cs.CVNov 9, 2026

Where Does Proposal Selection Fail? Diagnosing Frozen Vision-Language Queries over Detector Proposals

Authors: Bo Ma, Weiqi Yan, Jinsong Wu

Organizations: Auckland University of Technology · Guilin University of Electronic Technology

Abstract

In modular grounding a frozen detector proposes regions and a vision-language model (VLM) selects one, at lower cost than letting the VLM decode a box, but it is unclear where such systems fail. We hold perception fixed---every trained selector chooses among the same frozen proposals, which contain the referent for at least 99.8%99.8\% of RefCOCO/+/g queries---and vary the selection interface one factor at a time for two VLMs of one family (Qwen2.5-VL-7B, Qwen3-VL-8B). On RefCOCOg, what the selector reads matters more than how it is built: the VLM's image-conditioned query encodes the referent's location and beats a text-only query by 0.150.15--0.180.18 with every head tested (by less for InternVL3-8B, whose vision encoder differs; one head tested). The remaining errors are rankings among a few top candidates; a cross-attention selector supervised with every valid box reaches the VLM's coordinate decoding on RefCOCOg, and with Qwen2.5-VL on RefCOCO/+ when also trained on their data. Beyond that distribution it does not: on Ref-L4's Objects365 images, mostly of categories outside training, every trained head falls to 0.190.19--0.280.28 while Qwen decoding keeps about 0.80.8 (InternVL3's drops too), neither a wider detector prompt nor a class-agnostic proposer closes the gap, and on public reasoning benchmarks Ref-Adv-s and RefBench-PRO full-budget heads trail decoding by 0.190.19--0.370.37 although proposals cover most referents. A trained verifier reduces to an existence probe on the VLM's query state and does not beat the VLM's yes/no answer on public no-target benchmarks.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Jun 27, 2026

HKVLM: Faithful Query--Region Binding for Frozen-Detector Visual Grounding

Visual grounding often fails even when the target object is present in the proposal pool, because the language-side referent is bound to the wrong region. We study this binding failure under frozen perception and ask whether an explicit query--region alignment hook, together with a perception-grounded abstention mechanism, can improve faithful grounding without retraining the detector or the vision-language backbone. HKVLM freezes a language-aligned open-vocabulary detector for localization and learns a lightweight hook that maps referential query embeddings to detector proposals in a shared space; a verifier abstains when no region sufficiently supports the query. We prove an exact proposal-level diagnostic decomposition, (1−SeeErr)(1−SayErr)(1-\mathrm{SeeErr})(1-\mathrm{SayErr}), separating proposal-coverage failures from conditional binding failures, and a monotonicity result that characterizes the faithfulness--recall trade-off induced by abstention. Across RefCOCO, RefCOCO+, RefCOCOg, and POPE, HKVLM improves over untrained and trained matched-perception binding controls and substantially reduces hallucination through abstention. Strong coordinate-decoding and end-to-end fine-tuned baselines remain much higher in raw grounding accuracy, and a reasoning-stress set exposes binding as the main current bottleneck. We therefore present HKVLM as a diagnostic and mechanism-level study of query--region binding under frozen perception, not as an absolute localization leader.
Apr 18, 2026

Prompt Sensitivity in Vision-Language Grounding: How Small Changes in Wording Affect Object Detection

Vision-language models enable open-vocabulary object grounding through natural language queries, under the implicit assumption that semantically equivalent descriptions yield consistent outputs. We examine this assumption using a controlled pipeline combining DETR for object proposals with CLIP for language-conditioned selection on 263 COCO val2017 images. We find that overlapping prompts such as "a person," "a human," and "a pedestrian" frequently select different instances, with mean instability of 2.11 distinct selections across six prompts. PCA analysis shows this variability is structured and directional, not random. Prompt ensembling does not improve quality and often shifts selections toward generic regions. We further show that text embedding proximity explains only 34% of grounding disagreement (r = -0.58), confirming that instability arises from the argmax selection mechanism rather than text-level distances alone.
Oct 26, 2026

LOCUS: Locate Once, Check Until Settled. Draft-and-Verify Visual Grounding with a Box Head and Coordinate-Token Verification

Vision-language models (VLMs) ground a referring expression in one of two ways. They decode the box as coordinate tokens, which is precise but takes one sequential step per token, or they regress it from a hidden state with a small head, which takes one step but loses accuracy at high IoU. The two fail differently: a head usually finds the right object but places its edges loosely, while coordinate tokens place edges precisely. We therefore use the regression head as a speculative drafter for the model's own coordinate tokens. Locus writes the head's box as coordinate tokens and checks them with the same backbone by Jacobi iteration over a shared image prefix. The fixed point is the model's greedy coordinate-token answer, reached in about 5.60 sequential passes on average instead of 18.46 decoding steps; head and verifier are one set of weights, trained jointly. On the 8 RefCOCO, RefCOCO+ and RefCOCOg splits, verification raises Locus-2B's [email protected] from 54.87 for its own head to 59.13, and the one-pass head is ahead at [email protected] of every published model with at most 3B parameters except Florence-2-L. Against Jag, the strongest open regression-head model, at its own size and training budget, Locus ties at [email protected] and, with typical acceptance, gains +4.52 points at [email protected], with paired significance tests. Exact answers come 1.5x faster than vLLM greedy-decoding the same coordinate tokens with the same weights; a pure regression head remains faster still.