Robotic Manipulation Surfaces (RMS) reposition objects by deforming the surface on which they rest. A recent class of RMS suspends a continuous fabric sheet from a sparse grid of vertical linear actuators lowering the actuator density of such surfaces but how to design such surfaces so that objects can be controlled everywhere on it, and how to extend it beyond a single module so that objects can pass between modules and achieve parallel, remain open. This paper presents a separable catenary model of the suspended sheet that is fast to compute and provides both the surface shape for given actuator heights and the actuator heights for a desired local slope. The closed form inverse lets a simple PID controller position objects on the sheet, and the model relates fabric length, module span and actuator stroke to the reachable workspace, yielding a minimum fabric length bound and design charts for these surfaces. The approach is then extended to a multimodular platform in which neighbouring modules share actuators. On a 2×2 prototype, we demonstrate that centimetre-scale objects are transferred between modules and positioned within 0.03 m over a 1m2 workspace with only nine actuators, enabling multi-object manipulation and opening the way to parallel manipulation.
Figures & tables
Fig. 1 : Multimodular soft manipulation surface. (A) Physical platform during manipulation of a spherical object. (B) Top view of the nine actuators (A0 to A8) and the four modules (M0 to M3) with the fabric removed. Adjacent modules share two actuators and diagonal modules share one. (C) MuJoCo model of the 2×2 configuration showing an object (green sphere) and its target location (blue cylinder).
Fig. 2 : Separable catenary surface model on a single module. (a) Single axis catenary of ( 1 ) to ( 5 ) between the supports of one module: the vertex at x0 lies a above the directrix, the commanded slope m is the tangent at the target xt , and the corner heights h(cjx) are measured from the datum h(xt)=0 . The fabric length S and the module span D fix a through ( 5 ). (b) Minimum fabric length of ( 6 ). (c) Surface of ( 7 ) as the sum of the two cross sections through pt=(xt,yt) , with the corner heights qˉj of ( 8 ) measured from the mean plane (dashed) and the error vector e driving the controller of Section V-A .
Fig. 3 : Surface models against the measured fabric for the command [+82.5,−27.5,−27.5,−27.5] mm. Top: the surface fitted through the 49 tracked markers (red dots) and the four model surfaces. Bottom: the applied command, then each model’s signed height error over the support square; small dots mark the marker lattice, large dots the supports.
Simulation
Hardware
Model
ϵz [mm]
ϵ∇
ϵz [mm]
ϵ∇
Command of Fig. 3 , [+82.5,−27.5,−27.5,−27.5] mm
Planar
39.4
0.37
50.9
0.67
Catenary
15.9
0.23
29.1
0.41
VVCM
30.9
0.33
49.9
0.65
Membrane energy
6.5
0.08
29.1
0.42
TABLE I : Height error ϵz (mm) and slope error ϵ∇ (dimensionless) of the four models. Top: the single command of Fig. 3 , one RMS value per model. Bottom: mean ± sd over the three support configurations.
Object (mass, size in cm)
Motion
Catenary
VVCM
Membrane
Sphere (32 g, ∅ 4.5)
rolling
7.1
8.3
18.4
Egg (61 g, ∅ 4.1 to 6.2)
rolling
8.8
14.6
25.5
Cube (31 g, 4.2)
mixed
14.9
21.7
33.2
Cylinder (71 g, ∅ 3 × 13)
mixed
12.1
15.6
25.3
Disk (26 g, ∅ 7 × 2.5)
sliding
14.3
20.1
31.4
TABLE II : Test objects and normalised equilibrium error eˉ=ep/D in %, where ep is the mean distance in simulation between the settled object position and the minimum of each model’s surface, over 40 corner configurations per object.
Latency [ms]
Model
Complexity
N=4
N=9
N=16
Inverse
Planar
O(N)
0.02
0.04
0.06
20 μ s
Catenary
O(N)
6.9
9.3
9.8
20 μ s
VVCM, general zj
O(T(N)polyK)
18.4
2767
6.1×105 ∗
none
VVCM, uniform zr
O(T(N)K3)
0.17
25.5
3140
none
Membrane energy
O(iters⋅M)
240
488
675
none
TABLE III : Cost of one forward evaluation per model on rigs of N supports. T(N)=∑K=3N(KN) is the number of VVCM taut sets (5, 466 and 65 399); M the number of mesh nodes (225, 441 and 625). Inverse: cost of the closed form map from commanded slope to support heights. ∗ Extrapolated from the measured per set cost.
Fig. 4 : Success rate maps for a sphere on a single module in simulation. (a) Planar controller [ 7 ] . (b) Catenary controller.
Fig. 5 : Design space of a suspended fabric module. Top: margin maps μ(xt,yt) of ( 9 ) at five operating points A ∗ to E of increasing fabric slack; green is positive margin, red is actuator saturation and the black contour is the zero margin boundary. Bottom: reachable workspace percentage over fabric length and actuator limit (left) and over fabric length and module span (right), with the blue curve giving Smin from ( 6 ) and the star marking the operating point of the platform. Parameters not varied are held at D=0.5 m and umax=0.16 m.
Simulation
Hardware
Object
SR 3
t3 [s]
efin [cm]
SR 3
t3 [s]
efin [cm]
Sphere
2/2
6.2±1.0
0.9±0.0
2/2
6.4±0.4
1.6±0.7
Cube
2/2
16.7±1.2
1.9±0.3
2/2
8.5±2.8
1.9±0.4
Disk
2/2
19.2±0.5
2.7±0.2
2/2
11.1±2.5
2.3±0.1
Egg
2/2
8.1±0.1
1.6±0.3
1/2
5.3
2.1±2.5
Cylinder
2/2
13.5±0.9
1.5±0.5
1/2
9.9
3.7±3.2
TABLE IV : End to end target reaching with the catenary controller on the 2×2 simulated membrane and hardware platform: two trials per object. SR 3 : trials that came within 3 cm of the target at any time; t3 : time from trial start, transfer included, to first reach 3 cm, over successful trials; efin : final distance to the target. Mean ± sd. Every trial came within 5 cm except one hardware cylinder trial.
No comp.
Comp.
Scenario
Object
drms
dmax
drms
dmax
Δ
Target, adjacent
Sphere
0.217
0.460
0.047
0.078
78%
Target, adjacent
Disk
0.064
0.076
0.026
0.040
59%
Target, diagonal
Sphere
0.031
0.058
NA
NA
NA
Target, diagonal
Disk
0.035
0.044
NA
NA
NA
Transfer, perp.
Sphere
0.044
0.065
0.031
0.044
30%
TABLE V : Displacement of a stationary object on a passive module while an object is manipulated on a neighbouring module, in metres, mean of three repetitions. drms , dmax : root mean square and maximum displacement over the manipulation; Δ : reduction of drms with compensation; lost: object left the module; NA: not tested.