Optimal Kinodynamic Motion Planning Through Anytime Bidirectional Heuristic Search with Tight Termination Condition
Authors: Yi Wang, Bingxian Mu, Shahab Shokouhi, May-Win Thein
Organizations: Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH, 03824, USA. · Faculty of Sustainable Design Engineering, University of Prince Edward Island, Charlottetown, PE C1A 4P3, Canada
This paper introduces Bidirectional Tight Informed Trees (BTIT*), an asymptotically optimal kinodynamic sampling-based motion planning algorithm that integrates an anytime bidirectional heuristic search (Bi-HS) and ensures the meet-in-the-middle property (MMP) and optimality (MM-optimality). BTIT* is the first anytime MEET-style algorithm to utilize termination conditions that are efficient to evaluate and enable early termination on-the-fly in batch-wise sampling-based motion planning. Experiments show that BTIT* achieves strongly faster time-to-first-solution and improved convergence than representative non-lazy informed batch planners on two kinodynamic benchmarks: a 4D double-integrator model and a 10D linearized Quadrotor. The source code is available here.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Experimental environment for the double-integrator robot (DIR) in a 2D workspace. This environment features enclosures, narrow passages, and multiple topological routes.
Figure 2: Experimental environment for the 10D linearized quadrotor (LQ) system in a 3D workspace. This environment features with non-convex corridors and narrow passages.
Figure 3: Comparative performance of evaluated planners across different domains in terms of median solution cost and success rate over time, with 95 % confidence interval in each plot. Note that the median solution cost is ∞ when the success rate of a planner is below 50 % . The dots in each plot denote median initial solution times and costs with 95 % confidence intervals (CI), while shadows around the dots indicate a more conservative 99 % CI.
This paper presents BOWConnect, a bidirectional parallel kinodynamic motion planner that addresses three fundamental limitations of existing sampling-based methods: sample inefficiency in high-dimensional state spaces, unreliable cost heuristics under dynamic constraints, and poor performance in narrow passage environments. Unlike classical planners that rely on random control sampling and geometric distance heuristics, BOWConnect integrates Bayesian Optimization over Windows (BOW) as a learning-based steering function within a parallel tree-based exploration framework, enabling each worker to learn local cost maps and constraints to guide sampling toward dynamically feasible and collision-free controls. A bidirectional architecture simultaneously grows forward and backward trees from the start and goal regions in parallel threads, with a spatial hashing mechanism enabling fast connection queries and a boundary value problem solver generating kinodynamically consistent bridge trajectories. Extensive evaluations across ten benchmark environments demonstrate that BOWConnect achieves 100% success while delivering the fastest or near-fastest planning time in complex scenarios, including narrow passages and non-convex spaces where state-of-the-art planners fail or degrade substantially. Real-world deployment on a ground vehicle and a quadrotor confirms real-time planning with no collisions. Videos of real-world and simulated experiments, high-resolution versions of the figures, and the open-source code are available at https://bow-connect.github.io/.
Sourav Raxit, Abdullah Al Redwan Newaz, Jose Fuentes +1
Department of Computer Science, Louisiana State University New Orleans, New Orleans, LA 70148, USA · Knight Foundation School of Computing and Information Sciences, Florida International University, Miami, FL 33199, USA
We focus on the problem of efficient anytime kinodynamic planning for systems with complex dynamics in unstructured environments that make using precomputed motion primitives infeasible. Directly applying A* here is computationally infeasible due to the curse of dimensionality. Methods such as Hybrid A* (HA*) address this by pruning the search tree by discretizing the state space, but the coupling between pruning and discretization resolution can eliminate a vertex on the solution path. The Incremental Generalized Hybrid A* (IGHA*) breaks this coupling by organizing anytime search over a hierarchy of resolutions and by freezing vertices for later expansion rather than pruning. However, IGHA* can still freeze a vertex on the solution path, forcing the search to spend expansions elsewhere before reaching it. Our key insight is that bidirectional-IGHA* (Bi-IGHA*) not only gains the expected reduction in effective search depth from classical bidirectionality, but also mitigates this frozen-vertex barrier: when one search is blocked, the opposing search can reach it at a low resolution. We formalize this structural separation between Bi-IGHA* and IGHA* and empirically show a reduction in effective branching factor beyond the theoretical expectation from classic bidirectionality alone. Through open- loop experiments in R3, R4, and R6, we show that Bi- IGHA* substantially reduces expansions over IGHA*. Closed- loop experiments further demonstrate improved performance and feasibility in simulation and on a real-world robotic system. Link to Website: https://personalrobotics.github.io/IGHAStar/biighastar.html
Steering-based planners require solutions to state-to-state boundary value problems, which can be inaccessible for nonlinear platforms. Forward propagation evades the steering requirement, but the finite-sample behavior of the associated planners remains uncharacterized and their implementations underperform in practice. This paper develops a propagation-based kinodynamic planner with deterministic finite-sample near-optimality guarantees. We work within the large class of differentially flat nonlinear systems and show that a forward tree of locally dispersive control commands contains a near-optimal trajectory at a certified tree size. We provide a general mechanism to construct dispersive command sets for control-affine systems, which are necessary to implement the search algorithm prescribed by the theory. We show that covering the certified trajectory class irrespective of cost provably demands a tree exponentially sized in the problem horizon, and present a cost-conditioned dominance pruning procedure that retains near-optimality at a tree size polynomial in the horizon. We implement the resulting search algorithm, Dispersive Forward Tree search (DFT*), as breadth-first expansion of the forward tree, which maps naturally onto parallel hardware. We design efficient dispersive samplers for the unicycle, the trailer car, and the quadrotor and evaluate challenging planning tasks for these platforms. DFT* delivers consistently competitive and often substantially better solution quality than state-of-the-art kinodynamic planners at comparable solution times on embedded-tier processors, accelerating further as parallel compute is scaled. We also implement DFT* in a receding-horizon loop to demonstrate real-time planning in dynamic environments at embedded-tier compute budgets.
Shashank A. Deshpande, Jonathan P. How
Department of Aeronautics and Astronautics, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA