Recent advances in data-centric artificial intelligence highlight inherent limitations in object recognition datasets. One of the primary issues stems from the semantic gap problem, which results in complex many-to-many mappings between visual data and linguistic descriptions. This bias adversely affects performance in computer vision tasks. This paper proposes an image annotation methodology that integrates knowledge representation, natural language processing, and computer vision techniques, aiming to reduce annotator subjectivity by applying visual property constraints. We introduce an interactive crowdsourcing framework that dynamically asks questions based on a predefined object category hierarchy and annotator feedback, guiding image annotation by visual properties. Experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of this methodology, and annotator feedback is discussed to optimize the crowdsourcing setup.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Images and their labels in existing image datasets. (a) This image appears in three categories of ImageNet, i.e., “Musical Instrument”, “Guitar”, and “Acoustic Guitar”. (b)-(e) These four images are all labelled as the “Brown Bear” category in the Open Image Dataset.
Categories
I
II
III
IV
V
VI
VII
VIII
IX
X
XI
XII
Unrecognised
Alpha
Annotators group 1
98
101
86
102
97
103
92
95
96
96
90
95
49
0.934
Annotators group 2
91
105
93
98
101
98
91
94
87
104
88
92
58
Annotators group 3
95
100
91
101
99
102
95
92
90
98
93
98
46
Table 1: The number of images for categories we obtained by the proposed image annotation methodology from three groups of annotators, where ”I, II, …, XII” denote twelve categories. The “Unrecognised” indicates instances where annotators did not annotate the image into any of the twelve specific categories but rather assigned it to an upper-level category, e.g., its parent category. ”Alpha” refers to Krippendorff’s alpha measure, a statistical tool for assessing the reliability of these annotations.
Image annotation methodology
50 images per task
100 images per task
Alpha
Time (min)
Payments(£/p)
Alpha
Time (min)
Payments(£/p)
Method A
0.912
4.12
1
0.896
8.27
2
Method B
0.937
5.08
1.5
0.914
9.22
3
Method C (Ours)
0.974
5.47
1.5
0.958
9.47
3
Table 2: Results of implementing three different image annotation methodologies, including inter-class agreement evaluation with Krippendorff’s alpha measure, time cost on single tasks, and payment to one annotator for one task. To evaluate the proper number of images per task, we present a comparison of results for tasks with 50 images and 100 images.
Model
Method A
Method C (Ours)
Improvement
AlexNet [ 19 ]
0.543
0.596
9.76%
ZFNet [ 46 ]
0.612
0.657
7.35%
VGG [ 36 ]
0.655
0.743
13.44%
GoogleNet [ 39 ]
0.734
0.835
13.76%
ResNet [ 12 ]
0.593
0.732
23.44%
DenseNet [ 14 ]
0.724
0.793
9.53%
Table 3: Complementary downstream visual recognition results on an ImageNet-derived benchmark annotated under two different designs: a conventional name-based labeling condition and the full visual-property-guided design. Higher values indicate better classification accuracy.
Method
Hierarchy
Visual Properties
50 Images per Task
100 Images per Task
Alpha
Time (min)
Payment (£/p)
Alpha
Time (min)
Payment (£/p)
Method A
✗
✗
0.912
4.12
1.0
0.896
8.27
2.0
Method B
✓
✗
0.937
5.08
1.5
0.914
9.22
3.0
Method C (Ours)
✓
✓
0.974
5.47
1.5
0.958
9.47
3.0
Δ (B − A)
–
–
+0.025
+0.96
+0.5
+0.018
+0.95
+1.0
Δ (C − B)
–
–
+0.037
+0.39
+0.0
+0.044
+0.25
+0.0
Table 4: Ablation study on annotation design under the crowdsourcing setting. Method A uses category names only; Method B adds an object hierarchy; Method C further adds visual properties (visual genus and visual differentia) within the hierarchy. Higher Alpha indicates better inter-annotator agreement.
Reliable object perception is necessary for general-purpose service robots. Open-vocabulary detectors struggle to generalize beyond a few classes and fully supervised training of object detectors requires time-intensive annotations. We present a semi-supervised label propagation approach for household object segmentation. A segment proposer generates class-agnostic masks, and an ensemble of Hopfield networks assigns labels by learning representative embeddings in complementary foundation model embedding spaces (CLIP, ViT, Theia). Our approach scales to 50 object classes with limited annotation overhead and can automatically label 60% of the data in a RoboCup@Home setting, where preparation time is severely constrained. Dataset and code are publicly available at https://github.com/ais-bonn/label_propagation.
High-quality labeled data is essential for training robust machine learning models, yet obtaining annotations at scale remains expensive. AI-assisted annotation has therefore become standard in large-scale labeling workflows. However, in tasks where model predictions carry two independent components, a class label and spatial boundaries, a model may classify an object with high confidence while mislocalizing it. Existing AI-assisted workflows offer annotators no signal about where spatial errors are most likely. Without such guidance, humans may systematically underinspect subtly misplaced boxes. We address this by studying the effect of visualizing spatial uncertainty via a purpose-built interface. In a controlled study with 120 participants, those receiving uncertainty cues achieve higher label quality while being faster overall. A box-level analysis confirms that the cues redirect annotator effort toward high-uncertainty predictions and away from well-localized boxes. These findings establish localization uncertainty as a lever to improve human-in-the-loop annotation. Code is available at https://mos-ks.github.io/MUHA/.
Moussa Kassem Sbeyti, Joshua Holstein, Philipp Spitzer +2
1Scientific Computing Center, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology. · Institute for Information Systems, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology.
The original ImageNet benchmark enforces a single-label assumption, despite many images depicting multiple objects. This leads to label noise and limits the richness of the learning signal. Multi-label annotations more accurately reflect real-world visual scenes, where multiple objects co-occur and contribute to semantic understanding, enabling models to learn richer and more robust representations. While prior efforts (e.g., ReaL, ImageNetv2) have improved the validation set, there has not yet been a scalable, high-quality multi-label annotation for the training set. To this end, we present an automated pipeline to convert the ImageNet training set into a multi-label dataset, without human annotations. Using self-supervised Vision Transformers, we perform unsupervised object discovery, select regions aligned with original labels to train a lightweight classifier, and apply it to all regions to generate coherent multi-label annotations across the dataset. Our labels show strong alignment with human judgment in qualitative evaluations and consistently improve performance across quantitative benchmarks. Compared to traditional single-label scheme, models trained with our multi-label supervision achieve consistently better in-domain accuracy across architectures (up to +2.0 top-1 accuracy on ReaL and +1.5 on ImageNet-V2) and exhibit stronger transferability to downstream tasks (up to +4.2 and +2.3 mAP on COCO and VOC, respectively). These results underscore the importance of accurate multi-label annotations for enhancing both classification performance and representation learning. Project code and the generated multi-label annotations are available at https://github.com/jchen175/MultiLabel-ImageNet.
Junyu Chen, Md Yousuf Harun, Christopher Kanan
University of Rochester · Rochester Institute of Technology