Bootstrap Inference for Riemannian Optimization Problems
Authors: Xiaotian Chang, Qirui Hu, Yangdi Jiang, Nan Qiao
Organizations: Division of Mathematical Sciences, Nanyang Technological University. · School of Statistics and Data Science, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics. · School of Mathematics, Statistics and Mechanics, Beijing University of Technology, China.
We develop an online multiplier bootstrap for manifold-valued parameters estimated by averaging the iterates of Riemannian stochastic approximation. The method runs weighted iterations alongside the original algorithm, with each path using the same observations while updating its own state and intrinsic average. The weighted averages provide uncertainty assessments without a plug-in asymptotic covariance estimator. Under local stability and regularity conditions, we establish bootstrap consistency and show that a fixed number of paths suffices for asymptotically valid Student intervals and intrinsic confidence regions. The theory accommodates samplewise nonsmooth scores and identifies a critical oracle-bias regime in which the estimator's limiting distribution shifts, but the centered bootstrap distribution does not. Applications include spherical means, positive-definite matrix means and medians, and principal-subspace estimation. Simulations show coverage close to nominal in regular settings, and an analysis of North Atlantic storm locations illustrates descriptive online inference for a spherical center.
Figures & tables
Symmetric
Skew
Method
n=250
n=500
n=100
n=250
Proposed ( B=1 )
0.940
0.938
0.954
0.950
Proposed ( B=3 )
0.956
0.954
0.942
0.938
Proposed ( B=5 )
0.960
0.950
0.938
0.942
Proposed ( B=10 )
0.952
0.946
0.936
0.932
Proposed (quantile)
0.968
0.944
0.932
0.924
Table 1: Nominal 95% coverage in localized spherical designs. Proposed Student and quantile intervals use ( 7 ) and ( 35 ); the quantile and offline methods each use 200 replicates.
Proposed (Student)
Proposed (quantile)
Sandwich
Offline
B=1
B=3
B=5
B=10
B=200
B=200
0.948
0.958
0.950
0.970
0.964
0.948
0.900
Table 2: Nominal 95% coverage in the wider-cap spherical design ( q=2 , n=1000 ). Proposed (quantile) and offline basic intervals each use 200 replicates.
Figure 1: Proposed ( B=10 ) coverage in regular designs; the dashed line marks 95%. Spherical laws differ between horizons, so connecting segments are visual guides rather than same-law sample-size trends.
Contamination probability
Fréchet mean
Geometric median
0
0.930
0.936
0.05
0.952
0.948
0.15
0.952
0.956
Table 3: Nominal 95% coverage of Proposed ( B=10 ) for the largest log eigenvalue of the common positive-definite mean and median ( 3×3 matrices, n=5000 ).
Appendix figures & tables3 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
Symmetric
Skew
Wider cap
Method
n=250
n=500
n=100
n=250
n=1000
Proposed ( B=1 )
0.3280
0.2316
0.8337
0.4994
0.2814
Proposed ( B=3 )
0.1075
0.0720
0.2782
0.1775
0.0963
Proposed ( B=5 )
0.0927
0.0634
0.2384
0.1515
0.0818
Proposed ( B=10 )
0.0841
0.0573
0.2217
0.1370
0.0737
Proposed (quantile)
0.0764
0.0526
0.1996
0.1256
0.0662
Appendix
Table 4: Median 95% interval lengths for the spherical coverage comparisons. Proposed (quantile) and offline methods each use 200 replicates; all methods share the base estimator within a configuration.
Quantity
Estimate
95% fixed B=10
95% large B=200
Longitude
−59.88
[−61.77,−57.98]
[−61.57,−58.37]
Latitude
21.92
[21.06,22.78]
[21.11,22.49]
Appendix
Table 5: North Atlantic first recorded tropical/subtropical locations, 1980–2025. Coordinates and interval endpoints are in degrees; west longitudes are negative. All displayed intervals are descriptive working-independence multiplier intervals.
Figure 2: Retained storm-level locations and the chronological online intrinsic center. The plotted points are first archive records satisfying the tropical/subtropical filter, not physical genesis estimates.
We develop online statistical inference for Polyak-Ruppert averages of inexact Newton iterates on Riemannian manifolds. A local asymptotic representation separates observation noise, solver randomization, and accumulated implementation bias, and yields one-pass covariance estimators and asymptotically valid Wald regions under local regularity and centering conditions. Independent fresh solves add a positive semidefinite term to the score-sandwich covariance; averaging solver replicas reduces this term in inverse proportion to their number. Slowly varying predictable gains instead cancel from the first order law. Product torus simulations show how Newton scaling shortens an ill-conditioned transient and how retaining solver variation restores coverage. Intrinsic means and principal subspaces provide geometric applications, with a streaming data illustration.
Xiaotian Chang, Qirui Hu, Yangdi Jiang +1
Division of Mathematical Sciences, Nanyang Technological University. · School of Statistics and Data Science, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics. · School of Mathematics, Statistics and Mechanics, Beijing University of Technology, China.
We develop inference for manifold-valued population minimizers when each observation belongs to a different participant and only locally private messages reach the analyst. The method releases randomized tangent gradients and combines them through Riemannian stochastic approximation and Polyak-Ruppert averaging. Directly inserting a private data surrogate into a nonlinear loss can shift its population target, whereas conditional centring of the released gradient preserves the first-order equation. We introduce symmetric-pair regression (SPR) to estimate the asymptotic variance from the same private messages used for point estimation, without holding out participants or requesting a second release. We prove the central limit theorem and consistency of the fully transcript-based sandwich covariance and intrinsic Wald region under local differential privacy. Simulations across various statistical problems and manifolds support the predicted decrease in estimation error and near-nominal coverage under moderate privacy. An application to NHANES anthropometric data illustrates private estimation of a leading body-size direction and its uncertainty.
Xiaotian Chang, Yangdi Jiang, Qirui Hu
School of Physical and Mathematical Sciences, Nanyang Technological University · School of Statistics and Data Science, Shanghai University of Finance and Economics.
We study online inference for averaged Riemannian stochastic gradient descent (RSGD) when the unknown parameter lies on a manifold. Although the averaged RSGD iterate is asymptotically normal, practical inference requires estimating the unknown covariance operator in its limiting distribution. Existing online batch-means methods cannot be applied directly because a general Riemannian manifold lacks an addition operation, and the tangent space containing the Riemannian gradient varies across iterations. Through vector transport, we construct overlapping and non-overlapping covariance estimators that adaptively combine information from successive batches while accounting for the changing tangent spaces. The proposed estimators are online, require neither Riemannian Hessian computations nor a prespecified terminal sample size, and attain the same convergence rates as their Euclidean counterparts (Zhu et al., 2023). Together with asymptotic normality, these estimators enable online statistical inference for RSGD on manifolds. We illustrate the proposed framework through a detailed study of streaming principal component analysis on Grassmann manifolds.
Jingrong Guan, Liwei Jiang, Sen Na
Department of Industrial Engineering and Management Sciences, Northwestern University · Edwardson School of Industrial Engineering, Purdue University · School of Industrial and Systems Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology