Cover First, Disagree Softly: Rethinking Mismatch-First Active Learning for Frame-Level Audio Classification
Authors: Shiqi Zhang, Tuomas Virtanen
Organizations: Audio Research Group, Tampere University, Tampere, Finland
Abstract
Sound event detection relies on frame-level strong labels whose annotation is expensive. Active learning addresses this problem by selecting the audio segments whose labels help the classifier most. One of the prevailing acquisition strategies for this task, mismatch-first farthest-traversal (MFFT), combines the disagreement between two classifiers and the diversity of the selected segments through hard sequential decisions. It selects whole groups of high-disagreement segments first and spreads only the remaining budget by farthest traversal. On two multi-label datasets we show that this design is blind to the similarity among the selected segments and fails under low budgets, with every mismatch-first variant ending below the plain geometric strategy it builds on. We propose mismatch-weighted facility location (MW-FL), which spends the entire budget through a disagreement-weighted coverage objective that penalizes similarity among the selected segments. The disagreement signal from MFFT is used to obtain the nonnegative weights of this facility-location objective, without introducing hyperparameters. Experiments across two geometric mechanisms with three ways of using disagreement show that coverage of the selected segments is the dominant factor, hard disagreement gating of selection is harmful on both mechanisms, and soft disagreement weighting helps on top of coverage. MW-FL attains the best area under the learning curve on both datasets.
Bioacoustic call-type classification relies on costly expert annotation. Active learning can reduce this burden by selecting a small batch of segments for expert annotation and using the labeled segments for training the classifier. The setting is hard: the target calls are extremely sparse and the call-type distribution is long-tailed, so a tight budget must be spent on the few rare, informative segments. We propose BADGE-Greedy-DPP, a deterministic batch selector that greedily adds the segment whose BADGE gradient embedding most enlarges the volume spanned by the batch; because this log-volume objective is submodular, the greedy rule guarantees a batch value at least a (1-1/e) fraction of the optimum of this objective, a guarantee not provided by BADGE's existing k-means++ and MCMC DPP sampling heuristics. There is also a temporal granularity mismatch in the task. The acquisition function scores whole segments, yet the informative frames inside them are few. Uniform averaging therefore washes them out. We show that the BADGE construction naturally addresses this mismatch when applied frame-wise, as prediction residuals weight the aggregated pseudo-gradient, so confidently predicted no-call frames contribute little while a single uncertain rare-call frame can still set the segment's direction. Across 10 runs on a sparse, imbalanced hyena call-type dataset, BADGE-Greedy-DPP achieves the best overall and rare-call-type performance among all compared query strategies, including MFFT, the strongest non-BADGE baseline, and the two vanilla BADGE traversals.
Shiqi Zhang, Marius Faiß, Ariana Strandburg-Peshkin +1
Active learning is a promising framework for reducing annotation costs in large-scale bioacoustic monitoring, where expert labeling is expensive and data distributions are highly heterogeneous across environments. However, existing sample selection strategies often rely on static criteria that do not adapt to the evolving reliability of model predictions during training. This limitation can lead to suboptimal exploration-exploitation trade-offs and redundant sample selection. We propose an active learning strategy for multilabel bioacoustic event classification that jointly models predictive uncertainty, embedding-space diversity, and intra-batch redundancy. The method introduces an adaptive weighting scheme that progressively shifts from diversity-driven exploration in high-uncertainty regimes toward uncertainty-driven exploitation as the model becomes more confident, reflecting the increasing reliability of the classifier. To further improve annotation efficiency, a greedy Maximum Marginal Relevance (MMR) procedure is used to enforce diversity among selected samples within each acquisition batch. We evaluate the proposed approach within the BioDCASE 2026 Task 4 active learning framework on terrestrial (BirdSet) and marine (ATBFL) benchmarks using pretrained audio embeddings and a fixed annotation budget. Experimental results show consistent improvements in learning efficiency and competitive in terms of macro mean Average Precision (mAP) and Area Under the Learning Curve (AULC) across heterogeneous acoustic domains. The gains are particularly pronounced on structured terrestrial soundscapes, while performance remains competitive under noisier marine conditions. These findings demonstrate that adaptive acquisition strategies combining uncertainty estimation, embedding-space diversity, and redundancy-aware batch construction provide an effective and robust solution for [...].
The performance of acoustic machine learning systems is commonly evaluated using fully annotated test sets. In real-world deployments, however, exhaustively labeling large volumes of continuously collected audio data is often infeasible. Consequently, performance assessment typically relies on a small labeled subset of the available data, introducing a sampling bias that can severely distort evaluation metrics. This paper studies methods for compensating the bias in evaluation-labeled subsets under strict annotation-budget constraints. We study whether importance weighting techniques can mitigate this discrepancy by compensating for the selection bias. Specifically, we implement and compare three density-ratio estimation methods: kernel density estimation (KDE), logistic regression, and k-nearest neighbors (kNN), utilizing feature-space representations of the deployed audio. To emulate realistic deployment scenarios, the labeled subsets are generated using five distinct sampling strategies based on active learning techniques. Experiments conducted on an audio scene classification (ASC) benchmark demonstrate that importance weighting consistently yields more realistic accuracy estimates, significantly reducing the gap between subset-based metrics and the true evaluation performance.
Javier Naranjo-Alcazar, Annamaria Mesaros, Tuomas Virtanen +1