cs.CYNov 6, 2026

Functional Dependency beyond Similarity: Hierarchical Decomposition of Training Data Attribution in Music Generative Models

Authors: Changheon Han, Hugh Xuechen Liu, Ashkan Panahi, Kıvanç Tatar

Organizations: Chalmers University of Technology and University of Gothenburg, Department of Computer Science and Engineering, Gothenburg, Sweden

Abstract

Copyright analysis focuses on the similarity between two works. However, generative AI models learn from training data through functional relations beyond similarity. Training Data Attribution (TDA) estimates the influence of each training instance on a generated output and may serve as a basis for remuneration. However, prior studies find global influence, where a few training instances rank as the most influential for almost every generation. Used directly, TDA scores would distribute part of every remuneration to these instances regardless of what was generated. To address this, we propose a new approach in which TDA scores are decomposed into three levels of influence, namely global indicating the influence of a training data to a trained model, group for its influence on a group of generated outputs (that could be clustered together), and specific for its influence on a single generated output. Our study finds that, across several music generative models and TDA methods, global- and group-level influence is non-negligible in every case. Based on these observations, we propose the term functional dependency for the relation of training data to a trained model or to its outputs. This notion both encompasses and distinguishes dependencies of different scopes, allowing TDA scores to be interpreted as distinct forms of contribution in legal, economic and ethical discussions on remuneration.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables10 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

May 15, 2026

ARIA: A Diagnostic Framework for Music Training Data Attribution

Training data attribution (TDA) for music generation must answer two questions that copyright analysis requires, namely which training songs influence a generated output and along which musical aspects the influence operates. Existing methods reduce influence to a single scalar, without revealing which musical aspects are dominant in that influence. We propose ARIA, a framework that decomposes attribution along musical aspects (five for symbolic music, three for audio) and pairs the decomposition with reliability diagnostics computed from the segment-level score matrix. It measures within-group similarity among the top-K attributed tracks against random reference groups drawn from the training pool, and diagnoses the score matrix through its singular value decomposition and column statistics. On a symbolic-music model where attribution ground truth is available through counterfactual retraining, the reliability diagnostics rank four attribution methods identically to that ground truth. On an audio music generation model, ARIA reveals attribution behaviors that vary substantially across TDA methods, flags score matrices whose retrieved tracks are nearly identical across queries rather than reflecting per-query attribution, and characterizes embedding-similarity retrieval baselines by the musical aspect each encoder surfaces. Together, ARIA produces per-aspect attribution evidence aligned with the musical aspects considered under the idea-expression distinction in copyright analysis.
Jul 1, 2026

What's a Credit Worth? A Market Framework for Attribution-Aware Compensation in Generative Music

Advances in generative AI are rapidly increasing the quality and commercial value of generated music, and this progress depends on large catalogs of creators' recordings. This raises a central question for platform design: how should creators be compensated when their work is used to train generative AI models that in turn produce commercial outputs? We develop a framework for fairly compensating creators in generative-music markets, where each creator's payment depends on a data-attribution score estimating their contribution to model outputs. Compared to past compensation frameworks, our framework has two unique considerations: (1) attribution is traced to entire creator catalogs, not individual songs, and (2) the informativeness (signal-to-noise ratio) of the attribution score is an input to the payment mechanism. The framework yields a closed-form payment rule per creator and measures the welfare cost of inaccurate attribution for both creators and the platform. Whether the welfare-optimal contract is royalty-based or takes the form of fixed-fee licensing depends on how informative attribution is for that creator's catalog. We show that better attribution translates directly into welfare gains for both creators and the platform, yet under multi-platform competition a platform only captures gains from attribution improvements when its signal becomes the most precise in the market. To ground our framework in empirical behavior, we train acoustic and symbolic music generation models and measure the informativeness of scalable attribution techniques against a leave-one-catalog-out ground truth. Our experiments reveal that noisy attribution signals push payment toward fixed-fee licensing and diminish welfare for both creators and the platform, providing an economic motivation for further research on improved attribution.
Oct 7, 2026

Tracing Inputs, Verifying Outputs: Validating Attribution in Music Generation

How can we verify whose music contributed to an AI-generated output? This paper demonstrates how input-based attribution can provide verifiable evidence of which audio sources were used in a generation and whether they shaped the output. To do so, we condition the generation solely on audio without any text input, then trace the inputs behind each output, and establish their musical effect. In prompt adherence tests and controlled input swaps, the stems generated by our generator, MixAudio, follow the prompt audio in timbre and the context audio in harmony. Yet these outputs may still reproduce training data not supplied as inputs. We therefore audit memorization with our musical version identification model, musicDNA, and find few reproductions outside the input records. On human-judged cases within the flagged pool, it achieves higher precision and recall than the other tested memorization detectors. The two evaluations suggest that input records and output analysis provide complementary evidence for attribution, on which rights-holder reporting and compensation can draw as the AI music economy takes shape. Audio examples are available at https://neutune.github.io/attr2027demo/