math.OCNov 10, 2026

Two Communities, One Problem: Branch-and-Bound vs. A* for Resource-Constrained Project Scheduling

Authors: Izack Cohen, Dominik Kress, Lara Nehrke, Erwin Pesch, Shimrit Shtern

Organizations: Faculty of Engineering, Bar-Ilan University, Max and Anna Webb Street, Ramat Gan 5290002, Israel · Business Administration, especially Procurement and Production, Helmut Schmidt University/University of the Federal Armed Forces Hamburg, Friedrich-Ebert-Damm 245, D-22159 Hamburg, Germany · Management Information Science, University of Siegen, Kohlbettstr. 15, D-57072 Siegen, Germany

Abstract

Branch-and-Bound (B&B) and A∗A^* are popular exact search methods originating from Operations Research and Artificial Intelligence, respectively. Although the two methods share fundamental search principles, their different ways of exploring the search space can lead to substantially different computational performance. We investigate these differences using the Resource-Constrained Project Scheduling Problem (RCPSP) as an exemplary problem setting. We first establish the relationships between mixed-integer linear programming, state-action, and timed Petri-net representations. Since B&B and A∗A^* admit numerous algorithmic enhancements, we focus on relatively basic implementations. This allows us to examine the fundamental differences between the methods rather than compare the performance of state-of-the-art solvers. By using the same lower bound and best-first node selection, we isolate the effects of the search mechanisms, particularly the identification of equivalent states reached through different scheduling decision sequences. Experiments on 480 benchmark RCPSP instances show that graph-based A∗A^* substantially outperforms the B&B variants considered. With additional pruning rules, A∗A^* proves optimality for all 480 instances, compared with 445 for best-first B&B under the same time and memory limits. Depth-first B&B uses less memory and can find feasible solutions even when the search does not finish within the time limit. Stronger linear programming relaxations reduce the search space but introduce considerable computational overhead. Our findings highlight the importance of duplicate-state detection and clarify the computational trade-offs between the search approaches. These insights can help researchers select an appropriate method and identify opportunities to incorporate effective mechanisms from one approach into the other.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables3 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

May 15, 2026

Petri Net Induced Heuristic Search for Resource Constrained Scheduling

We formulate the Resource-Constrained Project Scheduling Problem (RCPSP) as optimal search over the reachability graph of a Timed Transition Petri Net with Resources, using relative-delay tokens so that scheduling decisions correspond to transition firings in the induced state space. We solve the resulting problem with A∗A^* guided by a heuristic that combines Critical Path and resource-based lower bounds, and prove that it is consistent under our token-based time semantics. Experiments on the PSPLIB benchmarks show that the approach outperforms strong exact Mixed-Integer Linear Programming (MIP) baselines (SCIP, CBC) in both success rate and solve time. Per-instance analysis shows that heuristic search and MIP degrade along independent axes, resource tightness for A∗A^* and formulation size for MIP, with resource strength mediating which solver benefits from scale.
Jan 10, 2026

Resource-constrained Project Scheduling with Time-of-Use Energy Tariffs and Machine States: A Logic-based Benders Decomposition Approach

In this paper, we investigate the Resource-Constrained Project Scheduling Problem (RCPSP) with Time-of-Use (TOU) energy tariffs and machine states, a variant of RCPSP for production scheduling, where energy price is part of the criteria and one highly energy-demanding machine can be in one of the following three states: proc, idle, or off. The problem involves scheduling all tasks, respecting precedence constraints and resource limitations, while minimizing the combination of the overall makespan and the Total Energy Cost (TEC), which varies according to the TOU tariffs, which can take negative values. We propose two novel approaches to solve it: a monolithic Constraint Programming (CP) approach and a Logic-Based Benders Decomposition (LBBD) approach. The latter combines a master problem handling the energy cost solved using Integer Linear Programming (ILP) with a subproblem handling the RCPSP, resolved using CP. Both approaches outperform the monolithic compact ILP counterpart, but the LBBD significantly outperforms the monolithic CP in most cases, especially when the makespan criterion is not included in the objective function, solving to optimality instances with up to 480 tasks. Finally, we propose a way to generalize our LBBD approach to other problems sharing similar characteristics, and applied it to various problems, such as an RCPSP with blocking times & total weighted tardiness criterion, or a flexible job shop.
Feb 17, 2026

On inferring cumulative constraints

Cumulative constraints are central in scheduling with constraint programming, yet propagation is typically performed per constraint, missing multi-resource interactions and causing severe slowdowns on some benchmarks. I present a preprocessing method for inferring additional cumulative constraints that capture such interactions without search-time probing. This approach interprets cumulative constraints as linear inequalities over occupancy vectors and generates valid inequalities by (i) discovering covers, the sets of tasks that cannot run in parallel, (ii) strengthening the cover inequalities for the discovered sets with lifting, and (iii) injecting the resulting constraints back into the scheduling problem instance. Experiments on standard RCPSP and RCPSP/max test suites show that these inferred constraints improve search performance and tighten objective bounds on favorable instances, while incurring little degradation on unfavorable ones. Additionally, these experiments discover 25 new lower bounds and five new best solutions; eight of the lower bounds are obtained directly from the inferred constraints.