cs.CLNov 10, 2026

Framing-Induced Vulnerability in Large Language Models: Evidence from Chinese News Headlines

Authors: Mo Zhou, Yiwei Zhang

Organizations: Nanjing Normal University · Communication University of China

Abstract

Large language models increasingly evaluate, route, and moderate news, so a model's judgment of a headline has become a gatekeeping decision. We ask whether that judgment follows the fact being reported or the way the fact is framed. We combine an ecological audit of 63,926 Chinese news headlines with a controlled experiment. The experiment covers 30 real events, 30 synthetic events, and 29 natural headline pairs, tested on four Chinese models. Changing only the headline frame shifted both perceived misleadingness and event severity, and the direction and ordering of the shifts were the same for DeepSeek, MiMo, Dots, and LongCat. Emotionally intensified headlines raised severity ratings by 0.65 to 0.88 points, whereas positively reframed headlines lowered them by 0.34 to 0.52 points. Supplying the article body reduced this severity bias by 54 to 80 percent, and all four reductions were significant at p < .01. A small human reference study showed the same direction of effect. Headline-only LLM evaluation therefore carries a measurable robustness gap, and framing sensitivity belongs among the reliability properties that deployment and governance check.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Jul 22, 2026

Sympathetic Framing: Evaluating AI Alignment across Sociodemographic Groups

Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly shaping how we consume information and form our worldview. This raises concerns beyond bias in AI: do LLMs grasp the emotional nuances conveyed via textual framing? In this work, we empirically evaluate how well an array of LLMs aligns with human emotional perception. Considering news headlines covering political and geopolitical conflicts, both human participants (n = 3011, a representative sample of the U.K. adult population, via a YouGov survey) and seven LLMs answered whether headlines evoked sympathy for a specified side in a conflict. We find that the correlation between AI and human evaluations varies across models, ranging from very high (0.789, GPT-5.2) to medium (0.4 ,Mistral Large 2512). Crucially, the leading models are broadly aligned with human judgments across all demographic subgroups, including age, gender, level of education, prior geopolitical knowledge, and participants' predispositions regarding the conflict, although there are statistically significant differences between groups. This research, with its robust design and large, demographically diverse dataset, offers the most comprehensive evaluation of LLMs' comprehension of news framing to date. Findings highlight an important, often-ignored aspect of differential alignment: even when aggregate performance is high, AI alignment is not universal -- it may correspond differently with demographic features and cultural norms. Considering or ignoring the need for differential alignment may therefore have significant implications for the development of ethical and useful AI systems.
Sep 10, 2026

Recognizing Is Not Reversing: A Controlled Inversion Test of Fact-Preserving News Framing

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used to analyze and rewrite news, yet current framing studies mainly evaluate generation, detection, or whether rewritten text appears more neutral. They do not directly show whether a model can undo a known framing transformation while keeping the facts fixed. We introduce a controlled inversion test over three established textual realizations of framing: evaluative lexis, agency realization, and information salience. Across 60 news articles and three intervention strengths, this yields 540 paired variants with preserved atomic facts and recorded edits. Across Qwen, DeepSeek, and Kimi, factual preservation remains near 0.84, whereas intervention reversal is 0.044--0.068. Even when both framing type and direction are recognized correctly, pooled reversal reaches 0.071. These results reveal a clear separation between factual fidelity, framing recognition, and framing inversion: recognizing how an article is framed does not imply that the framing can be undone.
Aug 12, 2026

Framing by Wording, Framing by Selection: A Large-Scale Two-Dimensional Audit of French News Headlines, 2022-2025

News headlines frame public issues both by what they select and by how they word it, yet computational framing work typically collapses these operations into a single score. We introduce a two-dimensional framework that separates salience framing, measured through four wording devices (loaded vocabulary, blame attribution, threat framing, rhetorical question), from selection framing, measured through outlet-level story-form and high-charge distributions. We build a 10,000-headline French supervision set using three LLM annotators with majority-vote resolution and human arbitration, validate the labels against two annotator-independent blind human studies, and apply the strongest classifier to 902,111 deduplicated headlines from 25 French outlets (2022-2025). Three main findings emerge. First, salience and selection divergence are positively correlated yet leave nearly half of outlet-level variance unexplained, populating interpretively distinct off-diagonal cells in a four-cell outlet typology. Second, default classification thresholds systematically inflate corpus-level salience estimates; a precision-floor recalibration protocol corrects this distortion. Third, group-mention analysis reveals sharply unequal salience contexts: headlines mentioning Jews, the Far-right, and Muslims carry the highest detected salience rates, which broad event-context composition does not fully explain (residuals are descriptive, not same-event causal estimates; per-group lexicon precision is reported alongside). To our knowledge, this is the largest framing-focused French headline audit to date; we release the supervision set, lexicons, and analysis code.