Structural Consequences of Policy-Based Interventions on the Global Supply Chain Network
Organizations: Department of Engineering, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom · The Alan Turing Institute, London, United Kingdom
Abstract
As global political tensions rise and the anticipation of additional tariffs from the United States on international trade increases, the issues of economic independence and supply chain resilience become more prominent. The importance of supply chain resilience has been further underscored by disruptions caused by the COVID-19 pandemic and the ongoing war in Ukraine. In light of these challenges, ranging from geopolitical instability to product supply uncertainties, governments are increasingly focused on adopting new trade policies. This study explores the impact of several of these policies on the global electric vehicle (EV) supply chain network, with a particular focus on their effects on country clusters and the broader structure of international trade. Specifically, we analyse three key policies: Country Plus One, Friendshoring, and Reshoring. Our findings show that Friendshoring, contrary to expectations, leads to greater globalisation by increasing the number of supply links across friendly countries, potentially raising transaction costs. The Country Plus One policy similarly enhances network density through redundant links, while the Reshoring policy creates challenges in the EV sector due to the high number of irreplaceable products. Additionally, the effects of these policies vary across industries; for instance, mining goods being less affected in Country Plus One than the Friendshoring policy.
Figures & tables
| Scope / Policy | China+1 | Friendshoring | Reshoring |
| American | Transportation Equipment | Transportation Equipment | Mine, Refinery, Smelter |
| Industrial Intermediate Prod | Oil & Gas Services & Equip | Mine, Smelter | |
| Semiconductors | Industrial Intermediate Prod | Mine | |
| Technology Services | Steel | Smelter | |
| Renewable Energy | Machinery | Telecommunications | |
| European | Transportation Equipment | Cable & Satellite | Mine, Refinery, Smelter |
Appendix figures & tables10 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
| Geopolitical Clusters | Geographical Clusters | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low Risk (19) | Medium Risk (107) | High Risk (15) | Asian (10) | American (3) | European (31) | ||
| Australia | Algeria | Ghana | Namibia | Belarus | China | Canada | Austria |
| Belgium | Angola | Greece | New Caledonia | Cambodia | Hong Kong | Mexico | Belgium |
| Canada | Argentina | Guatemala | Nigeria | China | India | United States | Bulgaria |
| Denmark | Aruba | Guinea | Oman | DR Congo | Indonesia | Croatia | |
| Finland | Austria | Guyana | Pakistan | Cuba | Japan | Cyprus | |
| After enforcing policy | ||||
| Network Measures | Initial | China+1 | Friendshoring | Reshoring |
| Avg. No. Edges | 56339 | 59287.2 | 61931 | 61478 |
| Density | 0.000243 | 0.000256 | 0.000268 | 0.000266 |
| Degree Assortativity | -0.121478 | -0.124697 | -0.112675 | -0.109282 |
| Location Assortativity | 0.428589 | 0.410186 | 0.47501 | 0.52449 |
| Avg. Shortest Path Length | 4.575134 | 4.597169 | 4.745798 | 4.753068 |
| After enforcing policy | ||||
| Network Measures | Initial | China+1 | Friendshoring | Reshoring |
| Avg. No. Edges | 56339 | 61148 | 62989 | 59018 |
| Density | 0.000243 | 0.000264 | 0.000272 | 0.000255 |
| Degree Assortativity | -0.121478 | -0.133112 | -0.111633 | -0.112158 |
| Location Assortativity | 0.428589 | 0.395352 | 0.409187 | 0.525181 |
| Avg. Shortest Path Length | 4.575134 | 4.624493 | 4.602967 | 4.661914 |
| After enforcing policy | ||||
| Network Measures | Initial | China+1 | Friendshoring | Reshoring |
| Avg. No. Edges | 56339 | 62015.8 | 67732 | 68218 |
| Density | 0.000243 | 0.000268 | 0.000293 | 0.000295 |
| Degree Assortativity | -0.121478 | -0.124529 | -0.112532 | -0.105941 |
| Location Assortativity | 0.428589 | 0.390959 | 0.37841 | 0.633812 |
| Avg. Shortest Path Length | 4.575134 | 4.662426 | 4.621184 | 4.933708 |
| After enforcing policy | ||||
| Network Measures | Initial | High Risk+1 | Friendshoring | Reshoring |
| Avg. No. Edges | 56339 | 68467.2 | 68161 | 69999 |
| Density | 0.000243 | 0.000296 | 0.000294 | 0.000302 |
| Degree Assortativity | -0.121478 | -0.13027 | -0.103142 | -0.093862 |
| Location Assortativity | 0.428589 | 0.356546 | 0.372094 | 0.699809 |
| Avg. Shortest Path Length | 4.575134 | 4.569131 | 4.729862 | 4.957766 |
| After enforcing policy | ||||
| Network Measures | Initial | High Risk+1 | Friendshoring | Reshoring |
| Avg. No. Edges | 56339 | 72863.8 | 64989 | 72665 |
| Density | 0.000243 | 0.000315 | 0.000281 | 0.000314 |
| Degree Assortativity | -0.121478 | -0.122476 | -0.109138 | -0.078241 |
| Location Assortativity | 0.428589 | 0.334296 | 0.380879 | 0.752534 |
| Avg. Shortest Path Length | 4.575134 | 4.563405 | 4.742278 | 5.093038 |
| Scope / Policy | China+1 | Friendshoring | Reshoring |
| American | Rear Axle Module | Transmission | Alumina |
| ABS ECU | Rebar | Transmission | |
| Brake Pedal | Brake | Rebar | |
| Air Bag Fabric | Steel billets | Software | |
| Engine Cooling Module | Wheel Hub | Wire rods | |
| European | Engine Cooling Module | Dolomite | Steel meshes |
Supply Chain Management
Supply chain management coordinates sourcing, production, inventory, and delivery to balance cost, service, resilience, and sustainability.
See all 73 papers