Differential Privacy in Two-Layer Networks: How DP-SGD Harms Fairness and Robustness

Differentially private (DP) training of neural networks is often hindered by the large amount of noise required by gradient-based methods such as DP-SGD, which repeatedly inject high-dimensional noise in parameter space throughout training. In this paper, we propose a new framework for DP learning that avoids iterative optimization in parameter space. Instead of updating the target model using privatized gradients, we employ a hypernetwork trained on public datasets to map a private dataset to the parameters of the target model. Specifically, each example is embedded into a low-dimensional representation, the embeddings are aggregated and perturbed to obtain a DP dataset embedding, and the hypernetwork generates the target model parameters from this noisy embedding. Because privacy noise is injected only once into a low-dimensional dataset representation, our approach can significantly reduce the adverse effect of noise. We theoretically show in a synthetic setting that, under a fixed privacy budget, models produced by our approach achieve higher utility than those trained with DP-SGD. Moreover, we apply our approach to LoRA fine-tuning of diffusion models and show that it achieves lower FID than LoRA models trained with DP-SGD and other public-data-guided methods.

Differentially private optimization suffers from a fundamental geometric mismatch: deep networks have highly anisotropic loss landscapes, yet DP-SGD injects isotropic noise. Second-order preconditioning can resolve this, but estimating curvature typically requires private data (consuming privacy budget) or public data (introducing distribution shift). We show that the Fisher Information Matrix decouples into architectural sensitivity, recoverable via synthetic noise, and input correlations, approximable from modality-specific frequency statistics. We propose DP-KFC, which constructs KFAC preconditioners by probing networks with structured synthetic noise, requiring neither private nor public data. Empirically, DP-KFC consistently outperforms DP-SGD and adaptive baselines across diverse modalities in strong privacy regimes ($\varepsilon \leq 3$). DP-KFC matches private-data preconditioners while public-data variants degrade by up to $4.8\%$, showing that curvature can be estimated without consuming privacy budget or introducing distribution shift. This enables privacy-preserving learning in specialized domains (e.g., medical applications) where regulatory constraints make data scarce.

Differentially private stochastic gradient descent (DP-SGD) is a standard approach to privacy-preserving learning based on per-example clipping, subsampling, Gaussian perturbation, and privacy accounting. Classical DP-SGD releases a noisy version of the current clipped subsampled gradient sum. We propose Fractional-Order Differentially Private Stochastic Gradient Descent (FO-DP-SGD), a mechanism-level extension that replaces this current-only query, before Gaussian noise is added, with a fractional recursive query combining the current clipped sum with a finite-window, power-law-weighted aggregation of previously released private sum-level outputs. This injects fractional memory into the release mechanism while preserving the standard sum-then-noise-then-divide structure. Under add/remove adjacency with Poisson subsampling, the current-step sensitivity analysis shows that the only newly data-dependent term is the scaled current clipped sum. Hence, conditioned on the private history, the effective $\ell_2$-sensitivity is at most $βC$, where $C$ is the clipping threshold and $β\in(0,1]$ controls the current-step contribution. Thus, FO-DP-SGD admits standard per-step Rényi differential privacy accounting via a Poisson-subsampled Gaussian mechanism with effective noise-to-sensitivity ratio $σ/β$, and composes to yield overall $(\varepsilon,δ)$-differential privacy guarantees. FO-DP-SGD provides a framework for studying long-memory effects in private optimization. The fractional order, memory window, and mixing coefficient govern the trade-off among current-step sensitivity, signal retention, and private-history influence. Experiments on SVHN, CIFAR-10, and CIFAR-100 show improved test accuracy and privacy--utility performance over DP-SGD and private baselines including DP-Adam, DP-IS, SA-DP-SGD, ADP-AdamW, DP-SAT, and DP-Adam-AC.