stat.MLNov 9, 2026

From Granger causality to causal structure in dynamical systems

Authors: Víctor Elvira

Organizations: Basque Centre for Applied Mathematics (BCAM), Bilbao, Spain · the School of Mathematics, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK.

Abstract

The idea of testing whether the past of one signal improves the prediction of another can be traced back to Wiener. It was Granger who formalized the concept. Granger causality has become one of the most widely used tools to infer directed interactions between the components of a system. The name however can be misleading: it detects predictive relations among the measured signals, not causal relations among the mechanisms that generate them. This article starts by reviewing recent advances in observation-space Granger analysis. It then follows a path to directed structure in latent dynamical models, and asks under which conditions that structure can be read causally.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Oct 22, 2025

Learning Granger Causality under Latent Confounding via Intervention-Induced Heterogeneity

Granger causality characterizes directed predictive dependencies in multivariate time series, but recovering such dependencies becomes challenging in the presence of latent confounding. Cross-environment invariance provides a natural source of information in heterogeneous settings, yet invariance alone can be insufficient: when latent-to-observed mechanisms remain stable, hidden confounders can induce predictive dependencies that are just as invariant as genuine Granger-causal relations. We show that interventions provide an additional source of identifying information by inducing structured variation in observed mechanisms, while stable latent pathways need not exhibit the same cross-environment changes. In practice, however, neither the intervened environments nor the affected mechanisms are known. We propose GRACE, a framework for learning Granger causality under latent confounding from intervention-induced heterogeneity. GRACE decomposes multivariate dynamics into a shared Granger mechanism, sparse environment-specific deviations that capture edge-level interventions, and a latent component that accounts for confounding. Under a linear generative model, we show that GRACE can recover which environments intervene on a given edge when the edge is perturbed in at least one but fewer than half of the environments and the intervention effect is sufficiently large to survive sparsity shrinkage; the recovered intervention pattern then provides a certificate for the corresponding Granger causal edge. Experiments on synthetic and real-world time series demonstrate improved Granger causal structure recovery under latent confounding and unknown interventions.
May 9, 2026

Prediction Bottlenecks Don't Discover Causal Structure (But Here's What They Actually Do)

A Mamba state-space model trained only for next-step prediction appears to recover Granger-causal structure through a simple readout S=∣WoutWin∣S = |W_{out} W_{in}|, with early experiments suggesting the phenomenon generalized across architectures and benefited from interventional data at p<10−5p < 10^{-5}. We package the protocol used to test that claim -- standardized synthetic generators (VAR/Lorenz/CauseMe-style), three intervention semantics (do(X=c)do(X=c), soft-noise, random-forcing), edge-provenance cards on three real datasets, and size-matched control arms -- as a reusable falsification benchmark, and walk the claim through it in five stages. The method-level claim does not survive: (i) a plain linear bottleneck does as well or better; (ii) tuned Lasso beats the bottleneck on synthetic CauseMe-style benchmarks, and on Lorenz-96 (the only real benchmark with unambiguous ground truth) classical PCMCI and Granger lead a tight cluster in which the bottleneck trails; (iii) the headline intervention advantage is roughly 60% a sample-size confound, and the residual disappears under standard do(X=c)do(X=c) interventions, surviving only under a non-standard random-forcing scheme; (iv) even that residual reproduces, with a larger effect, in classical bivariate Granger -- the effect is method-agnostic. What survives is a narrow characterization result; the benchmark is the lasting artifact, and each stage above is one of its control arms.
Mar 26, 2026

Causal-INSIGHT: Probing Temporal Models to Extract Causal Structure

Understanding directed temporal interactions in multivariate time series is essential for interpreting complex dynamical systems and the predictive models trained on them. We present Causal-INSIGHT, a model-agnostic, post-hoc interpretation framework for extracting model-implied (predictor-dependent), directed, time-lagged influence structure from trained temporal predictors. Rather than inferring causal structure at the level of the data-generating process, Causal-INSIGHT analyzes how a fixed, pre-trained predictor responds to systematic, intervention-inspired input clamping applied at inference time. From these responses, we construct directed temporal influence signals that reflect the dependencies the predictor relies on for prediction, and introduce Qbic, a sparsity-aware graph selection criterion that balances predictive fidelity and structural complexity without requiring ground-truth graph labels. Experiments across synthetic, simulated, and realistic benchmarks show that Causal-INSIGHT generalizes across diverse backbone architectures, maintains competitive structural accuracy, and yields significant improvements in temporal delay localization when applied to existing predictors.