cs.SDNov 10, 2026

Navigating relational agency in AI feedback musicianship: a diffractive dialogue

Authors: Yichen Wang, Charles Patrick Martin, David Gunawan, David Cooper

Organizations: The Australian National University, Australia · Dolby Laboratories, Australia

Abstract

Musical AI systems behave in non-linear, dynamic ways that exceed the tool-oriented framings inherited from earlier instrument design. Existing frames of control and ensemble interaction do not articulate the entangled, relational agency that emerges when performers work with AI feedback instruments over time. We examine a duet practice with two AI-enabled feedback instruments, Sù and Agentier, in which feedback operates at the inner level of the AI's recurrent processes and the outer loop of musical interaction between performer, instrument, and co-performer. Our work draws on agential realism and a diffractive dialogue methodology to read our independent reflections through one another across five performances, examining how agency is enacted between performers and AI instruments. We find that control and agency are relational and shift across performances; musical textures enact feedback moments of control with performers; reaching a productive feedback environment is itself a shared exploratory act; and performers maintain their instruments through funnelling and injection, developing the skill of navigating agency along a continuous spectrum. Feedback musicianship with AI instruments demands navigation of this relational agency, displacing the leading-versus-responding binary that initially framed our reflections. This work contributes a materially-grounded vocabulary for AI feedback musicianship and a model of human-AI creative collaboration in which mutual agency is worked for through practice rather than designed in.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Apr 28, 2026

Huí Sù: Co-constructing a Dual Feedback Apparatus

This performance presents a duet between two intelligent musical instruments, Sù (to trace back; to go upstream) and Agentier (playing on agentic clavier), and their human performers, connected through feedback loops. Rather than treating AI as a tool that responds predictably to input, both systems operate recursively, where past actions continuously influence future behaviour. The Sù operates in the audio space through latent representation. Its performer uses Make Noise 0-series synthesisers and MIDI controllers to work with a neural feedback synthesis system based on a RAVE model, with a latent feedback loop embedded within the model's internal structure. This allows the instrument to remember and reuse its own internal states, influencing ongoing sound generation through its recent sonic history. The Agentier functions in the control space. Its performer interacts with the system using a Roland S-1 synthesiser and Keith McMillen QuNeo touchpad, where control gestures are routed into a recurrent neural network that feeds back into the synthesis process. Through this feedback loop, the system actively shapes the evolution of control signals over time. Contrasting feedback in the audio and control domains, the performance explores shared agency, resistance, and negotiation between humans and intelligent musical systems. Musical phenomena are co-produced through the entangled states of interaction, rather than through pre-existing system configuration or fixed mappings.
Aug 7, 2026

Beyond Call and Response: Modelling Reciprocal Coordination in Human-AI Vocal Ensembles

Musical interaction with AI is often organised as a response loop: a human performs, the system interprets that action, and the system answers, accompanies, or schedules a musical event. Unconducted vocal ensembles pose a different problem. Singers act simultaneously and continuously affect one another; neither timing nor pitch is fixed by a conductor, metronome, accompaniment, score, or tuning source. Collective organisation emerges from many-to-many reciprocal adjustment. This paper frames such ensembles as coupled dynamic systems and proposes a research architecture for vocal agents that enter, rather than merely track, their collective states. Some target repertoires are metrical, while others exhibit non-isochronous temporal contours that cannot be reduced to a beat grid; we treat the latter as a hard case for a general framework. The architecture connects multichannel capture in the field to dialect- and singing-aware representation, collective-state inference, vocal generation, and in-situ evaluation. The resulting agenda asks not only whether an artificial singer can synchronise, but how its presence reorganises human coordination, leadership, style, and musical transmission.
Nov 2, 2026

CrowdForge: Effects of Audio and Visual Audience Participation Modalities on Agency, Collaboration, and Engagement in AI-Mediated MR Performances

Technology-mediated audience participation (TMAP) enables audiences to influence live performances, yet balancing interaction with meaningful agency remains challenging. While AI-generated music and MR enable new forms of audio and visual audience participation, little is known about how these participation modalities influence audience experiences during live musical performance. In particular, it remains unclear how they shape perceived agency, collaboration, and engagement, and how they complement one another within TMAP systems. We present CrowdForge, an AI- and MR-mediated paradigm where audiences collectively control generative music and virtual environments during a live performance featuring a guitarist and DJ. Through a mixedmethods concert study evaluating three interaction conditions (audio, visual, and combined audio-visual), we demonstrate that observability is the primary driver of audience agency. While visual interaction provided easily observable feedback, audio parameters offered macro-structural control over the music. Audiences tended to use the control enabled by AI audio generation to test musical boundaries, introducing a productive adversarial tension between the crowd and the musicians. This dynamic pushed creative limits, deepened engagement, and generated moments of musical coherence when performers successfully resolved audience-induced challenges. We argue future TMAP systems should prioritize human-centered, highly observable interactions to build agency, while combining the expressiveness of music with the clarity of visual feedback.