cs.CVMay 27, 2025

Good Enough? An Investigation on the Impact of Label Quality in Large-Scale Medical Datasets

Authors: Alexander JausZdravko MarinovConstantin SeiboldSimon ReißJiale WeiJens KleesiekRainer Stiefelhagen

Abstract

Manually refining radiological segmentation masks is highly resource-intensive. To determine when this expert commitment is truly justified for the training of segmentation models, we investigate the relationship between label quality and model performance. Expanding beyond models trained directly for inference, we conduct the first study isolating the impact of label quality in pre-training datasets. While high-quality labels remain essential for models proceeding directly to deployment, we find no evidence that strict label quality is crucial for pre-training efficacy. These results question the necessity of exhaustive human-in-the-loop refinement for massive corpora intended for pretraining and suggest that expert effort is more effectively invested in well-curated downstream target datasets.

Explore similar work

Jun 1, 2026cs.CV

Quality-Guided Semi-Supervised Learning for Medical Image Segmentation

Training accurate medical image segmentation models requires large amounts of densely annotated data, which is costly and time-consuming to obtain. Semi-supervised learning (SSL) alleviates this by learning from both abundant unlabeled data and limited labeled data. However, most modern SSL methods rely on pseudolabels for unlabeled data, and typically assess their reliability through model confidence or uncertainty, measures that are self-referential and lack explicit grounding in segmentation quality. Instead, we propose a quality-guided SSL framework that trains a dedicated network to estimate segmentation quality from image-mask pairs. The predictor is trained on variable-quality masks generated through synthetic corruptions augmented with imperfect outputs from partially trained segmentation models, capturing realistic error patterns encountered during training. We integrate the quality predictor into SSL through two complementary mechanisms: a quality-aware regularization loss and a quality-based pseudolabel sample reweighting scheme. We show that our method serves as a drop-in enhancement to existing SSL frameworks. Extensive experiments across five datasets and multiple architectures demonstrate consistent improvements over competing SSL methods, advancing the state-of-the-art in semi-supervised medical image segmentation.
Kumar Abhishek, Ghassan Hamarneh
Aug 5, 2026cs.CV

Segmentation Pre-training for Label-Efficient Lumbar Spine Degeneration Grading

Automated assessment of degenerative pathology in the lumbar spine on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) requires access to large-scale datasets of expert-annotated radiological gradings. In contrast, segmentation pseudo-labels can be generated by automated tools at negligible radiologist cost. We examine whether pre-training on segmentation can effectively replace a fraction of the manual grading annotations required for downstream supervision. We pre-train a 3D ResNet encoder to segment the vertebrae, intervertebral discs (IVDs), and the spinal canal, then fine-tune lightweight task-specific grading heads using different proportions of the available training data, ranging from 10%10\% to 100%100\%. On a multicentre dataset of 2,000{\sim}2{,}000 subjects across 11 pathologies, segmentation pre-training, achieving a Dice score of 0.940.94 against pseudo-labels, improved the task-averaged (macro) one-vs-rest ROC-AUC at all proportions. With only 20% of grading labels after pre-training, the method achieved near full-supervision performance, with the largest gains observed for either low-prevalence or spatially grounded pathologies.
Monzon Maria, Zisserman Andrew, Jutzeler Catherine R. +1
Sep 1, 2026eess.IV

GazeRefine: Expert Gaze as a Test-Time Prompt for Training-Free Medical Image Segmentation

Medical image segmentation remains difficult to scale because high-performing methods typically rely on dense expert annotations and task-specific training. We introduce GazeRefine, a training-free framework that uses gaze as an inference-time prompt for zero-shot medical image segmentation. Sparse, duration-weighted fixations are converted into foreground and background priors that initialize semantic prototypes in frozen DINOv3 feature space. These prototypes are iteratively refined through foreground-background discrimination, feature-space affinity propagation, and anchoring to the initial gaze guidance, allowing segmentation to extend beyond directly fixated regions while limiting semantic drift. GazeRefine requires no segmentation masks, fine-tuning, adapters, prompt encoders, or gradient updates. We evaluate the method on gaze-annotated polyp segmentation and prostate MRI segmentation. The results show strong performance on colonoscopy images and competitive performance on prostate MRI, supporting gaze-guided prototype refinement as a promising approach for segmentation-label-efficient, human-in-the-loop medical image segmentation. Our tools and code can be found in the following repository: https://github.com/MohammedOussamaBEN/GazeRefine.git
Mohammed Oussama Benyahia, Marouane Tliba, Mohamed Amine Kerkouri +10