Organizations: Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, University of California, Los Angeles, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA · Department of Urban Planning, Tsinghua University, Beijing 100084, China · Department of Urban Planning and Design, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Road, Hong Kong SAR, China · College of Urban and Environmental Sciences, Peking University, Beijing 100871, China · Department of Urban and Regional Planning, University of Florida, Gainesville, FL 32611, USA · Department of Urban Studies and Planning, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA
Transit-Oriented Development (TOD) is a key strategy for advancing sustainable urban development by promoting high-density, mixed-use land development within walking distance of public transit stations. However, traditional TOD planning often relies on heuristic methods, making it difficult to efficiently identify quantitatively optimized transit-oriented land use patterns. This paper presents DRL4TOD, a deep reinforcement learning framework that automatically optimizes land use types and floor area ratios (FARs) around transit stations in alignment with TOD principles. DRL4TOD incorporates a graph neural network to capture spatial interdependencies among land parcels, road networks, and metro stations, and uses a DRL-based optimization strategy to assign land-use types and FARs to selected parcels. It jointly optimizes multiple objectives, including land use density, land use diversity, and transit capacity utilization, while minimizing reconstruction costs to account for development feasibility. Applied to two real-world station areas in Shanghai, DRL4TOD consistently outperforms rule-based approaches and genetic algorithms, achieving more effective TOD outcomes with lower reconstruction costs. By adjusting objective weights, the framework enables flexible prioritization, such as placing greater emphasis on cost minimization when financial feasibility is a concern. These results demonstrate DRL4TOD's potential as a decision-support tool for generating coordinated land-use and FAR configurations under planner-specified priorities, rather than prescribing a single fixed design. For policymakers, the framework provides parcel-level, constraint-aware alternatives that make trade-offs among competing objectives explicit and support targeted decisions about development intensity and feasibility.
Figure 2: Overview of the proposed DRL4TOD framework
Figure 3: Graph construction from spatial layout in the TOD planning context
Figure 4: Illustration of MDP transitions with spatial and graph representations
Figure 5: Spatial layouts and functional zoning of the two selected case study communities: (a) Community 01—Xintiandi Station (central urban context) and (b) Community 02—Jinjing Road Station (suburban context). Colors indicate functional land-use categories.
Land-Use Type
Maximum FAR
Hospital & Clinic
1.5
School
1.2
Recreation
2.0
Residential
2.5
Park & Open Space
0.0
Office
4.0
Table 1: Maximum allowable floor area ratio by land-use type
Station
Model
Metrics
Total Reward
LUDE
LUDI
TCU
DF
Xintiandi
Initial Plan
0.1757
0.1732
0.7858
0.1993
-
RBCP
0.2521
0.2251
0.7018
0.1728
0.3064
RBDP
0.1886
0.0753
0.7071
0.1697
0.3658
SA
0.4507
0.5751
0.8333
0.1680
0.3975
PSO
0.4542
0.6122
0.7027
0.2172
0.2935
Table 2: Quantitative performance comparison of DRL4TOD and baseline methods across two metro stations. Best results for each station are bold-underlined, and ∗ / ∗∗ denote statistical significance at p<0.1 and p<0.05 , respectively.
Figure 6: 3D FAR distribution under different planning methods at Xintiandi Station. Taller blocks represent higher FAR values.
Figure 7: 2D land use allocation patterns for Xintiandi Station under different planning methods.
Model Variant
Performance Metrics
Total Reward
LUDE
LUDI
TCU
DF
Without Metro Station Data
0.5232
0.6939
0.8365
0.2100
0.4096
MLP State Encoder
0.7984
1.3011
0.8106
0.2132
0.2701
DRL4TOD (Full Model)
1.0371
1.6965
0.8385
0.2272
0.4505
Table 3: Ablation study: performance comparison on Xintiandi Station
Figure 8: 3D visualization of the ablation study results
Figure 9: 2D visualization of the ablation study results
LUDE
LUDI
TCU
DF
Residential
Business
Office
Weight
Baseline
0.0825
0.1675
0.25
0.05
0.25
0.2
Modified LUDE
0.4050
0.0450
0.05
0.05
0.25
0.2
Value
Baseline
0.0141
0.0726
3.3397
0.8385
0.2272
0.4505
Modified LUDE
0.0452
0.0890
0.7655
0.8080
0.2653
0.3711
Table 4: Effect of residential density weight on performance metrics. The adjusted weight and its corresponding score are bold-underlined.
Figure 10: 3D spatial planning outcomes under varying TOD objective weights.
Figure 11: 2D spatial planning outcomes under varying TOD objective weights.
LUDE
LUDI
TCU
DF
Weight
Baseline
0.5
0.05
0.25
0.2
Modified LUDI
0.05
0.8
0.05
0.1
Modified TCU
0.1
0.05
0.8
0.05
Modified DF
0.1
0.05
0.05
0.8
Value
Baseline
1.6965
0.8385
0.2272
0.4505
Modified LUDI
0.3022
0.9415
0.2013
0.4876
Table 5: Effect of LUDI, TCU, and DF weights on planning performance. The adjusted weights and corresponding scores are bold-underlined.
Figure 12: 3D spatial planning outcomes under development feasibility weight adjustment. Hatched parcels indicate preserved areas.
Figure 13: 2D spatial planning outcomes under development feasibility weight adjustment. Hatched parcels indicate preserved areas.
Station
Model
Metrics
Total Reward
LUDE
LUDI
TCU
DF
Xintiandi
Weight
–
0.23
0.27
0.22
0.28
AGA
0.3865
0.1310
0.7253
0.1716
0.4386
DRL4TOD
0.4349 ∗∗
0.2232 ∗∗
0.8022 ∗∗
0.1859 ∗∗
0.4503 ∗∗
Jinjing Road
Weight
–
0.22
0.30
0.24
0.24
AGA
0.3354
0.2158
0.6154
0.1680
0.2623
Table 6: Performance of AGA and DRL4TOD under expert-elicited objective weights.
Appendix figures & tables4 assets
Supplementary material from the paper’s appendix.
Appendix
Figure 14: XGBoost feature importance for the station-level ridership model.
Hyperparameter
Value
Metrics
Total Reward
LUDE
LUDI
TCU
DF
PPO learning rate
1×10−4
0.7756
1.1848
0.8217
0.2107
0.4472
4×10−4
1.0371
1.6965
0.8385
0.2272
0.4505
1×10−3
0.9548
1.5478
0.8142
0.2121
0.4359
GNN layers
1
0.6946
1.0332
0.8082
0.2098
0.4258
2
1.0371
1.6965
0.8385
0.2272
0.4505
Appendix
Table 7: Sensitivity of DRL4TOD performance to the PPO learning rate and GNN message-passing depth at Xintiandi Station. Values are means over five independent runs. In each block, only the listed parameter is varied; all other settings remain fixed. Bold and underlining identify the reference configuration.
Model Variant
Performance Metrics
Total Reward
LUDE
LUDI
TCU
DF
Initial Plan
0.1757
0.1732
0.7858
0.1993
-
DRL4TOD
1.0371
1.6965
0.8385
0.2272
0.4505
Preservation-Constrained Scenario
0.6889
1.0002
0.7313
0.2598
0.4362
Appendix
Table 8: Performance comparison under heritage-preservation constraints at Xintiandi Station.
Figure 15: 3D visualization of the preservation-constrained scenario at Xintiandi Station: (a) initial planning configuration and (b) preservation-constrained configuration. Solid outlines in both panels indicate the parcels fixed in the preservation-constrained scenario.
Urban planning uses geospatial data, machine learning, and optimization to analyze cities and guide transport, land use, housing, and climate decisions.
Dept. of Civil, Environmental and Infrastructure Engineering George Mason University Fairfax, VA, USA · Dept. of Sustainability University of South Dakota Vermillion, SD, USA · School of Information Studies Syracuse University Syracuse, NY, USA +2