AI has its own style in mathematical proving
Organizations: School of Systems Science, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China · Microsoft Research Asia, Beijing 100080, China · School of Mathematics, Renmin University of China, Beijing 100872, China
Abstract
As large language models increasingly generate mathematical proofs, whether they develop a proving style distinct from that of human mathematicians remains an open question. This question is particularly pressing as mathematicians increasingly voice concerns that proofs generated by large language models are difficult to interpret. Here we ask three large language models to independently reprove all 465 propositions of Euclid's Elements and compare their citation choices against the human-proof baseline through Jaccard similarity and complex network analysis. We find that AI-generated proofs differ from human proofs, and this difference is stable and reproducible: mean pairwise Jaccard similarity among AI runs (~0.68) is nearly twice that between AI and human proofs (~0.37), and cross-run classification consistency is also high. By examining citation structure in detail, we identify the concrete signature of this difference: approximately 40% of AI citations point to foundational elements (definitions, common notions, and postulates), compared with only 13% in human proofs; even among theorem-to-theorem citations, AI tends to cite more distant results. Roughly half of AI's extra citations trace to the upstream dependencies of the human proof. Together, these findings suggest that the AI proving style is a tendency to construct arguments on its own from foundational elements rather than directly citing later, more established results, which we term "building from the ground up". Our findings offer a new perspective on how AI systems organise and invoke mathematical knowledge, with implications for understanding the interpretability of AI-generated proofs.
Figures & tables
| P | G | D | E | Err% | |
| After AI check | |||||
| Run A | 22 | 317 | 115 | 11 (5) | 2.37 |
| Run B | 18 | 320 | 119 | 8 (3) | 1.72 |
| Run C | 24 | 295 | 136 | 10 (3) | 2.15 |
| After expert validation | |||||
| Run A | 22 | 319 | 115 | 9 | 1.94 |
| 3-run overlap | 2-run overlap | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Category | Total | Count | % | Count | % |
| P | 64 | 45 | 70.3 | 57 | 89.1 |
| G | 934 | 723 | 77.4 | 873 | 93.5 |
| D | 371 | 201 | 54.2 | 303 | 81.7 |
| E | 26 | 0 | 0.0 | 8 | 30.8 |
| Overall | 1395 | 969 | 69.5 | 1241 | 89.0 |
| Full Network | Theorem-Only | |||
| Metric | AI-Only | Human-Only | AI-Only | Human-Only |
| All D-class pairs | ||||
| Sample size | 377 | 352 | 343 | 351 |
| Mean node count | 6.33 | 2.87 | 3.76 | 2.68 |
| Has internal edges | 76.9% | 29.5% | 51.6% | 27.4% |
| Longest path 2 | 28.4% | 7.4% | 17.5% | 6.6% |
LLM Mathematical Reasoning
Large language model mathematical reasoning studies how AI systems solve, explain, verify, and generalize across mathematical problems and proofs.
See all 281 papers