cs.AISep 28, 2026
SaveNociception as a Control Primitive: Afferent Channels and Nociceptive Memory for Agents Deployed in One Body
Organizations: Saarland University and German Research Center for Artificial Intelligence (DFKI)
Abstract
An agent deployed in a single body cannot learn how fast that body wears, because every trial that would reveal its wear resistance wears the body it would protect. We study this \emph{epoch-one} setting, in which the parameters of a fixed-weight policy are set before the body is drawn and never updated in life. The agent carries a load-gated nociceptive channel and a memory that retains what was felt. We prove that felt cost moves the allocation to the best-\emph{paid} work not yet felt rather than the gentlest, that an agent without retention never sees the felt-cost constraint bind, and that the channel pays only where the threat is individually unpredictable, cheap to avoid and expensive to ignore. We measure per body, setting the agent with channel and memory against the same individual without them, where neither carries a schedule learned across lives. On simulated floor-layer knees, with wear anchored to published loss rates, feeling, retaining and substituting extends the working life from age to and raises career output from to . of bodies gain and \textbf{none lose}. A body that feels but retains nothing past the day gains one of the years, and retention carries the rest. A population-trained agent gains years from the same channel at output. The difference is what a species prior already supplies, and a single body has none. The two are related by an identity, the ablation mean reporting of the per-body value with the share a blind schedule already captures, so we report both. Where the regime map predicts value, a care robot sextuples its certified service life and a field-anchored fleet writes off of its machines instead of . Where it predicts none, a rover gains little over blind caution, so the map holds in both directions.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: Architecture. The fast loop is one life inside a single hidden draw of the world. The dashed line is the observation boundary, crossed only by the afferent signal. The decision level allocates the day, which sets the load, the wear and the strength of the next signal, and its in-life state is the recorded felt cost per activity (probe) or a nociceptive memory (trained arm). The slow loop feeds the fast loop only before the life begins, with the draw and with the parameters of both the afferent layer and the decision level, and receives nothing back (Def. 1 ). The experimenter reads the whole life across the observation boundary and sets nothing inside it.
| floor layer, absolute | care robot | rover | fleet | |||||||
| what the body does | works to | output | life | output | life | output | life | output | ||
| works at full effort, reads nothing | ||||||||||
| spares from the first day † | ||||||||||
| fixed endowment †§ | — | — | — | — | — | — | ||||
| trained, feels nothing ‡ | ||||||||||
| trained, full stack ‡ | ||||||||||
Table 1: Three ways to use one body, in four worlds, on the same individuals. All arms are paired, and no arm carries a schedule learned across lives (Def. 1 ). Floor layer: works to is the age the trade ends, output career output, cartilage lost, meniscal competence retained ( bodies). Machines: the first row gives the service life (certified months for the care robot, months otherwise) and the output of the arm that reads nothing ( paired lives per robot, in the fleet), the other rows the percent change against it. The fleet runs to a horizon of months, which the retaining arm reaches in every life, so its gain is a lower bound. † Not admissible as a reference, since it already knows which work is gentlest. § Trade only, since a machine reads every activity at once and an endowment is overwritten by the first reading. ‡ PPO. Trade: environment steps, paired seeds, paired lives per seed, output as the trade paid it. Robots: steps, seeds, the rover at residual stream . Fleet: steps, seeds, entropy (App. C ). The blind trained arm already carries the population’s schedule (it reaches without a channel), so these rows measure what a species prior gains from the channel, while the value to one body is the last row against the first.
Appendix figures & tables10 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
Figure 2: The same stack in four worlds, both endpoints per world. Bars are the arms of Table 1 on the same paired bodies, and the dotted line is the body that reads nothing. In the trade and the care robot the retaining arm and the present-signal arm separate in opposite directions, slot (b) paying in one and costing in the other. In the rover blind caution reaches almost the whole gain, and in the fleet the one-shot memory alone takes the write-off rate from to (App. Table 7 ), while the present-signal arm stays within of the reference, the one-step twitch of condition (b). Its trained arms are in Table 1 and App. Table 2 . Drawn from results/fig_arme_welten.json , which collects the files of Table 1 and App. C .
| wear takes the movement away | no wear | |||
| what the body carries | floor layer | care robot | latent-defect agent | |
| loses trade | decertified | written off | ||
| feels, minds, remembers | ||||
| feels nothing | ||||
| feels, is not moved to act | n.s. | n.s. | ||
| feels and acts, but forgets | n.s. | n.s. | ||
Table 2: The same three parts, for trained policies. The share of lives that lose the paid work before the horizon, for one chain run through a floor layer’s cartilage, a care robot’s joints and a latent-defect fleet ( environment steps, for the robot). seeds per arm, for the care robot, and against the intact body, n.s. marks a cell the measurement cannot separate from it.
| variant | entr. | full | ignorant | memory heur. | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| cascade | / | / | / | / | / | / | |
| cascade | / | / | / | / | |||
| cascade , seeds | / | / | / | / | / | / | |
| defective, | / | / | / | / | / | / | |
| defective, | / | / | / | / |
Table 3: Field-anchored fleet (Clusters 196499 and 196650, seeds per cell unless stated, paired lives per cell): death rate / welfare , medians over seeds. For the variant the death rate is conditional on carrying the defect and is unconditional. Right: the same bodies under the ignorant static and the one-shot nociceptive-memory heuristic.
| what was wrong | what it produced, and the check |
| The floor was switched off in both machine configurations | Sparing costs nothing, so the felt arms lose, output against blind caution, and with the floor restored the same probe gains months. Check that the floor can bind. |
| The rover’s floor was on the wrong quantity | It scored science yield while the mission is the traverse, so a portfolio parked at the instrument station cleared the floor at zero speed and the sparing arm completed of milestones in every life. Fixed with a progress floor at the rover’s own plan rate. |
| The rover’s mission ends long before its career does | Every policy completes all three milestones by month – of and earns the same reward to within , so of the horizon is driving with nothing left to achieve. No floor repairs this, and the run was withdrawn for the design in Table 1 . |
| The horizon censored the protected arms | of felt lives ran into the care robot’s horizon against of insensate ones, understating the effect roughly tenfold, becoming once the horizon was lifted. Check that censoring falls on both arms alike. |
| Career length was not in the objective | Under average-reward training an episode ending on losing the work costs nothing, since episode length does not enter a per-step average, mean reward without an absorbing exit against with it. Every ablation then beat the intact stack. One common functional across arms, and the training signal is never the endpoint. |
| Career length could not move in the capacity-exit acute knee | Every fixed probe reached exactly over bodies, since under maximal load damage reached only by and the only exit was the clock. Re-anchored, the exit fires in of lives and careers end at . Check, before any arm is compared, that the world can express protection at all. |
Figure 3: Both headline numbers against the specialization axis. The band is the anchoring, not the sampling. Paired, bodies per point. (a,b) Career length and output against the degree of specialization, the band spanning the anchored lost flexion ( Zhou et al., 2023 ) (a confidence interval would span years). (c) Per-body distribution at the observed mix: filled, the whole apparatus ( gain, none lose); outline, the memory’s part alone ( gain, none lose), which carries of the years.
Figure 4: The middle link, over paired bodies. Means over the bodies still working at that age, drawn while at least a fifth of them are. (a) The day’s share on the work that pays best and wears the joint. (b) How many activities the day contains at all, each at least of it. (c) The share on the two gentle grips the trade offers (load below ). (d) The same day at , heavy (dark) to gentle (pale), activities under pooled at the right. Mechanism, not result: the result is printed below.
Figure 5: The chain, with the quantity that carries each link. Means over the paired bodies of the anchored cell, the same bodies in every arm. Escape load is the hazard-weighted mean of the non-kneeling part of the day, and returns counts the years a body takes the heavy work back after leaving it. The two head numbers sit at the last link, and everything left of them is mechanism.
| the result | the mechanism | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| what the body carries | works to | output | on the knees | on gentle work | returns | at |
| reads nothing | ||||||
| present signal, no retention | – | – | ||||
| reads the signal and remembers | ||||||
Table 5: The middle link as a quantity, on the same paired bodies as Table 1 . Working life only. On the knees and on gentle work are shares of the day over the last five working years, gentle meaning the two grips below load . Returns counts the years the heavy work is taken back after having been left. at is cartilage damage relative to the insensate body, over the bodies still in the trade at in every arm. Ranges are a tie-break span, not a confidence interval. † Not a decision: that share moves because the joint stops delivering. Source results/substitution_spur_b042.json .
| cell ( , work available) | years | CI | output | CI |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| , | [ , ] | [ , ] | ||
| , | [ , ] | [ , ] | ||
| , | [ , ] | [ , ] | ||
| , | [ , ] | [ , ] | ||
| , | [ , ] | [ , ] | ||
| , | [ , ] | [ , ] |
Table 6: on both headline numbers, against a body that senses nothing and learns nothing ( paired bodies per cell, seven of fifteen cells, the rest interpolate monotonically). The second axis is how much of the trade’s work one worker may specialize into, and is the observed population mix. All cells are the pinned world results/bodenleger_lp_b042 . Every interval excludes zero.
| world (exit rule) | same body without / with | body endpoint | career (y, CI), and | gain/lose |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| knee, wear with tears, (total-output floor, gate cell) | ignorant / full | early exit ; tears per exposed year unchanged | ; (all) | / |
| knee, wear with tears, | same | cap rarely binds | ; | / |
| fleet (absorbing death) | uniform static / one-shot nociceptive memory | written off in of lives against ; service months, output | ( ) | / |
| care robot, anchored floor | full contact / reads the signal and spares | service months | output ( ) | / |
Table 7: across the worlds: the same body with and without a fixed protective response, no schedule learned across lives. Paired bodies: knee per cell, fleet , care , and the rover’s probes are in App. C ( lives). is the common functional of Eq. 2, all five random streams are seeded per life, and the care row is measured at the anchored floor with an uncensored horizon. ‡ Censored: see below.