physics.flu-dynAug 18, 2026

A Residual Learning Approach for Unsteady Aerodynamic Load Prediction

Authors: Divya Sanghi, Carlos E. S. Cesnik

Organizations: University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109

Abstract

This paper investigates the feasibility of using residual learning to improve unsteady aerodynamic load prediction for aeroelastic applications. The machine learning technique selected for the study is the long short-term memory (LSTM) neural network, which is used for its suitability for sequential data with aerodynamic memory effects. The approach is investigated for the NLR 7301 airfoil benchmark using high-fidelity CFD lift data for prescribed pitch and plunge motions in the transonic flow regime in the presence of shock motion. An analytical unsteady aerodynamic model based on the Wagner function is used as a physics-based baseline, and the neural network is trained to learn the difference between the CFD lift coefficient and the Wagner prediction. The residual model is compared with a direct neural-network model trained to predict the CFD lift coefficient. The comparison includes feature and normalization studies, external benchmark cases, and leave-one-out and leave-family-out generalization tests across a range of sinusoidal and non-sinusoidal motions. The residual model performs best when its inputs align with the Wagner formulation variables, generally giving lower error and more consistent performance across training runs, though the direct model remains more accurate for some high-frequency cases. The residual model also generalizes better in the leave-one-out and leave-family-out tests, with a smaller increase in error than the direct model when entire motion families are withheld from training. Overall, the results indicate that residual learning shows promise as a modular approach for augmenting classical low-order aerodynamic theories, especially when the physics baseline removes a structured part of the aerodynamic response and leaves a lower-variance correction for the neural network to learn.

Figures & tables

Explore similar work

Sep 18, 2026

Periodic Neural Mapping for Unsteady Rotor-Blade Pressure and Aeroelastic Load Prediction

Accurate prediction of unsteady aerodynamic loads remains a major challenge in turbomachinery design. High-fidelity Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulations are expensive, while aeroelastic Quantities of Interest (QoI) depend sensitively on the temporal evolution of the pressure field. This work introduces periodic Fourier Neural Mapping (p-FNM), a neural-operator framework for predicting unsteady pressure distributions on turbine rotor blades simulated using the chorochronic numerical hypothesis. The architecture embeds temporal periodicity into the model and learns a continuous mapping from operating conditions and time to pressure fields. Unlike sequential latent-space approaches, p-FNM predicts pressure fields independently at any time, avoiding error accumulation while preserving temporal continuity. The model is evaluated on a database of unsteady rotor-blade simulations and compared with a reduced-order baseline based on a variational autoencoder and recurrent neural network, refered as the Temporal Prediction Model (TPM). Performance is assessed for pressure fields and Generalized Aerodynamic Forces (GAFs), the primary aeroelastic QoI. Across all training datasets, p-FNM consistently outperforms TPM. On the largest dataset, p-FNM achieves a pressure-field mean absolute percentage error of 0.46% and a GAF-magnitude prediction error of 4.42%, corresponding to improvements of 60.7% and 77.6%, respectively. The minimum weighted phase error reaches 0.060 rad, demonstrating accurate preservation of the temporal characteristics of the aerodynamic response. The results show that GAF prediction is more challenging than pressure-field prediction and that temporal coherence is critical for accurately predicting spectral aerodynamic quantities. These findings demonstrate the potential of periodic neural operators for reduced-order modeling and aeroelastic analysis in turbomachinery.
Sep 27, 2026

Modelling non-linear aeroelastic loads in long-span bridges with extreme learning machines

Accurate modelling of aerodynamic loads is essential for predicting instabilities and ensuring the safety of long-span bridges. A methodology is introduced for modelling aerodynamic self-excited forces in bridge-deck cross-sections using extreme learning machines (ELMs). ELMs, as single-layer feedforward neural networks, offer efficient training and accurate predictions. Forced-oscillation datasets from computational fluid dynamics (CFD) or wind-tunnel experiments are used for training, enabling systematic data selection to capture non-linear aerodynamic behaviour often missed by semi-analytical approaches. Once trained, the model predicts self-excited loads for any arbitrary motion composed by frequencies and amplitudes within the training domain. Comparisons with analytical, semi-analytical, and CFD results show superior accuracy in capturing non-linear force components and close agreement for aerodynamic loads and flutter wind speeds. Training required about 1.1% of the time of a conventional neural network, and coupled flutter analysis runs in seconds, providing orders-of-magnitude speed-ups over CFD. These results indicate that ELM-based frameworks are accurate, practical, and efficient alternatives for modelling self-excited loads, particularly when preliminary CFD or wind-tunnel data are available. The presented approach offers a reliable data-driven technique for aeroelastic load modelling in long-span bridges.
Jul 17, 2026

Spatio-Temporal Prediction of Unsteady Airfoil Aerodynamics Using Augmented Graph Neural Ordinary Differential Equations with Exogenous Controls

Unsteady aerodynamic phenomena, such as gusts, turbulence, and fluid-structure interactions affect an aircraft during flight. For design, optimisation and certification, it is indispensable to quantify such unsteady aerodynamic effects. Industry-standard computational fluid dynamics methods, such as solving the unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes equations or the linearized frequency domain method, are either computationally expensive or restricted by assumptions like linearity. Once trained, machine learning methods are capable of computing non-linear relationships very fast, making them suitable as surrogate models. By autoregressively applying graph neural networks (GNNs), operating on a discretised spatial domain, spatio-temporal predictions can be made. However, autoregressive GNNs suffer from error accumulation leading to unstable rollouts over time. Here we show that combining GNNs with augmented Neural Ordinary Differential Equations yields temporally stable predictions of the surface forces on a pitching airfoil. We found that our approach, called GNODE, based on Graph Neural Ordinary Differential Equations, provides temporally more stable, spatially smoother, and overall more accurate results than an autoregressive GNN baseline. Tests are conducted on a dataset consisting of a simulations of a pitching airfoil, including transonic shocks, transient behaviour and dynamic non-linearities. Augmenting GNODEs with additional latent dimensions improves the expressivity and accuracy by capturing underlying history effects. The developed method demonstrates an approach that is suitable to model non-linear spatio-temporal systems with exogenous inputs.