Physics-based control is central to robot learning, but differentiating through implicit physics steps typically requires Hessian or Karush--Kuhn--Tucker (KKT) linear solves; we ask whether gradient steps suffice. Each simulation step minimizes an energy under many contact and collision constraints. Without constraints, we view control over
K steps as
K-level optimization with strongly convex lower levels, recast as one min--max problem. Our Penalized Single-loop
K-level method (PSK) uses only gradients and a projection, updates all levels in parallel, and reaches an
ε-stationary control in
O(ε−3) iterations, with a
K-independent exponent but a
K-dependent constant. Contact-rich constraints, however, typically violate a constraint qualification (CQ). We replace each constraint by a smooth wall that acts on a band of constant width. Under mild assumptions that need no CQ, every exact solution of the banded lower levels is then feasible and banded Fritz--John, and PSK keeps the
O(ε−3) complexity. Without a CQ that is uniform in the band width, however, a shrinking band loses the
K-independent exponent: with width
ε and fixed
K≥2, deterministic zero-respecting methods need
Ω(ε−(K+3)/4) calls on a hard instance whose control dimension grows with
1/ε. We prove our assumptions for smoothed kinematic and dynamic multi-robot navigation among segment obstacles. In navigation experiments, PSK, tuned per case, reaches every goal with sixteen levels and, at equal time, reaches a lower loss than tuned unrolling in 17 of 18 cases, while implicit differentiation is lower in 10.