Do bioacoustic foundation models hear through the noise ? SNR and generalization in underwater detection
Authors: Lucie Jean-Labadye, Nicolas Farrugia, Axel Marmoret, Dorian Cazau, Olivier Adam
Organizations: Sorbonne Universit´e, Institut ∂’Alembert, UMR CNRS 7190, F-75005, Paris, France · ENSTA, Lab-STICC, UMR CNRS 6285, F-29806, Brest, France · IMT Atlantique, Lab-STICC, UMR CNRS 6285, F-29238 Brest, France
Bioacoustic foundation models are claimed to generalize across taxa and recording conditions, but are trained mainly on terrestrial archives of focal, high-quality recordings and evaluated on benchmarks emphasizing architecture over data conditions. We evaluate four such models as frozen encoders on an underwater detection task, using linear probing on continuously recorded data from the Kerguelen Plateau. Four datasets of identical size were built to differ only in the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of their positive segments, and probes were trained and evaluated across all combinations. Evaluation SNR accounts for more variation in average precision (AP) than model choice, and performance peaks when training and evaluation share a noise regime --- the configuration least representative of a continuous deployment. Training on mixed SNR redistributes performance toward low-SNR conditions without improving it overall, and AP remains low throughout. In light of these results, we call for evaluation standards grounded in realistic noise and deployment conditions rather than curated, high-quality recordings.
Figures & tables
Figure 1: SNR distribution across the whole dataset, with an example spectrogram for each level
Train
Val.
Test
Positive segments
6996
1749
2187
Negative segments
6996
1749
36187
Control, per stratum
2332
583
729
Table 1: Data splits. All four conditions have the same size and differ only in the SNR of their positives.
Figure 2: Pairwise AP differences between models
Figure 3: AP of esp-effnet across training and evaluation SNR
Bioacoustic foundation models rely on large-scale citizen science platforms like Xeno-Canto for geographically and ecologically diverse data. Recent work has shown that supervision alone can produce SotA species detection models when trained on this large-scale data -- however, there remains unutilized potential in the form of recording metadata readily available within these community-driven data hubs. In this work, we explore the use of metadata -- such as location and time -- as auxiliary supervision signals, allowing the model to leverage species-metadata correlations in its learned representation. Auxiliary metadata losses provide additional information beyond vocalizations alone that can encourage a richer, more robust representation that generalizes better to species distribution and acoustic domain shifts -- important challenges for deployment in real-world passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) settings. We introduce MetaPerch, a new foundation model that achieves strong species identification performance across multiple challenging domains and present an extensive empirical study of the effects of 9 diverse metadata sources on 17 bioacoustic datasets.
Mustafa Chasmai, Vincent Dumoulin, Jenny Hamer
University of Massachusetts Amherst. · Google DeepMind.
Bioacoustics and ethology encompass a wide range of audio understanding tasks, many of which stand to benefit from recent advances in large audio-language models. However, progress in the field has so far been assessed on a narrow set of tasks, primarily centered on label-centric biological category recognition, such as species and call-type classification. In this work, we introduce BEANS-Next, a benchmark grounded in a taxonomy of bioacoustics tasks spanning acoustic perception, biological category recognition, scene understanding, and in-context learning. Using BEANS-Next, we show that existing models exhibit limited performance beyond the task families emphasized by existing evaluations, constraining their usefulness for broader bioacoustic applications. To support progress on this broader task space, we also introduce ROOTS, a large-scale training resource built from expanded curated real-world data and previously underused behavioral and acoustic metadata, supplemented by audio-derived information and scalable synthetic generation where labeling is insufficient. We demonstrate that training on this dataset yields substantial progress across all task groups of BEANS-Next, moving audio-language models closer to their potential as general-purpose assistants for bioacoustics and ethology. To accelerate progress in the field, we open-source our benchmark, dataset, and data pipelines.
Christos Plachouras, David Robinson, Marius Miron +17
Earth Species Project · Queen Mary University of London
Modern bioacoustic foundation models like Perch and BirdNET can identify species with high discriminative accuracy, yet their confidence scores are often uncalibrated and difficult to interpret as probabilities of real-world occurrence. This limits their use for ecological inference beyond threshold-based detection. We leverage a global annotated acoustic dataset (WABAD) to produce calibration priors for an acoustic model, optionally incorporating species-level information. We introduce new methods of fusing the acoustic predictions with geopriors, which empirically improves calibration while preserving discrimination. Together, these results suggest a path to simpler and more reliable acoustic monitoring for broad biodiversity.
Neha Sajja, Bart van Merriënboer, Burcu Karagol Ayan +1