q-bio.NCNov 2, 2026

When Model Complexity Matters in Cross-Subject Naturalistic fMRI Prediction

Authors: Junhao Zhao, Jacob Kang, Colin Kurniawan, David Simberg, Nan Xu

Organizations: Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA · Fischell Department of Bioengineering, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA · Department of Computer Science, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA · Brain and Behavior Institute, University of Maryland, College Park, MD, USA · 

Abstract

Increasingly complex neural models predict blood-oxygen-level-dependent (BOLD) responses to naturalistic stimuli, but the predictive value of this added complexity remains unclear. We ask when pretrained stimulus representations help and how much downstream complexity is needed, with and without recent measured BOLD history. We compare linear diagnostic references and nonlinear predictors across HCP movie fMRI (154 subjects), BOLD Moments (10 subjects), and Algonauts 2025 (4 subjects). Under a shared offline protocol, models are fitted on training subjects and evaluated on held-out subjects viewing largely familiar stimuli, without refitting. Pretrained visual features generally improve prediction over raw pixels; for linear autoregression, this advantage becomes more pronounced over longer rollouts (recursive predictions without additional measured BOLD). Measured BOLD history provides substantial gains that generally diminish {as rollouts lengthen}. Nonlinear stimulus-only predictors can improve on linear readouts, whereas linear autoregression provides a strong history-conditioned baseline. Controls examine context length, regularization, fitting procedures, and model capacity. Regional response consistency across subjects is associated with held-out prediction accuracy, while less consistent regions tend to gain more from measured history. In paired simulations with fixed linear neural dynamics, slower hemodynamic responses generally sustain high temporal prediction correlations over longer rollouts, illustrating how the observation process can contribute to predictive persistence. Together, these findings support evaluating stimulus representations and downstream complexity separately, using history-conditioned linear prediction as a diagnostic reference under matched inputs and measurement availability.

Figures & tables

Appendix figures & tables20 assets

Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.

Appendix

Explore similar work

Apr 13, 2026

Probabilistic Prediction of Neural Dynamics via Autoregressive Flow Matching

Forecasting neural activity in response to naturalistic stimuli remains a key challenge for understanding brain dynamics and enabling downstream neurotechnological applications. Here, we introduce a generative forecasting framework for modeling neural dynamics based on autoregressive flow matching (AFM). Building on recent advances in transport-based generative modeling, our approach probabilistically predicts neural responses at scale from multimodal sensory input. Specifically, we learn the conditional distribution of future neural activity given past neural dynamics and concurrent sensory input, explicitly modeling neural activity as a temporally evolving process in which future states depend on recent neural history. We evaluate our framework on the Algonauts project 2025 challenge functional magnetic resonance imaging dataset using subject-specific models. AFM significantly outperforms both a non-autoregressive flow-matching baseline and the official challenge general linear model baseline in predicting short-term parcel-wise blood oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) activity, demonstrating improved generalization and widespread cortical prediction performance. Ablation analyses show that access to past BOLD dynamics is a dominant driver of performance, while autoregressive factorization yields consistent, modest gains under short-horizon, context-rich conditions. Together, these findings position autoregressive flow-based generative modeling as an effective approach for short-term probabilistic forecasting of neural dynamics with promising applications in closed-loop neurotechnology.
Jul 24, 2025

A Multimodal Sequence-to-Sequence Model for Cross-Subject Prediction of Brain Responses to Naturalistic Stimuli

Brain encoding models predict time-resolved neural activity from computational representations of ongoing experience, providing a principled framework for testing how information is represented and transformed across cortical systems. Naturalistic audiovisual narratives are a particularly rich but challenging testbed for these models, requiring integration of multimodal inputs over long temporal horizons and generalization across individuals with substantial response variability. We introduce a multimodal sequence-to-sequence Transformer with a hybrid cross-subject parameterization that predicts cortex-wide parcel-wise fMRI time series autoregressively from visual, audio, language, and vision--language representations. We evaluate the approach on data from the Courtois NeuroMod project, where four deeply-sampled participants viewed six seasons of Friends and four feature-length films during fMRI. Sequence-to-sequence temporal modeling yields consistent improvements over single-frame prediction across cortical networks, with gains extending to novel stimuli. A hybrid architecture that pairs a shared stimulus encoder with lightweight subject-specific decoder components outperforms both fully shared and fully individual models, indicating complementary advantages of learning shared stimulus representations across subjects and fitting individual neural readouts. Finally, we show that in data-scarce settings, hybrid models can be personalized to new individuals with limited fMRI data, demonstrating that multi-subject pretraining serves as a strong inductive prior for building individual-specific encoding models. Together, these results indicate that combining multimodal sequence modeling with a hybrid cross-subject architecture offers a scalable framework for personalized brain encoding under naturalistic conditions.
Sep 28, 2026

Natural Image Autoencoder-Based fMRI Representations for Trait and State Prediction

Foundation models pre-trained on large-scale fMRI datasets have shown strong downstream performance, but at substantial data and computation cost. To investigate how much fMRI-specific pre-training is actually needed for such performance, we introduce FReD, which derives fMRI representations from a frozen Deep Compression AutoEncoder (DCAE) pre-trained exclusively on natural images and pairs them with a task specific readout. For trait prediction, FReD summarizes frame-wise representations by their temporal mean and log-standard deviation and applies linear probing, with late fusion across two normalization schemes. For state prediction, it represents each frame as a single token and models temporal dependencies with a shallow Transformer. Across four resting-state datasets spanning six trait-prediction targets, linear probes on frozen DCAE features generally outperform those on fMRI foundation model representations and remain competitive with fully fine-tuned fMRI foundation models. On three task-fMRI state-prediction tasks, a temporal readout on DCAE features performs comparably to the strongest foundation models evaluated. A Gaussian injection analysis further shows that localized signal changes are recovered more accurately from the frozen DCAE features than from the evaluated foundation-model representations. Together, these results show that strong performance on current fMRI benchmarks is possible without fMRI-specific representation pre-training, making frozen natural-image features as a useful baseline for assessing its added value.