Monotone but Exciting: On Evolving Monotone Boolean Functions with High Nonlinearity

In this note, we introduce a polynomial-time version of the mistake-bounded language generation (MBLG) framework due to Kleinberg, Peale, and Reingold (2026). We observe that the family of parities of variables, and the family of conjunctions of literals, are polynomial-time MBLG. Our main result states that the family of monotone Boolean functions with polynomially-many maxterms is polynomial-time MBLG. This family includes all monotone Boolean functions, computable by polynomial-size decision trees. Our technique can be presented as a new combinatorial game about writing numbers on a board.

Monotonicity has been a long-running architectural inductive bias for neural networks, motivated by tabular, scientific, and economic settings where outputs are known to respond monotonically to certain inputs. Existing approaches are MLP- or flow-based and lack per-edge functional transparency; the only Kolmogorov--Arnold Network (KAN) variant with monotonicity, MonoKAN, enforces the constraint only on a restricted parameter subset and requires a projection-style training procedure. We close this gap with \textbf{MKAN}, a KAN with hard monotonicity guaranteed for \emph{all} parameter values via exponential reparameterization of B-spline coefficients, positive edge weights, and a monotone base activation. Training reduces to standard unconstrained gradient descent. Our headline theoretical contribution is a \emph{representation-cost} theorem: any $C^K, K >0$ feature extractor inducing a ball-shaped semantic-neighborhood partition admits a monotone realization of the equivalent neighborhood structure at $N' = N^* + k \le 2N^*$, where $k$ is the number of non-monotone coordinates of the original. The bound is architecture-agnostic and gives a principled sizing rule for monotone encoders. Empirically, MKAN is competitive with state-of-the-art monotone NNs on the SMM/ICML-2024 benchmark while being the only method that combines hard unconstrained monotonicity with KAN's per-edge functional transparency; the $2N^*$ prediction is validated in a self-supervised feature-size sweep on four real datasets, and on a controlled monotone-generative dataset MKAN recovers ground-truth factors with substantially higher Spearman alignment than KAN, MLP, and linear baselines.

We introduce the Banach-Butterfly Invariant (BBT), an influence-adaptive Banach geometry on the Walsh-Hadamard butterfly factorization. For a Boolean function $f:\{-1,+1\}^n\to\{-1,+1\}$ with coordinate influences $\mathrm{Inf}_\ell(f)$, BBT assigns exponent $p_\ell = 1+\mathrm{Inf}_\ell(f)$ to butterfly layer $\ell$, yielding the contraction invariant $μ(f)=\prod_\ell 2^{-\mathrm{Inf}_\ell/(1+\mathrm{Inf}_\ell)}$. We prove a Jensen lower bound $\log_2μ(f) \ge -I(f)/(1+I(f)/n)$ and that $μ$ is strictly Schur-convex in the influence vector (modulo permutation), giving scaling classes $μ\sim 2^{-n/2}$ (parity), $2^{-Θ(\sqrt{n})}$ (majority), $2^{-1/2}$ (dictators). $\log_2μ$ is rational but not polynomial in the Fourier coefficients while $μ$ is algebraic, and $μ$ separates functions with identical total influence (122 pairs at $n=3$). Using the certified $n \le 4$ ternary Walsh-threshold universe from a companion synthesis manuscript as a finite testbed, we compute exact MILP minimum-support certificates for all 65,536 Boolean functions at $n=4$ (mean 6.42, max 9, all-odd by a parity argument) and on 10,000 of the 616,126 NPN-canonical representatives we enumerate at $n=5$ (matching OEIS A000370). Conditional Spearman $ρ(μ,|\mathrm{supp}|)$ at fixed total influence is $+0.571$ in the largest stratum at $n=4$ but reverses to $-0.38$ at $n=5$ under both function-uniform and NPN-canonical sampling: $μ$ is a valid Schur-convex concentration invariant, not a universal monotone predictor of minimum support across $n$. A companion application paper validates a real-valued WHT activation-energy proxy inspired by this theory on five pretrained LLMs at W2A16, cutting wikitext-2 perplexity by 15-58% versus vanilla auto-round; the transfer from Boolean theory to the real-valued proxy is qualitative, not formal.