cs.IRJul 3, 2026

Modality Relevance is not Modality Utility: Post-hoc Selective Modality Escalation for Cost-Aware Multimodal RAG

Authors: Xue Li, Yiming Gai

Organizations: Hangzhou International Innovation Institute, Beihang University Hangzhou, China

Read PDF
Ask AI
Cite

Copy citation

DOINot available for this paper

Abstract

Multimodal retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) grounds a generator in evidence drawn from heterogeneous modalities -- text, tables, and images. The dominant deployment choice is binary and made before the model has tried to answer: either run a cheap text(+table) pipeline, or pay for an expensive vision-language model (VLM) over every image. Recent adaptive systems improve on this by selecting the modality or fidelity pre-retrieval, from a question-conditioned predictor of which modality will be needed. We show that this is the wrong decision point. Through an oracle headroom analysis on MultiModalQA, we find that the relevance of a modality to a question is a weak predictor of whether that modality is actually needed to answer correctly: a large fraction of questions whose gold support includes an image are nonetheless answerable from text and tables alone, and a pre-retrieval router that escalates on apparent visual relevance over-escalates substantially relative to an oracle. We propose \textbf{post-hoc selective modality escalation}: answer cheaply from text and tables, run a verifier on the (query, draft answer, evidence) tuple that localizes which modality is missing, and pay for VLM evidence only there. A calibrated value-of-escalation router then decides whether the expected accuracy gain justifies the visual cost. On MultiModalQA, our router recovers the accuracy of an always-on VLM pipeline while issuing far fewer visual calls, and closes most of the gap to the oracle escalation rate. The result extends a routing-signal hierarchy established for retrieval depth and reasoning hops to a third axis -- modality -- under a single cost-aware selective-escalation view.

Explore similar work

CardsList
May 13, 2026cs.CL

Utility-Oriented Visual Evidence Selection for Multimodal Retrieval-Augmented Generation

Visual evidence selection is a critical component of multimodal retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), yet existing methods typically rely on semantic relevance or surface-level similarity, which are often misaligned with the actual utility of visual evidence for downstream reasoning. We reformulate multimodal evidence selection from an information-theoretic perspective by defining evidence utility as the information gain induced on a model's output distribution. To overcome the intractability of answer-space optimization, we introduce a latent notion of evidence helpfulness and theoretically show that, under mild assumptions, ranking evidence by information gain on this latent variable is equivalent to answer-space utility. We further propose a training-free, surrogate-accelerated framework that efficiently estimates evidence utility using lightweight multimodal models. Experiments on MRAG-Bench and Visual-RAG across multiple model families demonstrate that our method consistently outperforms state-of-the-art RAG baselines while achieving substantial reductions in computational cost.
Weiqing Luo, Zongye Hu, Xiao Wang +3
Multi-Source Retrieval-Augmented GenerationVisual EvidenceMultimodal Learning
AskPDF
Sep 16, 2026cs.CL

Less Is More: Graph-free Multimodal RAG via Multi-signal Late Fusion

Graph-based retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) is widely used for multimodal, cross-document question answering. However, building corpus-level graphs is expensive, slow to query, and difficult to maintain. We present TrioRAG, a graph-free multimodal framework that integrates evidence from three complementary signals: the question, the anchor image, and a VLM-enhanced query generated from both. Each signal retrieves independently over a shared multi-vector index of page text and page images, and the results are combined through late fusion. Further, we introduce AutoQA, a multimodal automotive benchmark whose questions are grounded in noisy, web-sourced images rather than clean document-sourced figures. Its questions require reasoning across manuals. We position it as a model-curated testbed rather than a human-validated gold standard. Across three benchmarks, TrioRAG matches or outperforms graph-based systems while reducing total cost and accelerating per-query inference by 1.6-2.3 times. By construction, AutoQA grounds its questions in out-of-corpus web images. In this setting image retrieval reaches only 19.3% document-level recall, while text-derived signals, especially the VLM-enhanced query, keep retrieval robust.
Tithi Rakshit, Hongkuan Zhou, Lavdim Halilaj +1
Multi-Source Retrieval-Augmented GenerationGraph-Based Retrieval Augmented GenerationMultimodal Learning
AskPDF
Apr 4, 2026cs.IR

MG2^2-RAG: Multi-Granularity Graph for Multimodal Retrieval-Augmented Generation

Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) mitigates hallucinations in Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs), yet existing systems struggle with complex cross-modal reasoning. Flat vector retrieval often ignores structural dependencies, while current graph-based methods rely on costly ``translation-to-text'' pipelines that discard fine-grained visual information. To address these limitations, we propose \textbf{MG2^2-RAG}, a lightweight \textbf{M}ulti-\textbf{G}ranularity \textbf{G}raph \textbf{RAG} framework that jointly improves graph construction, modality fusion, and cross-modal retrieval. MG2^2-RAG constructs a hierarchical multimodal knowledge graph by combining lightweight textual parsing with entity-driven visual grounding, enabling textual entities and visual regions to be fused into unified multimodal nodes that preserve atomic evidence. Building on this representation, we introduce a multi-granularity graph retrieval mechanism that aggregates dense similarities and propagates relevance across the graph to support structured multi-hop reasoning. Extensive experiments across four representative multimodal tasks (i.e., retrieval, knowledge-based VQA, reasoning, and classification) demonstrate that MG2^2-RAG consistently achieves state-of-the-art performance while reducing graph construction overhead with an average 43.3×\times speedup and 23.9×\times cost reduction compared with advanced graph-based frameworks.
Sijun Dai, Qiang Huang, Xiaoxing You +1
Multi-Source Retrieval-Augmented GenerationCross-Modal LearningKnowledge Graph EmbeddingsExplicit Visual Grounding
AskPDF