cs.LGNov 5, 2026

PINNeval: A Comprehensive Evaluation Standard for Physics-Informed Neural Networks

Authors: Kevin von Bargen, Hamid Ebrahimy, Tim Römer

Organizations: Joint Lab Artificial Intelligence and Data Science, Osnabrück University, Osnabrück, Germany

Abstract

The Physics-Informed Neural Network (PINN) literature has produced a rapidly expanding catalogue of methods. We divide a PINN training pipeline systematically into four components and observe that many existing benchmarks study these components in isolation. These components are domain-importance adaptation, loss balancing, neural network architecture, and optimization scheme. Moreover, the studies set the surrounding and not considered components of the pipeline to a minimal default that is no longer representative of current best practice approaches. Conclusions drawn under such conditions may not transfer to competitive pipelines. In this work, we propose a new evaluation protocol that (1) treats the four components as an integrated system; (2) crucially requires competitive implementations of the components not under investigation; (3) specifies the metrics and reporting format; and (4) is accompanied by structured documentation that ensures the traceability of evaluations across studies. Based on this comprehensive protocol, we release PINNpipe, an innovative JAX package containing 18 different methods from the current literature as well as nine efficiently implemented benchmark problems. Using PINNpipe, we illustrate our evaluation protocol in relation to established benchmark studies and report results that challenge common assumptions.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables29 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

Apr 17, 2026

PINNACLE: An Open-Source Computational Framework for Classical and Quantum PINNs

We present PINNACLE, an open-source computational framework for physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) that integrates modern training strategies, multi-GPU acceleration, and hybrid quantum-classical architectures within a unified modular workflow. The framework enables systematic evaluation of PINN performance across benchmark problems including 1D hyperbolic conservation laws, incompressible flows, and electromagnetic wave propagation. It supports a range of architectural and training enhancements, including Fourier feature embeddings, random weight factorization, strict boundary condition enforcement, adaptive loss balancing, curriculum training, and second-order optimization strategies, with extensibility to additional methods. We provide a comprehensive benchmark study quantifying the impact of these methods on convergence, accuracy, and computational cost, and analyze distributed data parallel scaling in terms of runtime and memory efficiency. In addition, we extend the framework to hybrid quantum-classical PINNs and derive a formal estimate for circuit-evaluation complexity under parameter-shift differentiation. Results highlight the sensitivity of PINNs to architectural and training choices, confirm their high computational cost relative to classical solvers, and identify regimes where hybrid quantum models offer improved parameter efficiency. PINNACLE provides a foundation for benchmarking physics-informed learning methods and guiding future developments through quantitative assessment of their trade-offs.
Aug 26, 2026

Neither Precision Nor Architecture Alone: Controlled Tests of Failure Remedies for Physics-Informed Neural Networks

Physics-Informed Neural Networks (PINNs) frequently fail on stiff or advection-dominated PDEs, and two recent accounts offer competing remedies: switching from FP32 to FP64 to repair an L-BFGS stopping artifact, or replacing the MLP with a state-space-model (SSM) backbone plus sub-sequence alignment to counter architectural simplicity bias. We test both under matched, seed-paired controls in a pre-registered 144-run study spanning convection, reaction, and wave, plus an independent 85-run convection/wave study; success is relative ℓ2\ell_2 error below 0.050.05. The two remedies act on disjoint regime-and-seed slices: neither substitutes for the other. On hard convection (β=50β{=}50), alignment recovers 2/5 seeds in FP32 and 3/5 in FP64, where the unaligned SSM succeeds on 0/5 seeds at either precision and the vanilla MLP moves only from 0/5 to 1/5 across the precision switch---the recoveries trace to the alignment objective, not the backbone. On reaction the backbone alone already succeeds on 3/5--4/5 seeds, so each remedy covers a regime the other does not. Responses are also seed-specific: the same precision switch flips individual seeds in opposite directions and, on wave, lowers median error with no statistically significant success gain. Tightening the inner L-BFGS tolerance in an independent repeated-step runner likewise lowers median error at a large runtime cost, with success counts unchanged. Precision, stopping, backbone, and alignment must therefore be evaluated jointly and reported per seed.
Sep 19, 2026

PINNForge: Execution-Grounded Evolutionary Design of Physics-Informed Neural Networks

Physics-informed neural networks (PINNs) require coordinated choices across representation, architecture, sampling, constraints, loss construction, and optimization, yet effective configurations can vary substantially across partial differential equations (PDEs). Existing automated design methods search over these choices, but training outcomes are still used primarily to rank candidates rather than to inform subsequent designs. We develop PINNForge, an execution-grounded large language model (LLM)-driven evolutionary framework that treats observed PINN training behavior as a cross-generation design signal. PINNForge initializes diverse configurations from PDE-related prior knowledge, executes them, retains globally strong configurations, and feeds their execution evidence and accumulated run-level experience back to the LLM. The LLM then revises and recombines coupled design components or explores new combinations within a generate--execute--evaluate--evolve loop. Across 25 PDE benchmarks, PINNForge achieves the lowest mean MSE on 24 tasks among RoPINN, PINNsFormer, PINNsAgent, and PINNForge. Removing knowledge guidance, execution feedback, or evolutionary search increases the median task-wise MSE ratio to 3.74×\times, 12.10×\times, and 10.10×\times, respectively, relative to full PINNForge.