A Systematic Evaluation of Trajectory Data Curation for LoRA Fine-Tuning of Code Agents

Coding tasks are typically complicated and require multiple capabilities, ranging from high-level planning to low-level implementation. While coding agents are optimized for the joint capabilities, individual capabilities such as high-level planning may have different optima and remain a major bottleneck. To address this challenge, we train a separate critic model that is specialized in high-level planning to steer the coding agent in inference. We construct SFT and DPO data to train the critic model to identify errors made by the coding agent and provide correct and clear high-level guidance without generating concrete actions. Experiments show that our fine-tuned 4B and 8B critic models significantly improve the performance of 6 larger coding agents (e.g., improving the resolved rates of GLM-4.7-Flash-30B-A3B and GPT-OSS-120B by 16.0% and 14.4% on SWE-Bench Verified). The critic model also reduces the total inference costs for some coding agents by solving tasks in fewer steps (e.g., reducing the per-example inference cost for GPT-OSS-20B from $0.07 to $0.03). Code: https://github.com/shubhamrgandhi/critic-training

Multi-turn agent trajectories often contain redundant rounds (failed tool calls, parallel sub-queries, verification-only steps) that inflate both training and inference cost. We propose viewing each trajectory as a \emph{round-level dependency DAG} that exposes which rounds are globally load-bearing for the final answer, and fine-tune agents on trajectories refined through this DAG. Given an LLM-annotated DAG, these edits are deterministic and interpretable, with optional rephrasing. Models trained on these refined trajectories consistently outperform those trained on the original trajectories at lower inference cost. Specifically, across four multi-modal QA benchmarks, our refinements improve downstream accuracy by up to $1.7$,pp over vanilla SFT (and $5.7$,pp over an LLM-deletion baseline) while reducing per-sample inference messages by up to approximately $40\%$ and inference tokens by up to approximately $48\%$, translating to substantial savings in compute and serving cost. Code is available.

Supervised fine-tuning (SFT) on long teacher trajectories is the dominant way to instill investigation and reasoning in open software-engineering (SWE) agents. Since every retained response becomes an imitation target, the student inherits the final outcome and intermediate flaws, including ungrounded leaps and redundant loops. High-quality training data must be effective(each step is grounded and narrows the agent's epistemic gap to the correct fix) and efficient(each step is information-bearing rather than redundant or looping). Existing recipes filter or relabel teacher rollouts using only a binary terminal verifier, which does not directly target these axes and provides no supervision on instances where the teacher fails. Most real issue includes a developer-authored reference patch, $p^\star$, revealing the file paths, runtime behaviors, and coding conventions presupposed by the correct fix, yet standard pipelines discard it. We propose Patches-to-Trajectories (P2T), which uses $p^\star$ as privileged information during curation and formulates trajectory construction as bi-objective optimization over per-step effectiveness and trajectory length. A reverse phase distills $p^\star$ into a latent process graph, $G^\star$, of contextual facts and solution milestones. A forward phase curates trajectories from blinded teacher continuations by scoring per-step progress against $G^\star$ under a leakage-blocking groundedness check and retaining the shortest effective segments. Using only 1.8k curated SWE-Gym instances, P2T improves effectiveness and efficiency over outcome-filtered SFT and its tool-error-masking variant. On SWE-bench Verified, it raises Pass@1 by up to 10.8 points while reducing per-instance inference cost by ~15%, with consistent gains on SWE-bench Lite. Size-matched ablations and qualitative analysis further isolate trajectory quality from data scale.