Interleaved Information Structures in Dynamic Games: A General Framework with Application to the Linear-Quadratic Case
Authors: Janani S K, Kushagra Gupta, Ufuk Topcu, David Fridovich-Keil
Organizations: Department of Engineering Design, Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai, India · Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712, USA · Department of Aerospace Engineering and the Oden Institute for Computational Engineering and Sciences, The University of Texas at Austin, Austin, TX 78712, USA
A fundamental problem in noncooperative dynamic game theory is the computation of Nash equilibria under different information structures, which specify the information available to each agent during decision-making. Prior work has extensively studied equilibrium solutions for two canonical information structures: feedback, where agents observe the current state at each time, and open-loop, where agents only observe the initial state. However, these paradigms are often too restrictive to capture realistic settings exhibiting interleaved information structures, in which each agent observes only a subset of other agents at every timestep. To date, there is no systematic framework for modeling and solving dynamic games under arbitrary interleaved information structures. To this end, we make two main contributions. First, we introduce a method to model deterministic dynamic games with arbitrary interleaved information structures as Mathematical Program Networks (MPNs), where the network structure encodes the informational dependencies between agents. Second, for linear-quadratic (LQ) dynamic games, we leverage the MPN formulation to develop a systematic procedure for deriving Riccati-like equations that characterize Nash equilibria. Finally, we illustrate our approach through an example involving three agents exhibiting a cyclic information structure.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1: MPN building blocks across successive time steps for dynamic games with canonical information structures.
Fig. 2: MPN building block across successive timesteps for a dynamic game in which agents i and j exhibit a non-canonical interleaved information structure. Additional edges may appear depending on the information relationships with other agents in the game.
Fig. 3: MPN for a three-agent, three timestep game with a cyclical information structure: agent 1 observes agent 2, who in turn observes agent 3, who in turn observes agent 1.
We consider cooperative and iterative tasks involving multiple agents whose interactions are modeled as a dynamic game with shared constraints. We propose a general learning framework applicable to nonlinear and nonconvex dynamic games that uses previously executed feasible trajectories to construct a sampled joint safe set and player-specific cost-to-go functions. At each time step, the agents jointly select a previously sampled terminal state and a Generalized Nash equilibrium used to reach it. A new solution is adopted only if it satisfies a cooperative acceptance rule agreed upon by the players. The framework accommodates individual non-degradation requirements and selection criteria such as weighted costs and Nash bargaining. We show that the proposed framework guarantees recursive feasibility and characterize conditions under which each player's cost is non-increasing across iterations.
There has been significant recent progress in algorithms for approximation of Nash equilibrium in large two-player zero-sum imperfect-information games and exact computation of Nash equilibrium in multiplayer strategic-form games. While counterfactual regret minimization and fictitious play are scalable to large games and have convergence guarantees in two-player zero-sum games, they do not guarantee convergence to Nash equilibrium in multiplayer games. We present an approach for exact computation of Nash equilibrium in multiplayer imperfect-information games that solves a quadratically-constrained program based on a nonlinear complementarity problem formulation from the sequence-form game representation. This approach capitalizes on recent advances for solving nonconvex quadratic programs. Our algorithm is able to quickly solve three-player Kuhn poker after removal of dominated actions. Of the available algorithms in the Gambit software suite, only the logit quantal response approach is successfully able to solve the game; however, the approach takes longer than our algorithm and also involves a degree of approximation. Our formulation also leads to a new approach for computing Nash equilibrium in multiplayer strategic-form games which we demonstrate to outperform a previous quadratically-constrained program formulation.
As firms increasingly deploy machine learning for strategic decision-making, understanding algorithmic interactions has become central to operations research and economics. This paper studies learning in infinite-horizon, nonzero-sum linear-quadratic stochastic games under a radically uncoupled information structure, where players are either unaware of opponents or strategically oblivious, observing only a common state and their own action history. Under this minimal information, we analyze an asynchronous decentralized learning process in which each player independently runs a single-agent ε-greedy iterated least-squares algorithm. We prove that, despite being unable to identify the system parameters, players' learning dynamics converge almost surely to the complete-information Nash equilibrium and characterize the convergence rate. We then apply the framework to a dynamic Cournot competition with sticky prices. Numerical experiments validate the theoretical results and show that learning under limited information reduces firm profits under both low and high price stickiness, while total surplus declines and market concentration increases when price stickiness is high. Publicly revealing aggregate market output substantially accelerates convergence and mitigates these welfare losses.
Dantong Chu, Xuefeng Gao, Yufei Zhang
Department of Systems Engineering and Engineering Management, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China. · Department of Mathematics, Imperial College London, UK.