Natural-language point-cloud localization typically retrieves candidate map cells and then predicts a position inside each candidate, yet the final output is still determined by retrieval order. A retrieval score measures region-description relevance, not whether the coordinates a region yields are accurate: a relevant region may produce a displaced prediction, and a lower-ranked region may contain a successful one. We study the final selection problem after the candidate pool and Fine predictions are fixed---how to choose the coordinate most likely to localize successfully, and under which conditions the gain holds. We propose SCAR (Spatial Consistency-Aware Reranking). SCAR treats each cell--Fine-coordinate pair as a localization hypothesis, interprets directional relations as functions of position, and reads spatial support at the backbone's actual Fine point (Fine-conditioned Evidence Readout). It organizes this readout with center support, semantic presence, retrieval score, and geometric offsets into a 23-D representation, trains a shared scorer with localization-success labels, and at inference reranks existing hypotheses and returns their original coordinates. Experiments cover four public backbones and a corrected Des4Pos reimplementation across five domains. Excluding one protocol-reference configuration, exploratory TEST point estimates on the remaining 24 configurations show Top-1@5,m above Original on 23 and Cell R@1 above Original on all 24. On development-set VAL, the Fine readout improves Top-1@5,m by 5.77 percentage points (pp) over a center surrogate on corrected Des4Pos*KITTI, and the complete scoring scheme improves it by 13.98,pp over FSR on MambaPlace×nuScenesFull; the latter measures the complete scheme, not learned ranking alone.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1: Candidate availability and selection on MNCL × KITTI VAL with a fixed Top-25 prediction pool. (a) Original and Oracle@25 Top-1@5 m. (b) Queries corrected and broken by two training-free rankings relative to Original. The oracle uses GT only to measure recoverable coverage. Query counts, net gains, and the paired interval are discussed in the text.
Fig. 2: SCAR overview. A frozen Coarse–Fine backbone supplies 25 cell–position hypotheses. Query relations are matched to map objects, spatial support is read at each existing Fine prediction, and the resulting 23-D representation is normalized with TRAIN statistics and scored by a shared MLP. SCAR reranks the fixed hypotheses and returns the existing Fine coordinate of the selected candidate. Point-cloud layouts, relations, support fields, and scores are illustrative.
Benchmark
TRAIN
VAL
TEST
Split-unit definition
KITTI360Pose
28,807
3,187
11,505
30 m cells; six descriptions; TEST covers three scenes
PandaSetPose
4,000
2,000
2,000
six descriptions per pose; nearest retained anchor cell
nuScenesPose Full
15,113
7,635
7,403
2–6 original descriptions; 210 TEST scenes with queries
S3DISPose
1,084
544
542
rooms as split unit; four descriptions; TEST 68 rooms
ParisLillePose/NPM3D
120
128
116
20 m cells; three descriptions; TEST 29 query scenes
TABLE I: Frozen localization splits. Counts are localization requests; one request may contain several descriptions.
KITTI
S3DIS
PandaSet
Backbone
1 m
3 m
5 m
10 m
1 m
3 m
5 m
10 m
1 m
3 m
5 m
10 m
Text2Loc
6.46 (+3.36)
37.16 (+16.68)
59.45 (+24.31)
75.77 (+26.88)
30.26 (+20.85)
39.30 (+27.31)
41.33 (+27.49)
41.70 (+27.31)
7.70 (+0.15)
30.85 (+2.30)
44.95 (+4.00)
55.25 (+4.75)
Text2Loc++
8.29 (+3.78)
41.23 (+15.09)
64.15 (+20.43)
78.86 (+21.10)
34.50 (+18.27)
44.10 (+24.17)
45.94 (+25.28)
47.97 (+26.20)
4.55 (+0.35)
29.45 (+4.00)
44.30 (+6.95)
56.30 (+8.85)
MNCL
7.20 (+2.83)
40.40 (+11.26)
63.82 (+14.23)
79.69 (+13.99)
22.88 (+18.08)
36.90 (+29.70)
38.38 (+30.44)
39.11 (+31.18)
4.65 (-0.30)
27.20 (-2.10)
42.05 (-0.15)
52.50 (-0.10)
MambaPlace †
7.21 (+3.95)
36.01 (+17.49)
57.07 (+25.09)
72.92 (+28.34)
22.14 (+16.24)
38.19 (+27.68)
40.77 (+28.78)
42.07 (+28.60)
1.80 (+0.45)
14.35 (+5.65)
22.15 (+8.25)
34.65 (+11.85)
Des4Pos (reimpl.)
6.62 (+4.17)
36.11 (+19.06)
57.84 (+28.47)
73.53 (+32.37)
22.32 (+14.21)
36.35 (+22.51)
37.82 (+23.25)
39.11 (+23.25)
3.25 (+0.60)
21.60 (+8.95)
31.55 (+11.20)
44.65 (+14.65)
TABLE II: TEST localization success (%) of SCAR at four distance thresholds. Each cell shows the success rate above and the difference from Original (pp) below. The primary threshold is 5 m.
KITTI
S3DIS
PandaSet
Backbone
R@1
R@3
R@5
R@10
R@1
R@3
R@5
R@10
R@1
R@3
R@5
R@10
Text2Loc
43.74 (+13.90)
70.00 (+19.85)
76.99 (+16.82)
81.33 (+10.01)
41.70 (+27.31)
63.84 (+32.10)
72.51 (+25.83)
85.42 (+20.66)
52.35 (+7.30)
77.40 (+5.20)
85.40 (+2.40)
92.90 (+2.80)
Text2Loc++
45.02 (+10.02)
72.36 (+14.74)
80.15 (+13.26)
85.02 (+8.09)
48.15 (+26.20)
70.11 (+24.54)
82.29 (+24.91)
89.11 (+18.08)
49.10 (+7.95)
69.15 (+4.45)
83.20 (+9.00)
91.75 (+2.65)
MNCL
47.41 (+3.51)
76.62 (+9.77)
84.19 (+9.38)
88.80 (+5.77)
39.30 (+31.18)
60.15 (+38.38)
68.82 (+35.06)
77.86 (+25.46)
47.85 (+1.80)
74.20 (+5.95)
82.45 (+5.10)
89.55 (+2.50)
MambaPlace †
40.83 (+16.28)
65.34 (+21.56)
72.03 (+18.83)
76.26 (+11.79)
42.25 (+28.78)
64.76 (+33.03)
73.80 (+31.55)
82.66 (+23.99)
29.50 (+9.70)
46.90 (+11.95)
57.35 (+11.55)
73.20 (+14.85)
Des4Pos (reimpl.)
43.11 (+19.44)
65.72 (+23.06)
71.67 (+20.11)
75.35 (+12.07)
39.11 (+23.06)
61.44 (+27.31)
72.51 (+29.15)
82.10 (+18.82)
41.55 (+13.45)
61.70 (+8.10)
72.05 (+7.85)
83.25 (+6.35)
TABLE III: TEST Cell R@1, R@3, R@5, and R@10 (%) of SCAR. Each cell shows the recall above and the difference from Original (pp) below.
Dataset
Backbone
Original
Semantic Matching
Rank Fusion
FSR
SCAR
KITTI
Text2Loc
35.14 / 29.84
49.05 / 41.28
54.58 / 44.62
58.65 / 46.51
59.45 / 43.74
Text2Loc++
43.72 / 35.00
56.45 / 44.98
59.05 / 46.05
63.36 / 47.51
64.15 / 45.02
MNCL
49.59 / 43.90
54.90 / 46.01
57.56 / 46.62
62.00 / 48.19
63.82 / 47.41
MambaPlace
31.98 / 24.55
45.31 / 35.74
53.72 / 42.36
57.65 / 44.18
57.07 / 40.83
Des4Pos (reimpl.)
29.37 / 23.67
46.03 / 36.71
53.01 / 42.67
57.41 / 44.37
57.84 / 43.11
S3DIS
Text2Loc
13.84 / 14.39
28.23 / 29.89
36.90 / 38.38
44.83 / 46.49
41.33 / 41.70
TABLE IV: Same-pool TEST comparison of Semantic Matching, Rank Fusion, FSR, and SCAR. Each entry reports Top-1@5 m / Cell R@1 (%).
Fig. 3: TEST Top-1 localization success as a function of the true-distance threshold (1, 3, 5, and 10 m). All five panels use the Text2Loc backbone and its fixed Top-25 candidate pool and Fine coordinates on KITTI, PandaSet, nuScenes, S3DIS, and NPM3D. Original, FSR, and SCAR are three rankings of the same candidate set. The vertical axis is 0–80% in every panel; the gray dashed line marks the 5 m primary metric. Curves connect observed values without smoothing. All TEST comparisons are exploratory; Table II reports the four-threshold SCAR results, and Supplement Table S4 gives additional comparisons.
Fig. 4: Real corrected Des4Pos × KITTI VAL cases, shown from left to right: (a) correction, (b) preservation, and (c) degradation. Stars denote GT, orange triangles Original predictions, and purple squares SCAR predictions; dashed circles have a 5 m radius. Coordinates are relative to GT, with the same scale in all panels. Errors below each panel are Original → SCAR. The two predictions coincide in (b). Case identities, query descriptions, and selection details are given in Supplement S4.3.
Fig. 5: VAL Top-1@5 m differences between F and each control: (a) corrected Des4Pos × KITTI and (b) MambaPlace × nuScenesFull. Bars show point estimates; whiskers are paired 95% cluster-bootstrap intervals. Filled bars compare trained F/C/N arms, while hatched bars compare the complete F scoring scheme with training-free FSR. Both panels use scorer seed 0 and the same horizontal scale. Complete results are in Supplement Tables S8 and S9.
Fig. 6: Spatial-support distributions on MNCL × KITTI VAL. (a) Effective matched-relation count m , with the dashed line marking the m≥4 gate. (b) Joint histogram of center and Fine support among active-gate pairs; color indicates pair count on a logarithmic scale, white bins are empty, and the diagonal marks equal support. (c) Changes in satisfied-relation count at the Fine point relative to the center, normalized separately within 5 m-hit and 5 m-miss candidate pairs. These are descriptive distributions, not ranking ablations.
Method
Native K10
Same-pool K25
FSR
SCAR
Text2Loc
126.40
275.99
279.68
276.39
Text2Loc++
93.69
207.64
212.77
214.89
MNCL
252.87
584.45
588.88
592.78
MambaPlace
Not measured
Des4Pos (historical impl.)
100.49
191.98
199.65
196.25
TABLE V: KITTI fixed-VAL-query median stage-wise computational latency (ms) under warm cache. Text2Loc native K10/fixed K25 is 126.40/275.99; MambaPlace was not measured. The Des4Pos row is the historical implementation; its corrected reimplementation was not measured.
Configuration
Coarse
Fine
Evidence type
MambaPlace × KITTI
8 h 37 min 09 s
14 h 03 min 26 s
Start/end wall clock
MambaPlace × PandaSet
1 h 08 min 26 s
1 h 45 min 50 s
Session transcript; log not archived
MambaPlace × nuScenes
5 h 30 min 01 s
8 h 18 min 01 s
Start/end wall clock
MambaPlace × S3DIS
27 min 22 s
31 min 11 s
Start/end wall clock
MambaPlace × NPM3D
2 min 06 s
3 min 52 s
Start/end wall clock
Text2Loc++ × S3DIS
47 min 44 s
45 min 23 s
Start/end wall clock
TABLE VI: Stage training durations in the existing logs. Durations correspond to the original run environment and recipe of each configuration and exclude failed attempts and overall project development overhead.