 0.5625 (0.0341) | 0.5688 (0.0345) | 0.5777 (0.0468) | 0.5756 (0.0371) | 0.5806 (0.0384) | 0.5763 (0.0269) | 0.5970 (0.0547) | 0.5820 (0.0376) | 0.5748 (0.0277) | 0.5910 (0.0437) |
| FITS-K | 0.5714 (0.0423) | 0.5757 (0.0258) | 0.5883 (0.0368) | 0.5934 (0.0364) | 0.6013 (0.0440) | 0.5951 (0.0382) | 0.6050 (0.0395) | 0.6055 (0.0391) | 0.5987 (0.0392) | 0.6189 (0.0497) | |
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) | 0.4971 (0.0127) |
| M2 | – | 0.4926 (0.0113) | 0.4942 (0.0111) | 0.4968 (0.0115) | 0.4970 (0.0120) | 0.4975 (0.0116) | 0.4997 (0.0123) | 0.5015 (0.0135) | 0.5032 (0.0133) | 0.5057 (0.0126) | 0.5602 (0.0375) |
| M3 | 0.4926 (0.0113) | 0.4942 (0.0111) | 0.4968 (0.0115) | 0.4970 (0.0120) | 0.4975 (0.0116) | 0.4997 (0.0123) | 0.5015 (0.0135) | 0.5032 (0.0133) | 0.5057 (0.0126) | 0.5602 (0.0375) | |
| 0.4934 (0.0117) | 0.4947 (0.0112) | 0.4978 (0.0119) | 0.4979 (0.0118) | 0.4979 (0.0118) | 0.5005 (0.0120) | 0.5023 (0.0146) | 0.5037 (0.0133) | 0.5074 (0.0138) | 0.5500 (0.0358) | ||
| 0.4937 (0.0121) | 0.4953 (0.0118) | 0.4964 (0.0114) | 0.4979 (0.0128) | 0.4982 (0.0132) | 0.4994 (0.0126) | 0.5017 (0.0144) | 0.5024 (0.0122) | 0.5057 (0.0142) | 0.5400 (0.0294) | ||
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) | 0.8759 (0.0059) |
| M2 | – | 0.8763 (0.0054) | 0.8760 (0.0055) | 0.8748 (0.0055) | 0.8736 (0.0058) | 0.8745 (0.0058) | 0.8738 (0.0059) | 0.8727 (0.0058) | 0.8722 (0.0065) | 0.8705 (0.0077) | 0.8488 (0.0177) |
| M3 | 0.8763 (0.0054) | 0.8760 (0.0055) | 0.8748 (0.0055) | 0.8736 (0.0058) | 0.8745 (0.0058) | 0.8738 (0.0059) | 0.8727 (0.0058) | 0.8722 (0.0065) | 0.8705 (0.0077) | 0.8488 (0.0177) | |
| 0.8763 (0.0054) | 0.8761 (0.0055) | 0.8753 (0.0057) | 0.8743 (0.0055) | 0.8749 (0.0059) | 0.8746 (0.0059) | 0.8731 (0.0060) | 0.8732 (0.0061) | 0.8719 (0.0067) | 0.8570 (0.0114) | ||
| 0.8764 (0.0056) | 0.8762 (0.0054) | 0.8758 (0.0058) | 0.8750 (0.0059) | 0.8753 (0.0055) | 0.8751 (0.0060) | 0.8745 (0.0055) | 0.8742 (0.0054) | 0.8733 (0.0067) | 0.8632 (0.0115) | ||
| Mode | Parameters | Clients | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Client 0 (30%) | Client 1 (20%) | Client 2 (10%) | Client 3 (9%) | Client 4 (8%) | Client 5 (7%) | Client 6 (6%) | Client 7 (5%) | Client 8 (4%) | Client 9 (1%) | ||
| M1 | – | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) | 0.6028 (0.0433) |
| M2 | – | 0.5567 (0.0273) | 0.5889 (0.0319) | 0.7232 (0.0644) | 0.7731 (0.0580) | 0.8112 (0.0694) | 0.8747 (0.0853) | 0.9386 (0.1001) | 1.0237 (0.0881) | 1.1248 (0.1095) | 1.4740 (0.2824) |
| M3 | 0.5567 (0.0273) | 0.5889 (0.0319) | 0.7232 (0.0644) | 0.7731 (0.0580) | 0.8112 (0.0694) | 0.8747 (0.0853) | 0.9386 (0.1001) | 1.0237 (0.0881) | 1.1248 (0.1095) | 1.4740 (0.2824) | |
| 0.5646 (0.0365) | 0.5899 (0.0343) | 0.6999 (0.0600) | 0.7414 (0.0689) | 0.7943 (0.0727) | 0.8534 (0.1054) | 0.9549 (0.1172) | 1.0441 (0.1100) | 1.2009 (0.1289) | 1.5537 (0.2274) | ||
| 0.5654 (0.0329) | 0.5804 (0.0322) | 0.6707 (0.0498) | 0.6957 (0.0524) | 0.7449 (0.0674) | 0.7833 (0.0765) | 0.8586 (0.1190) | 0.9823 (0.1009) | 1.1235 (0.1313) | 1.6559 (0.2200) | ||
Synthetic Data Generation
Synthetic data generation creates artificial examples, simulations, and datasets to train, test, or protect machine-learning systems.
See all 625 papers