cs.LGNov 2, 2026

Efficient Closure Learning in Dynamical Systems: A Comparison of Data-Assimilated and Embedded Approaches

Authors: Rileigh Bandy, Teresa Portone, Mohammad Khalil, Eric Crislip, Kyle Neal

Organizations: Sandia National Laboratories · Department of Statistics, The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio

Abstract

Increased computing power has transformed computational science and improved predictive capabilities for complex systems, but many phenomena still exceed current simulation capabilities or require rapid evaluations for fast design iterations. Closure models address this challenge by approximating unresolved effects in reduced or incomplete dynamical systems. Data-driven closures offer a flexible mechanism for improving model accuracy and applicability, but approaches that embed the closure within a computational model for construction and training phases can be computationally expensive and cause numerical instabilities in the computational model during training. To avoid the challenges posed by embedded approaches, staged approaches to closure-model learning have been developed. The first stage uses data assimilation to infer state and closure trajectories from observations. The second stage trains a machine learning closure model offline using the assimilated data, thereby avoiding repeated simulator calls during training. In this work, we investigate the cost and accuracy tradeoffs between embedded and staged data-driven closure modeling approaches for a synthetic epidemiological SIQR model with a nonlinear state-dependent quarantine closure. The results illustrate a practical accuracy-efficiency trade-off: for this exemplar, embedded training provides the strongest average accuracy, while the staged approach yields comparable qualitative behavior with a moderate increase in error, substantially fewer model evaluations, and improved optimization robustness.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. Score-Based Stochastic Closure Modeling via Offline Indirect Learning and Online Data Assimilation

    Nov 15, 2026Xinghao Dong, Huchen Yang, Jin-Long WuReduced-Order ModelingData Assimilation

  2. Learning Closure of Dynamical Systems with Kernel Ridge Regression

    Oct 1, 2026Evan Habbershaw, John Harlim, Senwei LiangPDE Surrogate ModelingNonlinear System Identification

  3. Deep Learning of Solver-Aware Turbulence Closures from Nudged LES Dynamics

    Apr 26, 2026Ashwin Suriyanarayanan, Dibyajyoti Chakraborty, Romit MaulikPhysics-Informed MLComputational Fluid Dynamics