Roots Beneath the Cut: Uncovering the Risk of Concept Revival in Pruning-Based Unlearning for Diffusion Models

Existing attacks on unlearned diffusion models assume that the erased concepts are known in advance and focus on recovering them. In practice, however, model providers may not disclose which concepts have been removed, and even with access to the original base model, an adversary may still lack a clear target to attack. In this paper, we aim to answer the following critical but overlooked questions: which concepts have been erased from the model, and how many have been erased in total? To this end, we present Tracer, a framework that rapidly and accurately identifies erased concepts and estimates their number. Tracer efficiently identifies erased concepts without generating and classifying images. By combining lightweight spectral analysis of weight footprints, it enables efficient search over large candidate vocabularies. To distinguish multiple erased concepts, we introduce a footprint coverage objective that guides sequential discovery. Tracer estimates the number of erased concepts by detecting a sharp decline in candidate confidence as the selected concepts account for the erasure footprint, without requiring labeled examples for calibration. The framework requires only lightweight linear algebra and limited forward probes, with no prior knowledge of the unlearning algorithm. Experiments across text-to-image and text-to-video backbones and diverse unlearning methods demonstrate that Tracer identifies erased concepts and estimates their number in seconds, achieving 150 to 137,000 times and 133 to 20,000 times speedups over MIA and brute-force search on image and video models, respectively, with substantially higher identification accuracy.

Unlearning in diffusion models aims to remove undesirable data or concepts while preserving the utility of pretrained models -- two fundamentally conflicting objectives. We propose a principled constrained optimization framework that formulates unlearning as minimizing the deviation from a pretrained model, subject to explicit separation constraints from the unlearning distributions. Specifically, we formulate three constrained optimization problems based on reverse and forward KL divergences, and likelihood constraints. The first two generalize existing approaches for concept and data unlearning, while the third offers a novel and natural formulation for unlearning. Despite the nonconvexity of the KL constraints, we establish strong duality for all three problems, enabling us to explicitly characterize their optimal solutions as unlearning targets and develop primal-dual algorithms for each formulation. Experimental results demonstrate that our KL-constrained approach achieves superior retention-unlearning tradeoffs compared to weight-based baselines for concept and data unlearning, and that our likelihood-based approach matches unlearning effectiveness while better preserving retained concepts compared to baselines.

Diffusion models excel at generating high-quality images but can memorize and reproduce harmful concepts when prompted. Although fine-tuning methods have been proposed to unlearn a target concept, they struggle to fully erase it while maintaining generation quality on other concepts, leaving models vulnerable to jailbreak attacks. Existing jailbreak methods demonstrate this vulnerability but offer limited insight into how unlearned models retain harmful concepts, limiting progress on effective defenses. In this work, we show that a coherent, interpretable, attack-accessible linear residual of the erased concept can be recovered in the token embedding space, and that both an attack and a defense follow from this structure. We introduce SubAttack, a novel jailbreaking attack that reads out this subspace by learning an orthogonal set of attack token embeddings, each being a linear combination of human-interpretable textual elements, revealing that unlearned models still retain the target concept through related textual components. Furthermore, our attack is also more powerful and transferable across text prompts, initial noises, and unlearned models than prior attacks. Conversely, projecting out the same subspace yields SubDefense, a lightweight plug-and-play defense mechanism that suppresses the residual concept in unlearned models. SubDefense provides stronger robustness than existing defenses while better preserving safe generation quality. Extensive experiments across multiple unlearning methods, concepts, and attack types demonstrate that our approach advances both understanding and mitigation of vulnerabilities in diffusion unlearning.