Adapting LLM Judges to Observed Human Annotation Policy through Soft Prompt Tuning
Organizations: Hochschule für Technik und Wirtschaft Dresden · Otto Group one.O
Abstract
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly employed as automated judges for evaluating chatbot responses. While proprietary models can achieve high agreement with human annotators, they remain costly and difficult to deploy in practical settings. Lightweight open-source LLM judges provide an attractive alternative but typically exhibit lower agreement with human ratings. In this paper, we investigate whether soft prompt tuning can align open-source LLM judges more closely with human annotation policy. We train soft prompts on the FairBotBench benchmark and evaluate the adapted judges across the dimensions of bias, toxicity, and personalization. Our findings demonstrate that hybrid soft-prompt tuning, which combines textual prompts with learned continuous prompt embeddings, consistently improves agreement with human annotations over the corresponding untuned baselines. For Qwen 3.5 9B, the adapted judges surpass both hosted reference judges across all three evaluation dimensions.
Figures & tables
| Condition | Models | VT state | Task representation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foundation–Standard | All local | None | Standard Rubric |
| Foundation–Guideline | All local | None | Annotation guideline |
| Hybrid SPT | All local | Trained | Standard Rubric + VT |
| VT-only SPT | Qwen 9B, Llama 8B | Trained | Virtual tokens only |
| Untrained VT | All local | Untrained | Standard Rubric + VT |
| Hosted reference | 2 GPT | None | Standard Rubric |
| Condition | Models | Seeds | Variants |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hybrid SPT | All four | 42–44 | Random-init / text-init |
| VT-only SPT | Qwen 9B, Llama 8B | 42–44 | Random-init |
| Untrained VT | All four | 42–51 | Default / norm-matched |
LLM-as-a-Judge
Large language model (LLM)-as-a-judge research uses language models to score, compare, and verify AI outputs as scalable alternatives to human evaluation.
See all 603 papers