cs.CLNov 6, 2026

Policy Over Purpose: Auditing LLM Content Moderation of Reclaimed Slur Usage

Authors: Christina Chance, Kai-Wei Chang

Organizations: University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA, USA

Abstract

As Perspective API is deprecated, platforms are turning to large language models for content moderation, encoding policy as natural language that the model must interpret at inference time. Reclaimed slurs test this design directly. The same term can express in-group pride or target the community that reclaimed it, and misreading it silences the speech moderation is meant to protect. We audit four general-purpose LLMs and four moderation-specific systems, with Perspective API as a legacy baseline, on IYKYK, a corpus of reclaimed and derogatory usage of three slurs annotated by community members. Across the policy, decision, reasoning, disparity, and steering layers of this audit, we find that whether a system was purpose-built for moderation explains little about how it handles reclaimed language. No system reliably agrees with community judgment, and all fail most on language reclaimed within Black communities. What separates systems is instead how their policy is represented. Only systems whose policy is expressed in the prompt can be steered at all, and even then, explicit definitions change how models justify a decision more than how they make it. We argue that policy transparency determines whether moderation failures can be corrected, but that correcting them requires contextual judgment that definitions supplied at inference time cannot provide.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables24 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

CardsList
  1. IYKYK (But AI Doesn't): Automated Content Moderation Does Not Capture Communities' Heterogeneous Attitudes Towards Reclaimed Language

    Apr 17, 2026Christina Chance, Rebecca Pattichis, Arjun Subramonian +4Social Media AnalysisAnnotator Disagreement

  2. Mod-Guide: An LLM-based Content Moderation Feedback System to Address Insensitive Speech toward Indigenous Ethnic and Religious Minority Communities

    Jun 11, 2026Dipto Das, Achhiya Sultana, Ankit Singh Chauhan +5Content ModerationCultural Bias in Language Models

  3. Evaluating Criterion-Conditioned Behaviour of Large Language Models in Content Moderation

    Sep 3, 2026Danting Zhang, Bei Peng, Robert LoftinLLM Safety BenchmarksLLM Evaluation