RaLMPH: Reliability-aware Learning for Multi-Pathologist Harmonization in Whole-Slide Image Classification
Authors: Sungrae Hong, Jiwon Jeong, Soeun Cheon, Donghee Han, Sol Lee, Jisu Shin, Kyungeun Kim, Mun Yong Yi
Organizations: Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Daejeon, South Korea · Seegene Medical Foundation, Seoul, South Korea
Abstract
Multiple Instance Learning (MIL) is a standard paradigm for Whole-Slide Image (WSI) analysis and has achieved strong results in computational pathology. However, most MIL pipelines assume a single "gold" label per slide, which conflicts with clinical practice where substantial inter-pathologist variability is common. Existing multi-annotator learning and label-refinement methods typically estimate global annotator reliability or rely on single-instance assumptions, making them poorly suited to MIL and to localized diagnostic contexts where experts disagree. We propose RaLMPH (Reliability-aware Learning for Multi-Pathologist Harmonization), a MIL-based label reconciliation framework for WSIs annotated by multiple pathologists. RaLMPH introduces a reliability field that jointly models (i) local neighborhood structure in WSI feature space and (ii) expert uncertainty (entropy), enabling per-sample identification of trustworthy reference neighborhoods. Leveraging this field, RaLMPH performs sample-wise local annotator ranking to select reliable opinions per slide and applies an adaptive gating mechanism to fuse labels conditioned on local reliability. Experiments on a clinical WSI dataset with labels from six pathologists, as well as controlled simulated benchmarks, show that RaLMPH consistently outperforms existing approaches. Further analyses clarify how our reliability-aware mechanism improves label reconciliation and downstream MIL performance.
Multiple instance learning (MIL) has become a standard paradigm for whole slide image (WSI) analysis in digital pathology, as it enables slide-level prediction without dense annotations. Existing MIL methods typically rely on exhaustive extraction and encoding of high-resolution patches. However, this practice suffers from two critical limitations in real-world clinical settings: it struggles to capture global visual cues at lower magnifications, and incurs substantial computational overhead due to the massive number of high-resolution patches per slide. To address these limitations, we propose an efficient low-resolution multiple instance learning (LRMIL) framework that transfers high-resolution knowledge to low-resolution representations. LRMIL adopts a two-stage distillation strategy. First, patch-level cross-resolution distillation aligns low-resolution patch embeddings with high-resolution representations. Second, slide-level knowledge distillation trains a low-resolution student MIL model under both slide-level supervision and teacher guidance. At inference time, LRMIL operates exclusively on low-resolution patches, substantially reducing data preprocessing and computational cost. Extensive experiments on multiple WSI benchmarks demonstrate that LRMIL consistently outperforms state-of-the-art MIL methods while achieving more efficient inference. These results highlight LRMIL as a practical and scalable solution for WSI analysis in clinical pathology.
Multiple instance learning (MIL) is the standard approach for whole-slide image (WSI) classification and survival prediction, where attention-based models ag gregate patch features into slide-level predictions. These models treat attention weights as evidence for their predictions, but attention is optimized for classi fication, not for identifying which patches actually support the diagnosis. This conflation leads to three failures: selected patches are insufficient (keeping them alone drops Macro-F1 by 0.078), unnecessary (removing them barely changes the prediction), and unrecoverable (continuous attention scores disagree with discrete patch subsets used at inference). The central premise is that evidence quality should be optimized directly through explicit criteria- Sufficiency, Necessity, and Recov erability (S/N/R)- rather than inherited as a byproduct of classification. GCE-MIL is a backbone-agnostic wrapper implemented through three injection modes and three evidence components: a grounding mechanism that aligns selection with domain-specific concepts, noisy-OR coverage that acts as a differentiable proxy for interventional evidence search, and threshold-plus-repair recovery that converts continuous selectors into discrete subsets through marginal-guided repair. Across 9 backbones and 9 datasets (81 configurations), GCE-MIL improves average Macro-F1 by 0.024 and C-index by 0.014, reduces the continuous-discrete gap by 4-7, and increases complement degradation by 2-4. With optional tile prefiltering after discrete recovery, inference runs up to 5 faster while retaining 0.989 full-bag utility.
Whole slide image (WSI) analysis is central to computational pathology, with multiple instance learning (MIL) emerging as the standard pipeline for slide-level diagnosis. However, conventional approaches formulate WSI diagnosis as a flat classification task over discrete labels, contradicting the inherently hierarchical, coarse-to-fine nature of clinical reasoning. Although recent hierarchical classifiers and vision-language models (VLMs) have sought to address this structural gap, they either fail to capture semantic continuity between related diagnoses or suffer from unconstrained text generation that produces taxonomic hallucinations and parent-child label violations. To address these limitations, we propose TaxoMIL, a taxonomy-constrained framework that reformulates WSI diagnosis as a multi-granularity text generation task. TaxoMIL utilizes a dual-head Transformer decoder to generate coarse- and fine-level diagnostic text, and introduces taxonomy-guided objectives that explicitly structure the label embedding space and strictly ground slide-level visual representations within the clinical taxonomy. Extensive experiments across three diverse WSI datasets demonstrate that TaxoMIL consistently outperforms state-of-the-art MIL classifiers and VLM-based generative methods, yielding accurate and hierarchy-aware diagnostic predictions. The code is released at https://github.com/QuIIL/TaxoMIL