EnzymeRSI: A dual-loop recursive self-improvement system for enzyme design
Organizations: Genoria AI, Shenzhen 518083, China
Abstract
Enzyme engineering usually optimises which candidates to assay within a fixed model and workflow; when the bottleneck is a mismatched method or a failing workflow, that route is hard to escape. We present EnzymeRSI, a dual-loop system for recursive self-improvement (RSI). The outer loop evolves harness assets without changing model weights; the inner loop develops prediction and selection algorithms under controlled conditions; a cloud laboratory system is specified for closing the physical loop with quality-controlled feedback. The outer loop raised the mean development-set Spearman correlation on ProteinGym by 0.044 across five assays, reaching 0.335 on CD19 and 0.683 on OPSD (rhodopsin); of the two first places, only CD19 was produced by the outer loop itself. In ThermoMPNN self-improvement the inner loop reached a PCC of 0.849, and on TadA-Bench a Spearman correlation of 0.307 in 1.13 h. We examined the system's experimental decision-making in three enzyme systems. For the luciferase RLuc, 10 of the 32 nominated substitutions not pre-specified reached at least twice wild-type activity in a single round. For the cytidine deaminase A3A, a variant selected by a rule that caps loss of unmodified C raised 5mC conversion in the weaker CT context from 11.4% to 46.5% and reversed the substrate preference in both contexts. For the DNA polymerase KOD-E, 189 single-substitution variants defined a landscape on which different objective functions selected divergent next steps from the same parent; one assayed combination reached 31.1 times the parent on a modified substrate. By treating the organisation of research and the development of algorithms as separately scored objects of evolution, and linking a frozen decision record to a physical measurement, this work offers an evolutionary paradigm for moving beyond the blind spots of a fixed method and for autonomous enzyme engineering.
Figures & tables
| Reference strategy | Equal weight per group (21 groups) | Equal weight per environment (93 env.) |
|---|---|---|
| GP-BO | 0.6308 | 0.7388 |
| FolDE-style (reimplementation) | 0.6235 | 0.6684 |
| Static ESM2 | 0.6082 | 0.6782 |
| Linear ridge | 0.6063 | 0.7235 |
| Random | 0.5755 | 0.5669 |
| Framework | Native outer-loop round | Done/target | Scored (valid) | Best DEV PCC | ΔPCC | Final state |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| OpenRSI | native generation | 20/20 | 41 (40) | 0.834438 | +0.030080 | normal native return |
| AReaL-RSI | proposal experiment | 20/20 | 20 (20) | 0.831964 | +0.027606 | 20 completed; controller out of memory at wrap-up |
| AgenticEvolve | formal submission (2 islands) | 20/20 | 20 (19) | 0.823430 | +0.019072 | normal native return |
| ShinkaEvolve | native completions | 25/25 | 25 (24) | 0.813336 | +0.008979 | quota completed |
| MLEvolve | step attempt | 20/20 | 20 (15) | 0.812658 | +0.008301 | normal native return |
| RD-Agent | R&D loop | 25/25 | 69 (69) | 0.811239 | +0.006881 | native return (across a recovery) |
| Run | Task | Primary metric | Done/target | Valid evals | Best DEV | Wall clock (h) | Eval. index of first best |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unmodified | ThermoMPNN | PCC | 20/20 | 20 | 0.839677 | 1.60 | 20 |
| EnzymeRSI | ThermoMPNN | PCC | 20/20 | 19 | 0.849462 | 2.54 | 20 |
| Unmodified | TadA amino-acid view | Spearman | 20/20 | 20 | 0.300716 | 2.24 | 18 |
| EnzymeRSI | TadA amino-acid view | Spearman | 20/20 | 20 | 0.306826 | 1.13 | 20 |
| Class | Capability | Function | Quota |
|---|---|---|---|
| Execution enhancement | Long background job | Training is submitted as an independent process group and is not bound by the 600 s limit on foreground commands; the agent polls the status and the tail of the log | Not consumed |
| Execution enhancement | Structured execution failure | Returns the exception type, the stage at which it failed and a one-line diagnosis, in place of an opaque transport error | Not consumed |
| Cross-framework integration | Research state query | Returns, from the signed host record, the current best, the full submission history including prediction hashes, the reasons for failure and the number of evaluations remaining | Not consumed |
| Cross-framework integration | Repeated-prediction pre-check | Returns a submission whose prediction vector is identical to an earlier one, and identifies the duplicated submission | Returns are not counted |
| Cross-framework integration | Delivery-manifest pre-check | Checks the submission list against the final packaging rules and returns it immediately if it does not comply | Returns are not counted |
| Enzyme system | Measurement source | Steps EnzymeRSI performed | Evidence type | Main result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RLuc | Luminescence measured through the cloud-laboratory workflow this round (a single round; initial screen plus the measurement of three independent preparations) | Nominated 40 single substitutions before measurement and froze the design record and evidence grading | Prospective | 10 of the 32 candidates not pre-specified reached 2 WT; all three inference-only candidates exceeded WT (2.30, 1.98 and 2.43 ), of which 2 reached at least 2 ; design rank was weakly correlated with measured rank ( ρ = 0.175) |
| A3A | Dual-substrate conversion measured through the cloud-laboratory workflow for the variants nominated by EnzymeRSI (78 variants, 75 with complete pairs) | Generated the dual-context filtering and ranking rule and selected variants; analysed the measured results and performed structural analysis against 5KEG | Derived from measured variants | The selected variant changed between Y130Q, K47T and Y132C as the C limit was varied; Y130Q reversed the preference in both contexts; Tyr130 lies 3.66 Å from the target C5 |
| KOD-E | Cy3-dATP incorporation efficiency measured through the cloud-laboratory workflow for 189 single-substitution variants | Paired parents with descendants, compared paths under two objectives and analysed epistasis; structural analysis was completed without access to activity values | Derived from measured variants | 125 single-step comparisons; a different objective gives a different next step; a reversal of rank appears at 676/680, where Ser minus His moves from to |
| Evaluation tier | Primary output | Corresponding decision |
|---|---|---|
| Protein performance | Target activity, stability, selectivity and expression; difference relative to the reference and between replicates | Candidate priority, constraint satisfaction, next round of experiments |
| Algorithmic capability | Spearman correlation and PCC, top- k hits, calibration, query curve, constraint violations | Method adoption, category of applicability, further development |
| System execution | Rate of valid completion, fault recovery, cost, latency, version and evidence integrity | Harness adoption, improvements to scheduling and workflow |
| Cross-task effect | Group-level paired gain, differences between independent runs, transfer and negative transfer | Global adoption, scoped retention, rollback |
| Tier | Suite | Size and splits | Conclusions carried | Boundary not to be crossed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A Static task | evolution-v1 | 217 assays mapped to 101 groups; the outer loop takes one assay from each of five classes of measurement and self-evolves assay by assay, for 196 rounds in total | The five endpoints ranked alongside the 97 published models of the official ProteinGym record; the task base for H0/H1 paired comparison | Self-improvement assay by assay does not demonstrate generalisation across assays; formal attribution still requires the same algorithm assets, base model, environment and budget, together with traceable version changes and adoption records |
| A Budget replay | evolution-replay-v1 | 133 environments; 88 development, 5 validation, 40 test (36 ProteinGym and 4 FLIP2); 16 queries 10 rounds 5 seeds | Quality of sequential decisions and query efficiency for the five reference strategies (Appendix A.3); no system arm is reported on this tier in the present work | Selecting candidates over several rounds does not by itself constitute algorithm RSI, which requires evidence of a persistent change in the method artefact together with an equal-budget HPO control |
| B Real-time extrapolation | TadA-Bench | 31 rounds of PANCE; training rounds 1–27, validation round 28, test rounds 29–31 (sealed) | The ability to extrapolate the next round from past experiments | The DNA, RNA and amino-acid views come from the same experimental source and may not be counted as three independent campaigns; the data must never be re-split at random |
| B-mini Closed-loop campaign | external-campaign-v1 | AtHMT, YmPhytase and MjTyrRS; 1,321 assayed variants; 5, 4 and 4 rounds; the final round sealed | Ranking the next-round candidates that the authors actually selected | This may not be read as discovering candidates in an unconstrained design space; it serves as supplementary evidence only |
| B Supplementary | external-pance-v1 | POGO-PANCE single lineage R2_P1-2; 569 genotypes, 22 hotspots, 3 cycles; the final cycle sealed | Cycle-level prediction of the selection outcome of the next round | A selection outcome measured as pool frequency is not equivalent to the activity of the purified enzyme; a single lineage serves as supplementary evidence only |
| C External transfer | external-mavedb-v1 | 12 assays in 12 groups; 105,783 variants in the cumulative metadata | Analysis of transfer across proteins | Being a different protein from those in ProteinGym does not by itself imply the absence of homology, the absence of exposure during pre-training, or generalisation to an entirely new task |
Recursive Self-Improvement
Recursive self-improvement studies AI systems that use feedback from their own work to modify and evaluate future versions.
See all 107 papers